You will be able to judge a headline by whether it makes the target reader want to read on.
Scroll through a page of search results, an inbox or a social feed and notice what you actually read. A few words of each item, then a decision: open it or move on. Most of what you pass, you never read past the first line. That is how your readers treat your writing too. They give the headline a second or two, and if it does not tell them the piece is for them, the rest of your work goes unread.
So a headline has one job. It has to get the next line read. It does not need to sell the product, tell the whole story or show off your vocabulary. It needs to make the right reader think "this is about me" or "I want that" and keep going.
Because so many readers stop at the headline, it has to work alone. Someone who reads only "Small group maths for P5 and P6, Saturday mornings" knows who it is for and what it is, even if they never scroll. Someone who reads only "Where learning comes alive" knows nothing, and has no reason to find out.
A useful test: cover everything except the headline and ask a stranger what the page is about and who it is for. If they cannot say, the headline is decoration. It may look nice, and it is not doing the job.
A headline that works alone usually names at least one of three things: the reader ("for parents of P5 children"), the problem ("when your child goes blank in exams") or the result ("check her own working before she hands it in"). Your voice-of-customer file from lesson 1.4 is full of all three.
Business owners love puns and wordplay. "Maths-ter your exams." "Cake my day." They are fun to write and they make the reader do work before they know whether the piece is relevant. Most readers will not do that work.
Specific headlines win because they let the reader decide instantly. Compare two headlines for Mei Ling, the home baker in Punggol you may remember from Digital marketing foundations. "Let them eat cake" is clever and could sit above any bakery in the world. "Custom birthday cakes from Punggol, order by Wednesday for the weekend" tells a parent in the north-east whether she can get a cake for Saturday's party. Only the second one makes the right person read on.
Specific does not mean long. It means the words point at something real: a person, a situation, a number, a place, a time.
A headline that promises more than the page delivers wins the click and then loses the reader on the next line. If Priya's ad says "Free trial lesson this Saturday" and the page opens with a paragraph about her teaching philosophy, the parent who clicked feels misled and leaves. If the headline promises "Three ways to calm exam nerves", the post had better contain three ways, near the top.
This is more than politeness. Every time a reader finds that your headlines overpromise, they trust the next one less. A slightly duller headline that the page fully delivers will earn more readers over a year than an exciting one that disappoints. In module 3 you will also see that some overpromises are against the rules.
The copywriter Eugene Schwartz, in his book Breakthrough Advertising, argued that the right headline depends on how aware the reader already is. He described five awareness levels: unaware of the problem, aware of the problem, aware that solutions exist, aware of your product, and most aware, meaning ready to buy and waiting for the right offer.
You do not need to memorise the names. The practical point is that the same headline cannot work for everyone.
A parent who has not yet noticed that her son is struggling will not respond to "Small group P5 maths tuition". She is not looking for tuition. She might stop for "Why children who were fine in P4 often struggle in P5", because it names a situation she may be about to meet.
A parent who already knows her son needs help and is comparing options wants something different. "Groups of six, so the teacher checks every child's working" speaks to her, because she is weighing group classes against a private tutor.
A parent who has already visited the centre and only needs a reason to book now wants the offer itself: "Free trial lesson on Saturday 10am, two places left this week". That headline would mean nothing to the first parent.
This links to the buyer's journey you may have mapped in Digital marketing foundations, in lesson 2.3, What each stage needs from you. Early-stage readers need a headline about their situation. Late-stage readers need a headline about your offer. Most business headlines are written for late-stage readers and shown to early-stage ones, which is why they are ignored.
Before you publish a headline, read it as your target reader would and ask four questions. Would they know it is for them? Can they tell what they get? Does it point at something real rather than a general quality? Does the page deliver what it promises in the first few lines? A headline that passes all four has a fair chance. One that fails the first two will be skipped, however well written.
In the activity below you will practise on other people's headlines first, which is easier than judging your own. Pick competitors your customers would actually compare you with, and for each headline you collect, decide which of the reader, the problem or the result your rewrite will name before you start writing it.
Collect five headlines from competitors' websites and ads and rewrite each so it names a reader, a problem or a result.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).