Build a scorecard that compares two S-REITs on every metric in this module.
When two S-REITs are competing for the same money, line them up against each other on the ten metrics from Module 5. Give every figure a source and give every row a mark, and yield becomes one of ten rows feeding your decision.
Darren wants to use a top-up on one of two S-REITs. One yields 7%, the other 10%, and a friend says he should obviously take the higher one. Over Lessons 5.1 to 5.4, Darren has collected the figures a lender would want to see, and he'd like them laid out next to each other before he takes his friend's word for it. The pair he is looking at resembles REIT A and REIT B below (both REITs and all their figures are invented for the example).
A scorecard is a table that compares two REITs on ten metrics, with a source for every figure and a mark on every row. You'll use something from each lesson in Module 5 to fill it in. For two REITs, expect it to take about thirty minutes.
First, choose your pair. If both come from one sub-sector, the comparison is sharper. If they come from different sub-sectors, you'll see how much the numbers shift from one sector to another, and Module 6 explains why they do.
The table needs a column for each REIT and three further columns: one for source and page, one for the date of the figure, and one for your mark. Down the side go these ten metrics:
DPU trend over five years distribution yield gearing interest coverage ratio share of debt at fixed rates debt due in the next two years as a share of total debt WALE occupancy latest rental reversion price to NAV
The four debt rows (gearing, ICR, the fixed-rate share and debt due in the next two years) are explained in Lesson 5.2, "Gearing, interest coverage and the debt profile". For WALE and occupancy, Lesson 5.3, "WALE, occupancy and rental reversions", says which version to take. The price to NAV row draws on Lesson 5.4, "NAV per unit and what price to NAV tells you".
The latest results presentation will give you most of the rows. For the five-year DPU series, go to the annual reports, and mark any year with a capital distribution or a large unit issue using the approach in Lesson 5.1, "DPU is the number that pays you". Work out yield from recurring DPU, the way Lesson 3.3 shows.
A source means a reference another person can look up and check: a results presentation, an annual report or an SGXNet announcement, with its date and page written beside the figure. Without one, the figure is treated as a guess.
Sometimes the two REITs report the same metric on different bases. When that happens, write a note on the row. A common case is WALE, which one REIT may give by income and the other by space.
REIT A paid a DPU of S$0.070, 0.072, 0.073, 0.071 and 0.074 across the five years, a slow climb of about 5.7% over the period. Its units trade at S$1.05, so the distribution yield comes to about 7.0% (0.074 / 1.05). Gearing sits at 36% and ICR at 4.2 times. Of its debt, 80% is at fixed rates and 15% falls due in the next two years. WALE is 3.5 years, measured by income, occupancy is 97%, and the latest rental reversion was plus 4%. With NAV at S$1.10, price to NAV works out to about 0.95 (1.05 / 1.10).
REIT B's DPU ran S$0.090, 0.088, 0.082, 0.078 and 0.070, a drop of about 22% over the period. Its unit price is S$0.70, giving a yield of 10.0% (0.070 / 0.70). Gearing is 44% and ICR is 2.4 times. Only 55% of its debt is fixed, and 40% is due within two years. Its WALE of 2.1 years comes with no basis stated, so that row gets a note. Occupancy is 91% and the latest rental reversion was minus 3%. NAV is S$0.95, which puts price to NAV at about 0.74 (0.70 / 0.95).
Give each row one of three marks: stronger, weaker or similar. Stronger means the figure is better for the chance that the distribution keeps being paid.
On Darren's table, REIT A comes out stronger on 8 rows: DPU trend, gearing, ICR, fixed-rate share, debt due soon, WALE, occupancy and reversion. REIT B leads on 2 rows, the higher yield and the deeper discount to NAV.
Look at those two rows in the light of everything else on the page. Taken alone, a higher yield and a bigger discount to NAV seem appealing. When the other rows are weak, the yield and the discount may simply be how the market has priced that weakness. A weak scorecard like REIT B's doesn't mean the REIT is a bad investment, and a strong scorecard like REIT A's doesn't mean it's a good one. The scorecard tells you what you give up to get the high yield.
Next, write down for each REIT the single metric that worries you most. If nothing stands out, record "nothing stands out" in that space. A long WALE can be the worry, since it may slow how quickly a REIT can raise rents. A big share of debt due soon can be the worry, since refinancing at higher rates would push DPU down further, and high gearing leaves less room to absorb that.
If one of your two REITs resembles REIT B, go on to Lesson 3.4, "Run the yield trap check on a high yielder".
Leave the comparison paragraph until every row has its mark. Write it in plain words, so a reader could follow your reasoning without opening a single source report.
Your scorecard is complete when both REITs have all ten rows filled, each figure has its source, page and date next to it, each row is marked, you've named the biggest worry for each REIT, and the comparison paragraph is written clearly enough that someone could understand it without the source reports.
Darren doesn't buy either REIT that week. When he picks the decision up again, his starting point is the scorecard and the yield is one row on it.
Choose your two REITs, collect the figures along with their sources, and write your comparison last, once every row is marked.
Fill in the REIT scorecard for two S-REITs, give a source for every figure, and write one paragraph comparing them.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).