You will be able to confirm or reject a claim by finding it in the source yourself. Asking the assistant a second time does not count as checking.
When you ask an AI assistant about a fund or a REIT, it usually answers in tidy, assured sentences. That tells you nothing about whether the number is right. The figure may be stale, it may have been pulled from the wrong part of a report, or it may be made up. Any figure that comes from an assistant needs checking before you buy, sell or decide anything because of it. The rule is that a claim counts only once you have found it yourself, in the source, along with a date. Asking the assistant again does not verify anything, whatever wording you use.
Start by asking the assistant two things about each claim: which document it would have come from, and what date that document would carry. Even a reply that is partly wrong helps, because it tells you what type of document to look for, such as an annual report or a results announcement. Don't trust the specifics, though. Lesson 1.3, "Where it fails: invented numbers, old facts, wrong country", showed that an assistant can cite a source that does not exist. Any title, page number or link it gives you is a lead to chase. It stays a lead until you have seen the thing yourself.
Next, go to the source and look. For a REIT you will normally use three places: the investor relations page on its website, its latest annual report, and its most recent results announcement on SGX. Find the page, then find the figure on it and read it yourself. Don't paste the document into the chat and ask the assistant whether the number appears there. That breaks the rule, because the assistant is still the one giving the answer.
Once you have looked, each claim goes into one of three groups:
Confirmed means you can put your finger on the sentence or number in the document, and you know which date it describes. Rejected means you found the figure and it differs, or something in the source contradicts the claim. Unconfirmed means the claim is nowhere to be found. That does not make it wrong, but it does not count and you cannot act on it.
For every confirmed claim, write down three details: the document, the page and the as-of date. The as-of date is the date the figure applies to. It is a different thing from the date the document came out, and the publication date on its own will mislead you. Take an annual report released in March (an illustrative example). It covers a financial year that closed months before, so every figure in it shows the business as it was at that earlier point.
Figures change at very different speeds. The properties a REIT owns may stay the same for years. Its gearing, meaning the share of its assets paid for with debt, shifts whenever it takes on loans, pays them down or has its buildings revalued, and it is published a few times a year. For a fund, the fees are rarely changed, while the holdings change all the time.
Yield moves whenever the price does, since yield is the payout divided by the price. No single yield figure is the correct one. The answer depends on which payouts you include and which day's price you divide by. A yield from an assistant is therefore based on a price from some day it has no way of telling you. The source can tell you what the REIT paid out over a period, and from that you work out the yield yourself at today's price in a spreadsheet. Module 5 shows you how to do this.
As you check each figure, write down whether it is the kind that moves. For a figure that moves, the as-of date is part of the fact, and you should look for a more recent number. A fee with no date attached is acceptable. A yield or a holding with no date is only half a fact. Watch too for a figure that is "true once, now out of date". It agrees with an older source, but a newer source gives a different number.
You met Farhan in lesson 4.1, "Ask AI for questions, not a verdict", where he asked an assistant about a REIT he was considering. It gave him three claims. The yield was a little over six percent, gearing was in the mid-thirties as a percentage, and the largest tenant made up under a tenth of rental income (all invented example figures). From earlier learning he knew where each of these is published, so he opened the REIT's investor relations page, its latest annual report and its most recent results announcement on SGX.
On gearing, the annual report matched the assistant almost exactly. That figure was as at the end of the previous financial year, though, and the latest results announcement gave a higher one. Farhan labelled the claim "true once, now out of date" and wrote down the newer number. The largest tenant's share matched the annual report at the same date, so he marked it confirmed. He could not confirm the yield at all, because it depends on the price and on which payout period is used.
Summarising long documents is a good job to give an assistant. An annual report can run past two hundred pages, and a summary of a section such as the risk factors or the debt position saves you a lot of reading. Lesson 5.4 of the Working with AI assistants course, "Build a checked summary of a long report", teaches the method. Even when you uploaded the document yourself, what comes back is still a summary, and figures can go wrong in it.
Spot-check a summary before you rely on it. Choose three figures from it and look each one up on the page it should have come from. If all three agree, you can use the summary with reasonable confidence. If even one disagrees, either check every figure in the summary or go back to the section and read it yourself.
Farhan did this with a summary he asked for of the capital management section of the annual report. He checked three figures, and two matched. The third was the average cost of the REIT's debt. The assistant had taken it from the previous year's comparison column when it should have used the current year's. Taking a number from the right table but the wrong column is a common slip, and it is easy to miss.
Now take three claims an assistant made about the investment you chose, and run each one through the same check.
Pick three claims an assistant made about your investment. For each one, write down the source, the page, the date and whether the claim held up.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).