Run the yield trap check on a high yielder

Check one of the highest-yielding SGX stocks or REITs against the course's yield trap checklist.

A high dividend yield on an SGX stock or REIT is only likely to last if it survives five checks, each recorded with its source. You finish with one of three verdicts: pass, fail or more evidence needed. Allow about twenty-five minutes. You come away with a verdict and the evidence that supports it.

Wei Ling had the same REIT turning up near the top of every high-yield list. From lessons 3.1 to 3.3, Wei Ling understood that a yield that high might be a sign of trouble. It might also belong to a sound REIT in a sector the market has gone off. Nothing Wei Ling had read gave a way to tell which of the two applied to this particular REIT. So Wei Ling wrote out a method and worked through it one step at a time. That method is the exercise you are about to do, and Wei Ling's REIT supplies the figures at each step.

Finding a candidate and logging the starting figures

Open a stock screener, or the screening tools on the SGX website, and sort SGX stocks and REITs by trailing yield: the total paid out over the past year divided by today's price. This is the number screeners display. Take one stock from close to the top of the sorted list. If something you already hold yields well above the rest of your portfolio, pick that one instead, because you learn more when your own money is involved.

Write down the name, today's price and the trailing yield the screener shows, along with the source and the date you looked. Keep the same habit for every check that follows, noting both what you found and where you found it.

Wei Ling's REIT trades at S$0.50 today. Over the last year it paid S$0.06 per unit, which gives a trailing yield of 12% (S$0.06 / S$0.50).

Checks 1 to 3: price, one-offs and payout cover

The first check is the price trend. Pull up the price over the past one year and the past three years. If the yield has climbed mostly because the price dropped, look for what the market was responding to. Wei Ling's REIT traded at S$0.80 three years ago and has slid steadily since then, so the remaining checks are where the reason for that slide shows up.

The second check takes out anything that won't repeat. Remove specials and capital distributions from the past year's payouts and work the yield out again. The result is the recurring yield. Lesson 3.3, "One-offs, specials and payouts that will not repeat", gives the method. Of the REIT's S$0.06, S$0.01 was a capital distribution from selling a property. Without it, recurring distributions come to S$0.05 and the recurring yield is 10% (S$0.05 / S$0.50).

The third check asks whether the payout is covered, and you handle companies and REITs differently. For a company, calculate the payout ratio twice, once on earnings and once on free cash flow, following lesson 2.2, "Payout ratio tells you how much room is left". For a REIT, find out whether distributions are paid from operating income or topped up from capital, retained amounts or new borrowing. Module 5 adds further payout cover tests written for REITs. Wei Ling's REIT saw its distributable income from operations drop in each of the last two years. The manager released retained amounts to fill part of the gap, so distributions have come down more slowly than income.

Checks 4 and 5: debt and management's wording

Check 4 is about debt. Go to the debt note and find how much falls due over the next two years, the interest rates on that debt, and how close the company or REIT sits to any of its limits. Lesson 3.2, "Warning signs that a dividend is about to be cut", explains what to watch for. For the REIT, a large share of borrowings falls due within 18 months. Most of that debt was taken on at lower rates, and the manager expects refinancing to cost more.

Check 5 looks at what management has said. Put the dividend or distribution wording from the last two results announcements side by side, and look for a firm policy that has become a review. Two years ago the REIT's announcement said it aimed for stable distributions. The most recent one speaks of reviewing options to strengthen the balance sheet.

Choosing pass, fail or more evidence needed

With all five checks done, list the conditions that have to stay true for the current payout to keep coming, and against each one note whether your evidence backs it up. Wei Ling found three for the REIT to keep paying S$0.06: operating income has to recover, the debt has to be refinanced at rates near the old ones, and the REIT has to get by without issuing new equity or selling assets. Any of the three could happen, but the evidence gathered supports none of them.

Then pick a verdict using these definitions:

Pass: the high yield has an explanation other than a coming cut, such as a sector the market has turned against or a fall across the whole market, and the payout is covered with room to spare. Fail: the evidence points towards a cut. More evidence needed: you were unable to settle the question. This counts only when you name the evidence you are missing, write down exactly what would move the verdict to pass or fail (next quarter's operating income, the refinancing rate or a statement on distribution policy, for example), and put a date in your calendar to check again.

Wei Ling gave the REIT a fail. Part of the 12% is a one-off, income from operations is shrinking, refinancing will push costs up, and management's attention has moved from the distribution to the balance sheet. On that evidence, a cut, an equity raising or both are more likely than not.

Whichever verdict you reach, it answers only whether the yield is likely to last. It does not tell you to buy or sell. Your next move depends on your plan, and Module 8 is where you build that plan.

Now run your own high yielder through the five checks. Keep the notes, because lesson 8.3 asks you to rerun this same check whenever a holding cuts its payout.

Fill in the yield trap checklist for one high-yielding SGX stock or REIT. Give it a verdict of pass, fail or more evidence, and write down your reasons.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).