Compare the three CPF LIFE plans on starting payout, growth and bequest.
Choose a CPF LIFE plan by asking three things: how much income you need in the first years, how worried you are about rising prices and a long life, and how much you want to leave behind. All three plans, Standard, Basic and Escalating, pay you every month for as long as you live. They differ in the size of the first payout, how the payout moves over the years, and the amount that goes to your beneficiaries.
Linda, an invented example of someone close to retirement, once asked her sister which plan she was on. Her sister had no memory of picking one. She had never chosen, so she was placed on the default Standard Plan and had not checked it since. The plan happened to fit her, but she had no idea a choice existed or how the other two plans would have treated her.
The Standard Plan gives you the same monthly sum for life. It is the default, so anyone who does not pick a plan ends up on it. Its appeal is simplicity: you can count on the same amount each month, and it never goes down. Its weakness is inflation. Prices keep climbing while the payout holds still, so it covers less as time passes. As an illustration, an amount that pays for a comfortable month at 65 stretches noticeably less far at 85, after twenty years of price rises.
What this plan leaves your beneficiaries is the portion of your premium not yet paid back to you, together with any other savings still in your CPF. Every payout reduces that sum, so it falls steadily until it hits zero. Your monthly payouts carry on after that point.
The Basic Plan pays less each month than the Standard Plan in exchange for leaving more to your beneficiaries for a longer stretch. When payouts begin, part of your RA savings becomes your CPF LIFE premium, and the remainder stays in your RA. Your payouts come out of the remaining RA balance first. Later in life, they come from your CPF LIFE premium instead, and once that premium is used up, you keep receiving monthly payouts from the accumulated pooled interest, however long you live. The CPF Board explains the details on cpf.gov.sg. Since a bigger sum sits in your RA for longer, more of it can still go to your family if you die in the earlier years.
The cost is a smaller monthly amount that may slip downward over the years, since part of it relies on interest earned by an RA balance that keeps shrinking. People who suit this plan usually have another dependable source of income and put the most weight on what they leave behind.
The Escalating Plan begins below the Standard Plan's monthly payout and then goes up every year, for life, by a fixed percentage set by the CPF Board. It is meant to help with inflation. For the first several years you get less than you would on the Standard Plan. Later your payout passes the Standard Plan's level amount, and in your eighties and nineties you receive more. Compared with the other two plans, it does better the longer you live.
It has two drawbacks. If your other income is thin in your late sixties, the smaller starting payout may be hard to manage. And if you die early, you will have collected less in total than the Standard Plan would have paid.
Start with your income need at the beginning, and ask whether you could pay for essentials on a lower starting payout. If the Standard payout would only just meet your essential spending, the smaller early payouts of the Basic and Escalating Plans could leave a shortfall your savings would have to cover.
Next, consider inflation and longevity. A payout that grows each year is worth more to you when people in your family tend to live long, or when you hold few other assets whose value keeps pace with prices.
Then weigh the bequest. If you want to pass on a meaningful amount, particularly should you die in your sixties or seventies, the Basic Plan holds more money in your RA. If you have other assets to pass on, or the people you would leave money to are already taken care of, the size of your income may count for more than the bequest.
It also helps to set the plans beside your other retirement income. The course "Retirement & Estate: income for life and a plan for what you leave" does this in lesson 2.2, "Choose your CPF LIFE plan and start age for the whole plan", once you have built the rest of your income plan.
Your figures under each plan depend on your RA balance, the age your payouts begin, and current interest assumptions. Go by the Monthly Payout Estimator on cpf.gov.sg instead of a rule of thumb. It calculates your estimated monthly payouts from your current RA balance and lets you choose different CPF LIFE plans to see how each one affects your payouts, and lesson 7.4, "Compare plans with the CPF LIFE estimator", takes you through it one step at a time.
Most people see the same shape in their results: at the start the Standard payout falls between the other two, later the Escalating payout climbs above the Standard, and the Basic bequest stays the biggest for the longest time.
Linda tried the estimator once, quickly, and her results followed that shape, with her Escalating payout passing the Standard in her seventies. She is inclined towards the Escalating Plan. She has part-time income planned until her late sixties, which helps during the years when the Escalating payout trails the Standard, and the women in her family tend to live long: her mother is 79 and still active, and her grandmother reached 98.
Go through the three questions for your own situation, and decide which matters most to you: a level income, a larger bequest, or payouts that rise over time.
Write down the plan you lean towards and why: steady income, a larger bequest or payouts that rise.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).