Pay the mortgage from CPF or cash: the trade-off

You will be able to compare paying your home loan from CPF with paying it from cash.

Get your latest HDB loan statement and find the line that shows where your monthly instalment is paid from: CPF, your bank account, or both. If you are still house-hunting, write down the instalment you have been quoted. Where that money comes from affects how much cash you hold, how your CPF grows, and how much CPF you must pay back if you sell. No answer is right for everyone, but you can work through the choice in a clear order.

Kelvin and Mei, a young couple buying an HDB flat, met this question at their HDB appointment. The officer asked how they would pay each month. Kelvin said CPF straight away, because that is what everyone does. Mei asked whether they could pay part in cash, and the officer said yes. Then they both realised they didn't know which option was better.

What paying from CPF gives you and what it costs

Your instalment can come from your Ordinary Account (OA), the CPF account that earns a guaranteed CPF interest rate. Paying from the OA leaves your take-home pay untouched. You can put that salary towards an emergency fund, renovation and other savings goals, which helps most when you are young and have just moved in.

Paying from the OA has three costs. First, each instalment drawn from the OA stops earning CPF interest. Second, every dollar you use adds to the refund with accrued interest. This is the OA money spent on your home plus the interest it would have earned, which you owe back to CPF when you sell the flat. Lesson 2.3 walked through how this refund works. Third, if you keep the flat for life, the money you used is missing from your OA at age 55, when OA money moves towards your Retirement Account. You may have less to transfer.

Paying in cash reverses each of these. Your OA keeps growing at the guaranteed rate, and the refund due when you sell is smaller. The cost is the cash itself. It leaves your bank account every month, and money that could have gone to a buffer, a goal or your own investments is tied up in the flat.

You can think of a cash payment as a loan to yourself at the OA rate, repaid when you sell. You can't get at that money while you own the flat, but it earns the CPF rate and carries no market risk. On one side is cash in hand now, for a buffer, a goal or investments that might earn more than the OA rate. On the other is money parked at the OA rate until you sell, or until 55 if you never sell.

Kelvin and Mei's two plans over ten years

Kelvin and Mei's instalment is S$1,800 a month. Under plan A they pay all S$1,800 from CPF. Under plan B they pay S$1,000 from CPF and S$800 from cash. For the comparison, assume an OA rate of 3%, with interest added once a year. This is an example rate, not today's rate.

Over ten years, plan B puts S$800 x 12 x 10 = S$96,000 of their cash into the flat. At the ten-year mark, their OAs hold about S$110,053 more under plan B than under plan A. That is the S$96,000 they never withdrew plus roughly S$14,053 of interest earned on it.

If they sell at ten years, plan B's CPF refund is lower by the same S$110,053, so more of the sale proceeds come back to them as cash. Over the same ten years, though, S$96,000 has left their bank account under plan B, and they couldn't use it for anything else.

Three checks that come before the interest rate

Look at three things before you compare interest rates, in this order: your buffer, your cash goals and your job security.

Start with your buffer. If paying in cash would leave you with no emergency fund, pay from CPF until you have built one. Guaranteed interest is a poor trade if one bad month would push you onto a credit card.

Next, your cash goals. A wedding, a renovation or a baby in the next few years has to be paid for in cash, because CPF can't cover them. It often makes sense to let CPF pay the instalment while you save cash for those goals.

Then your job security. CPF contributions top up your OA only while you are employed. If you are out of work, your OA balance alone has to cover the instalments, and once it runs out you pay in cash anyway. For this reason some owners keep several months of instalments in the OA as a reserve. Paying part of the instalment in cash while you are employed is how that reserve builds up.

Once you have covered these three, weigh the OA rate against what your cash could do elsewhere.

Choosing a split you can change later

Your choice is not permanent. You can pay part of the instalment in cash, and you can change the CPF/cash split later through your lender and the CPF Board. A common pattern is to pay entirely from CPF in the early years, while renovation and wedding costs are still coming in. Once your buffer and goals are covered, you move part of the instalment to cash.

Kelvin and Mei chose this pattern. They will pay entirely from CPF for the first two years. When their emergency fund reaches six months of expenses, they will move S$500 a month to cash. They have put that date in their calendar.

The course "Property & Mortgages: buy a home and manage the loan" covers the same decision from the loan side in lesson 5.4, "Loan tenure, and paying from cash or CPF".

The easy mistake when you set your own split is to look at the OA rate first. Check what the cash part would leave in your emergency fund each month, since a split that drains your buffer fails the first of the three checks.

Write down your monthly instalment, or the one you expect, and note what paying it all from CPF and all from cash would each do to your buffer and your OA. Then choose a split and write the one reason that decides it.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).