How a high yield turns into a loss

Explain how a falling price pushes the yield up and how buyers get caught by it.

Before you buy a stock because its dividend yield is high, find out why the yield is high. Often investors expect the dividend to be cut and have already sold the shares down, so the figure that attracts you is a sign of trouble the market noticed first.

A yield trap is a stock or REIT whose high yield reflects a falling price ahead of a dividend cut. A version of it turns up regularly on social media. Someone writes about a stock they have found paying 11% (an illustrative figure, not tied to a real stock), puts a decent amount into it and starts mentally spending the income. Some months later the same person posts an update: the dividend has been cut, the share price has dropped further, and they are torn between selling at a loss and waiting it out. Updates like that appear so often that the situation was given its own name.

How trailing yield climbs while a company weakens

Lesson 2.1, "Dividend yield looks backward", showed you how yield is worked out. The yield quoted on most sites is the trailing yield, which is past dividends, usually last year's, divided by the current price. Because the dividend in the calculation is an old one, a price that drops before the dividend changes pushes the trailing yield up. The rise is largest for the companies nearest to trouble, since their prices have fallen furthest while the old payout is still counted in full.

The buyer and the market are therefore reading different years. A buyer sets last year's dividend against today's reduced price and concludes the shares are cheap. The market has been looking at next year's smaller dividend and has already priced it in. Screeners sort stocks by trailing yield, which can put a trap close to the top of a high-yield list. If you arrive from such a list, you may have no prior knowledge of the company and buy on the yield figure and a name you recognise.

Following one stock from S$2.00 to a halved dividend

Imagine a company whose shares sit at S$2.00 and which pays a regular dividend of S$0.16 a year. That works out to S$0.16 / S$2.00 = 8%, a moderate yield that has held steady. The company carries some debt and is under some pressure.

During the following year its sales slow and the cost of its debt goes up. Investors who watch the company closely begin to sell, and the share price slides to S$1.40. The dividend is still S$0.16, so the trailing yield becomes S$0.16 / S$1.40 = about 11.4%, which screeners display as roughly 11%, and the stock moves up the high-yield rankings.

Buyers drawn by that 11% start to come in. When the company next reports results, it halves the dividend to S$0.08 a year, and at a price of S$1.40 the yield drops to S$0.08 / S$1.40 = about 5.7%. The 11% those buyers saw was never actually on offer to them, since it combined last year's payout with this year's price.

A cut is often followed by a second fall in the price. Holders who owned the shares only for the income sell out, and other investors read the cut as evidence that the business is in worse shape than they had hoped.

Measuring the damage with total return

Total return is the price change plus the dividends received, the method from Lesson 1.4, "Track one dividend and its total return". It shows whether an investor came out ahead once both parts are counted. To calculate it:

Subtract the purchase price from the selling or current price to get the price change. Add the dividends received. Divide the result by the purchase price for the percentage gain or loss.

Apply it to the investor who bought at S$2.00 and held for the year. The price moved from S$2.00 to S$1.40, a change of minus S$0.60. Dividends paid on schedule came to S$0.16. Minus S$0.60 plus S$0.16 is minus S$0.44, and minus S$0.44 on S$2.00 is a 22% loss, more than a fifth of the money invested. This investor received every dividend and still lost money overall.

The buyer who came in at S$1.40 bought for roughly 11%, probably without having studied the company before, and will now receive S$0.08 a year while the price may keep sliding. If the price drops further after the cut, the reduced dividend will not come close to covering the fall.

Three reasons buyers fall for it

Share prices fall all the time, so a falling price on its own does not make a stock a trap. What makes it a trap is that the high yield pulled buyers in at the moment of greatest risk and gave them a signal opposite to the one the market was sending.

The first reason is that the yield figure feels factual, because it is calculated from payments that really happened. You trust it more than you would a forecast, although all it describes is the past.

The second is timing. A dividend cut is announced in a single day, while the warning signs accumulate over months in the cash flow statement, the debt notes and the tone of management commentary, which most investors never read. Lesson 3.2, "Warning signs that a dividend is about to be cut", takes you through each of these.

The third is that a lower price feels like a chance to buy cheaply. Adding to a holding at a lower price is sensible when the business's prospects are unchanged, and costly when they have got worse.

High yields are not all traps. A stock may yield more because it grows slowly, because its sector is out of favour, or because the whole market has fallen. Use a high yield as a cue to look harder, and make the decision only after you have done the looking. Lesson 3.4, "Run the yield trap check on a high yielder", gives you a checklist for separating a trap from a harmless high yield.

Before you turn to that checklist, go through the numbers again yourself, this time as the buyer who arrived at S$1.40. The activity uses one set of made-up figures; with them, work out exactly how much that buyer loses.

Take the made-up example. Work out the total return for someone who bought at S$1.40, received one payout, and watched the price fall to S$1.10 after the cut.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).