Moving OA money to your SA: the one-way trade

Decide whether moving OA savings to your SA suits your plans.

Move OA money to the SA only if you are confident you won't need it for a home or for tuition in the next ten years. The extra interest is real, but the transfer is permanent. Your plans for that decade should settle the question before the interest rate does.

Jun Hao, a colleague of Kelvin's, is 29. Last year he moved S$20,000 from his OA to his SA after a video called it the easiest money he would ever make. This year he got engaged and started looking at flats. He asked Kelvin, half joking, how to move the money back. There is no way to do it, because money in the SA cannot be moved back to the OA. That S$20,000 would have covered a large part of his CPF downpayment. It will now earn interest until he turns 55. The same amount has to come from cash or a larger loan.

What the higher SA interest is worth

An OA-to-SA transfer is a permanent move of money from your Ordinary Account to your Special Account so that it earns the higher SA rate. Lesson 1.2 explained that the SA pays a higher interest rate than the OA. From the day of the transfer, the money earns the SA rate, and over a long period the gap compounds.

Take example rates of 3% for the OA and 5% for the SA. These are invented for the arithmetic and are not the current CPF rates. On S$20,000, the first year earns S$1,000 in the SA against S$600 in the OA, about S$400 more. After ten years, the S$20,000 grows to about S$32,577.89 in the SA and about S$26,878.33 in the OA. At these example rates, the SA balance is about S$5,699.56 higher after the decade. That extra growth carries no market risk.

There may be a second effect. Only part of your OA counts towards extra interest. Moving OA money to the SA can therefore let more of your total balance qualify for extra interest. Whether this applies to you depends on how your balances are spread across your accounts. Check the extra interest rules on cpf.gov.sg against your own balances before you count on it.

What the money can no longer pay for

Money in the SA cannot pay for a home. It cannot pay tuition under the CPF Education Loan Scheme. It cannot be invested under the wider list of OA options in the CPF Investment Scheme. SA money is retirement money. At 55 it moves to your Retirement Account, up to your cohort Full Retirement Sum. Your cohort sum is the one set for the year you turn 55.

Housing is the biggest cost. Money you transfer is not available later for a downpayment or for instalments. You may then have to pay more in cash or take a larger loan.

Education is the second cost. The CPF Education Loan Scheme lets your OA pay tuition for you or certain family members. It covers only approved full-time courses that are subsidised by the Ministry of Education (MOE) and run locally at approved educational institutions. Check with the CPF Board for which courses and family members qualify. It works like a loan from your OA. After the course ends, the student repays the amount used plus interest at the OA rate, in cash. The scheme depends on OA money being available to lend. A transfer therefore reduces what is there for a child's degree or for your own study.

Transfers are also capped at a limit linked to the Full Retirement Sum. Once your SA reaches that limit, you can't move any more. The CPF Board sets the current limit rule and shows your remaining transfer room when you log in. An OA-to-SA transfer earns no tax relief, unlike a cash top-up, which lesson 3.2 covers. At 55 the SA closes, and its savings move to your Retirement Account up to your cohort Full Retirement Sum. After that, moving OA money to the Retirement Account is a separate decision. You make it with your retirement sum in view. Module 6 covers it, and the CPF Board sets the current rules.

Who a transfer usually suits

A transfer suits people who are confident the OA money will not be needed. It rarely suits someone in their twenties or early thirties without a home, because the next ten years are when most people buy one. It can suit someone in their forties with a paid-up flat and an OA that grows every month with nothing to spend it on.

A transfer usually makes sense when all of these are true:

You already own the home you will live in, with enough left in the OA as a reserve for instalments. You have no upgrade planned, or any upgrade will be paid for from the refund of your current home. You don't expect to use your OA for your own or a family member's tuition. You have a cash emergency fund, so your instalments would not rely on the OA after a job loss.

Deciding how much of your own OA to move

Start with the next ten years and leave the interest rate for later. Ask where you will live and whether you will buy or upgrade. Then ask whether anyone is likely to need your OA for study. If every honest answer points away from needing the OA, a transfer makes sense. It lets that money earn the higher SA rate with no market risk. If any answer is unsure, keep the money in the OA, because its flexibility is worth more to you than the extra interest. If you do go ahead, check your remaining transfer room when you log in to CPF. Also check the extra interest rules on cpf.gov.sg.

Kelvin worked through the same questions. Kelvin is about to buy a home with Mei. Kelvin's OA will carry the downpayment and instalments for years. The answer for now is no transfer. Kelvin wrote down the conditions for reconsidering: the flat bought, six months of instalments held in the OA as a reserve, and no upgrade planned within ten years.

Working through your own plans takes about ten minutes with your CPF login open. It is worth doing before any money moves, because a transfer cannot be undone.

Write down your housing plans for the next ten years, including any upgrade, and any tuition your OA might fund. Then look at your OA balance and decide how much of it, if any, could move to the SA without touching those plans.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).