You will be able to read a REIT's fee structure and pick out fees that pay the manager for size rather than for unitholder returns.
Open the latest annual report of an S-REIT you own or are considering. Find the section that sets out the fees paid to the manager. For each fee, ask what the manager has to do to earn more of it, and whether that also makes you better off as a unitholder.
Darren, an investor in an S-REIT, had already learned that their REIT's manager was owned by the sponsor. Next they went looking for how the manager was paid. The annual report had a table with five different fees, each with its own formula. Some were paid in cash and some in units, and together they came to millions of dollars a year. Darren could read every line but still could not tell whether the arrangement was good for them. Understanding each line of a fee table doesn't tell you that. You also have to work out what each fee rewards.
Most S-REIT managers receive a base fee. This is usually a percentage of the value of the REIT's properties, often called deposited property. The trust deed sets the exact percentage and basis, and the annual report states them. Suppose the base fee is 0.3% a year of deposited property (an invented example). On S$4 billion of property, that comes to S$12 million a year. If the REIT buys another S$1 billion of property, the base goes up to S$5 billion and the base fee goes up to S$15 million.
A base fee rises whenever the REIT gets bigger, whether the new property raises or lowers income per unitholder. A manager paid mainly on size has an incentive to grow the REIT even when growth does nothing for distributions per unit. Not every manager acts on that incentive, but you should know which way it points.
Many managers also receive a performance fee. The name sounds reassuring, so look at what it actually measures. Some performance fees are a share of net property income or total distributable income. These grow with total income. Total income can rise just because the REIT buys more property and issues more units, so this kind of performance fee behaves like the base fee.
Other performance fees are tied to growth in distribution per unit (DPU), the income each unit actually receives. Lesson 5.1, "DPU is the number that pays you", explains why DPU is the number that matters to a unitholder. A manager who is paid more only when DPU rises has incentives much more closely aligned with yours.
To check a performance fee, read its formula in the annual report or prospectus. Note whether it is based on total income or on a per-unit measure. Also note whether it is measured against a fixed starting point or against the previous year.
Acquisition fees and divestment fees pay the manager a percentage of the price each time the REIT buys or sells a property. At 1% on a S$1 billion purchase (an invented example), the manager receives S$10 million. The manager earns these fees when the deal completes, whether or not the deal turns out well for unitholders. If a manager buys an overpriced property from its own sponsor, it still earns the acquisition fee on the full price. The acquisition fee comes on top of a base fee that rises with every purchase. A purchase from the sponsor is an interested person transaction, but unitholders only get a circular and a vote on it when its value, alone or added to other deals with the same party in the same financial year, reaches the SGX materiality threshold. That threshold is set as a share of the group's latest audited net tangible assets, and the SGX rulebook gives the current figure. When a sponsor deal does come with a circular, read it carefully.
There may be other fees too, such as development management fees on building projects. The property manager also earns its own fees, as covered in lesson 4.1. Every one of these belongs on your list.
Fees can be paid in cash, in new units or in a mix of both. Paying in units keeps cash in the REIT, and managers sometimes present this as a sign of confidence. Each payment in units also creates new units. This happens again every year, so the same income is spread over more units. Suppose the S$12 million base fee above was paid entirely in units at S$1.20 each (an invented example). That would create 10 million new units a year, which is about a third of one percent of 3 billion units in issue. The annual report states how each fee was settled, so check it rather than assume.
When Darren finished the list, it showed a base fee on deposited property, a performance fee on net property income, and acquisition and divestment fees. Part of the base fee was paid in units. Every one of those fees grew with size.
If most of a manager's pay comes from size-driven fees, ask what stops the manager from growing the REIT for its own sake. Possible checks include a strong track record of DPU growth, an independent board, or a large sponsor stake that means the sponsor shares in unitholders' results. Sometimes you won't find a good answer.
To work through any S-REIT:
Find the manager's fee table in the annual report, and the formulas in the annual report, prospectus or trust deed. List every fee: base, performance, acquisition, divestment, development management and the property manager's fees. For each fee, write down its basis, the amount paid last year and how it was settled (cash, units or a mix). For performance fees, note whether the basis is total income or a per-unit measure, and whether it is measured against a fixed starting point or the previous year. Mark the fees that grow when the REIT gets bigger, regardless of DPU. If most of the pay is size-driven, write down what stops the manager from growing for its own sake: a DPU track record, an independent board, a large sponsor stake, or nothing. For any sponsor deal large enough to need a circular, read the circular carefully with the acquisition and base fees in mind.
In the activity you will build the same list for one S-REIT, with last year's amounts, and mark the fees that reward size so you can see the balance at a glance.
Go through one S-REIT's annual report and list every fee, how it is calculated and last year's amount. Mark the ones that pay more as the REIT gets bigger.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).