You will be able to explain how an assistant can describe a calculation correctly and still give the wrong answer.
Before you type a money question into an AI assistant, open an empty spreadsheet and put it next to the chat. An assistant usually explains a calculation well, but it is far less dependable when it has to carry the calculation out. The spreadsheet gives you a place to test whatever figure it gives you.
Lesson 1.1, "What an assistant is actually doing when you ask about money", showed that a language model produces digits by predicting what comes next, exactly as it produces words. If the model has not actually run code to work out the sum, the number you see is its prediction of what usually sits in that position.
Describing a concept, for instance the way compounding works, is a job for language. Models handle it well because their training includes thousands of sound explanations. Getting an exact answer out of several linked steps is arithmetic, and predicting is a weak stand-in for doing arithmetic. An assistant can set out the right method and then work the numbers using a different one.
One-step sums tend to be fine. If you ask for 15% of S$2,000, you will nearly always be told S$300 (an invented example). Trouble starts when a sum has several steps and each relies on the result of the last.
Compound growth is growth in which the interest for each period depends on the balance left by every period before it. Amortisation is a loan repayment schedule where the interest each month depends on what is still owed, and what is still owed depends on every payment made so far. Be careful with both of these, and also with comparisons that take off an annual fee every year, adjustments for inflation across many years, and any sum that relies on a monthly rate derived from a yearly one.
When steps are chained, a minor mistake near the start is carried all the way to the final figure. The model will not spot it, since it is not reviewing its working; it is producing whatever next line seems likely.
Certain assistants can write code, run it, and display both the code and what it produced. A number that came out of running code deserves much more trust than one predicted in a paragraph, since the computer did the arithmetic. The difficulty is that you often cannot see which of these happened. One assistant shows the code block and its output on screen. Another runs code out of sight and simply says it did. A third writes prose laid out like working that was never executed. Working with AI assistants, lesson 7.3, "Checking numbers, quotes, sources and code", explains why you so often cannot tell.
Work to one rule: if no calculation is visible behind a figure, count it as a guess. Handle it the way you would a number a stranger jotted on a napkin and passed to you. It could be correct, but you should not rely on it until you have checked it yourself.
You can still use assistants for money questions. The change is in where the arithmetic gets done.
Joanne (an invented example) wants to know what she will end up with if she pays S$300 a month for twenty years into an account that pays 4% a year, compounded monthly. Compounded monthly means the interest is added to her balance each month, and the next month's interest is worked out on that larger balance. The assistant gives her a clear and accurate explanation of compound interest and points out that regular saving builds up. It also tells her that her own deposits come to S$72,000 (S$300 x 240 months), and that she will finish with about S$157,800.
The explanation holds up, but the final figure is too high by nearly S$48,000. In effect, the assistant treated all S$72,000 as if it had been paid in on the first day and left to grow for twenty years at 4%, compounded once a year. Her real balance would be S$110,032.39 with deposits made at the end of each month, or S$110,399.16 with deposits made at the start. Both figures assume the 4% holds for all twenty years. If the rate drops or she misses deposits, she ends with less, and money put into investments instead of a savings account can also fall in value.
For any sum with several steps, ask the assistant for the formula and leave the final answer out. Copy that formula into your spreadsheet, give each input its own visible cell, and run it yourself, so every step is open to checking. How money works, lesson 2.4, "Build a compounding table in a spreadsheet", used this method for a lump sum, and lesson 5.2, "Ask for the formula, then run it yourself", applies it to loans and regular savings.
Regular savings call for the FV function, a spreadsheet function that works out future value from a periodic rate, a number of periods and a payment amount. Future value is what the money will be worth at the end. The periodic rate is the interest rate for one period, here one month. Joanne's periodic rate is 4% divided by 12. Her number of periods is 240, which is 20 years x 12. Her payment is S$300. FV also asks whether payments fall at the end or the start of each period. With end-of-month deposits it gives S$110,032.39, and with start-of-month deposits it gives S$110,399.16. The second figure is a little larger because every deposit gets one extra month of growth.
When a result seems off, change a single input and see which figures move. Because each input sits in its own cell, you can quickly see which one is responsible.
Finish with a rough estimate. Add up the total deposits, assume that money is invested for roughly half the term, and apply the stated rate. Half the term is a fair assumption with monthly deposits. The first payment grows for the whole term, the last grows for a single month, and on average the money is invested for about half of it.
Joanne's S$72,000 at 4% for about ten years comes to somewhere between S$105,000 and S$110,000. That is close to the spreadsheet result and nowhere near S$158,000. Put your estimate next to both the spreadsheet figure and the assistant's figure. The whole check takes about ten seconds, and it would have caught the assistant's wrong figure. Lesson 5.3, "Sanity-check results with a rough estimate", goes through the method in full.
Choose a savings question of your own, with your own amount, rate and number of years. Open a blank spreadsheet beside the chat before you ask the assistant.
Ask an assistant a compound interest question in plain words. Then work it out yourself in a spreadsheet and compare the two answers.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).