A headline has one job: get the next line read

You will be able to judge a headline by whether it makes your target reader want to keep reading.

A headline only has to do one thing: get its next line read. The selling, the full story and any impressive vocabulary can wait for the rest of the page. What the headline must do is give the right reader a reason to think "this is about me" or "I want that", and carry on.

Think about how you go through search results, your inbox or a social feed. You read a few words of each item and decide on the spot whether to open it or keep going, and most of the items you pass never get read beyond the first line. People treat what you write in the same way. Your headline gets a second or two of their attention, and when it fails to show them the piece is meant for them, nothing you wrote underneath gets read.

Writing a headline that makes sense alone

A lot of readers never get past the headline, so it has to carry its meaning with nothing else around it. Picture a tuition centre choosing between "Small group maths for P5 and P6, Saturday mornings" and "Where learning comes alive". Someone who sees only the first knows who the class is for and what is on offer. Someone who sees only the second learns nothing and has no reason to look further.

To check your own, try the cover test. Hide everything on the page apart from the headline, show it to a stranger, and ask them what the page is about and who it is for. If they can't answer, you have written decoration, a headline that may look nice and still fails at its job. Rewrite it.

Headlines that stand alone tend to name at least one of three things: the reader, the problem or the result. You name the reader with something like "for parents of P5 children", the problem with "when your child goes blank in exams", and the result with "check her own working before she hands it in". The voice-of-customer file you built in lesson 1.4 has plenty of all three to draw from.

Picking specific words over clever ones

Many business owners enjoy puns and wordplay, such as "Maths-ter your exams." or "Cake my day." They are enjoyable to come up with. The trouble is that a pun asks the reader to do some work before they can tell whether the piece concerns them, and most readers will skip that work and scroll on. A specific headline lets them decide at once, so it gets read more often.

Mei Ling, the home baker in Punggol you met in the Digital marketing foundations course, has two options. "Let them eat cake" is clever and could go above any bakery anywhere in the world. "Custom birthday cakes from Punggol, order by Wednesday for the weekend" lets a parent in the north-east see straight away whether they can have a cake ready for Saturday's party. The second is the one that gets the right person to keep reading.

Being specific has nothing to do with length. A specific headline uses words that point at something real, such as a person, a situation, a number, a place or a time.

Keeping the promise the headline makes

Whatever your headline says, the page has to back up. Overpromise and you may get the click, then lose the reader one line later. A post headed "Three ways to calm exam nerves" needs three ways in it, placed near the top.

Priya runs an ad offering a "Free trial lesson this Saturday". The page behind the ad begins with a paragraph about Priya's teaching philosophy. The parent who clicked wanted the trial lesson, feels misled, and leaves the page.

Politeness is only part of the reason to deliver. Every time readers find a headline has overpromised, they give the next one they see a little less trust. Across a year, a somewhat duller headline that the page lives up to completely will bring you more readers than an exciting one that lets them down. Certain overpromises are also against the rules, and module 3 deals with those.

Fitting the headline to how aware the reader is

In the book Breakthrough Advertising, the copywriter Eugene Schwartz argued that the right headline depends on how much the reader already knows. Schwartz set out five awareness levels: unaware of the problem, aware of the problem, aware that solutions exist, aware of your product, and most aware, which describes someone ready to buy and waiting for the right offer. There is no need to memorise these names. What matters in practice is that one headline cannot suit every reader.

Consider three parents. One has not yet noticed her son is struggling. Since she isn't searching for tuition, "Small group P5 maths tuition" won't get a response from her, though "Why children who were fine in P4 often struggle in P5" might make her stop, as it describes something she may soon face.

A second parent already knows her son needs help and is comparing group classes with a private tutor. A headline like "Groups of six, so the teacher checks every child's working" speaks to the decision in front of her.

The third has been to the centre already and just needs a reason to book now, so she wants to see the offer: "Free trial lesson on Saturday 10am, two places left this week". To the first parent, those same words would mean nothing.

So begin by deciding where your reader stands: only now noticing the situation, comparing options, or ready to book. Readers early on need a headline about their situation, and readers near the end need one about the offer. Most businesses write headlines for late-stage readers and then show them to early-stage ones, and the headlines get ignored as a result. If you mapped the buyer's journey in Digital marketing foundations, lesson 2.3, "What each stage needs from you", use that map to choose the kind of headline for each stage.

Checking a headline before it goes out

Put yourself in your target reader's place, read the headline, and answer four questions:

Would they know it is for them? Can they tell what they get? Does it point at something real rather than a general quality? Does the page deliver what it promises in the first few lines?

Pass all four and the headline has a fair chance. Fail either of the first two and readers will skip it, no matter how well it is written. A competitor's headline can go through the same questions as your own.

In the activity below you will practise on other people's headlines first, which is easier than judging your own. Pick competitors your customers would actually compare you with, and for each headline you collect, decide which of the reader, the problem or the result your rewrite will name before you start writing it.

Find five headlines on competitors' websites and ads. Rewrite each one so it names a reader, a problem or a result.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).