Healthcare and hospitality: master leases and variable income

Compare the steady income of healthcare REITs with the variable income of hospitality REITs.

Open the latest annual report or results presentation of any healthcare or hospitality S-REIT and search for "master lease". The report usually says how the REIT earns its rent. It either has master leases or runs the properties directly, and it shows how much of the rent is fixed and how much varies. That split explains most of what happened to these two kinds of REIT in 2020.

Hotels and hospitals in 2020

When borders closed in 2020, hotel occupancy worldwide collapsed within weeks, and hospitality REITs that depended on room revenue saw their income fall hard. Healthcare REITs that leased hospitals and nursing homes to operators on long leases kept collecting rent, because the leases required it. Both types were on the same stock exchange, so the difference came from how each one is paid.

Master leases in healthcare REITs

A healthcare REIT owns hospitals, nursing homes, medical centres or similar properties. It often leases each property to a single operator, which is the company that runs the hospital or nursing home. The lease is a master lease: one long lease covering the whole property, often for many years. The operator pays the REIT rent and usually takes on most of the running costs. These leases commonly include rent reviews, which are built-in yearly increases. Some are linked to inflation or to the operator's revenue, and some are a fixed step. The annual report summarises the lease terms, including their length and how the reviews work.

The rent is paid whether the hospital is busy or quiet, which gives steady, predictable income. This carried healthcare REITs through 2020. The steadiness depends entirely on the operator being able to pay. If the operator gets into financial trouble, it may ask for a rent cut or default, or the REIT may need to find a new operator. A new operator is hard to find for a specialised building, because a hospital cannot be re-let to a shop.

Healthcare REITs are often concentrated, with most properties leased to one or two operators. The main operator is sometimes a company related to the REIT's sponsor, so the sponsor may also be the main tenant. Lesson 4.1, Sponsor, manager and trustee: who does what, showed why sponsor links matter, and the same applies when the sponsor is also the tenant.

For a healthcare REIT, read the operator as carefully as the property. After the lease terms, find:

the share of rent that comes from the largest operator how healthy that operator's finances are how much rent it pays compared with the earnings it makes at the property

The annual report gives some of this, and operators that are listed publish their own results.

Why hotel income swings with travel

A hospitality REIT owns hotels and serviced residences. Its income moves with how many rooms are filled and at what price. Both rise when travel is strong, and income can drop sharply and quickly when travel stops. It follows tourism, business travel, events and exchange rates, all of which change quickly. The Singapore Tourism Board publishes visitor arrival and hotel statistics that you can use to check the current picture.

Hotels have high fixed costs, such as staff, maintenance and utilities. These costs stay when revenue falls, so profit falls faster than revenue. If a REIT's income is based on hotel profit rather than revenue, the swing is larger still.

Fixed and variable rent in hotel master leases

Some hospitality REITs also use master leases, with the hotel operator or the sponsor as the lessee. These often combine a fixed rent, which is set regardless of how the hotel performs, with a variable rent linked to the hotel's revenue or profit.

Say a hotel REIT's master lease pays a fixed rent of S$20 million a year (these are made-up figures). In a good year the variable rent is S$25 million, for a total of S$45 million. In a bad year it is S$5 million, for a total of S$25 million. The fall from S$45 million to S$25 million is about 44%. A comparison REIT with no fixed element might earn S$40 million in a good year and S$10 million in a bad year, which is a 75% fall.

The fixed element only works if the lessee can pay it in a bad year. A sponsor lessee with a strong balance sheet helps. With a small operator, the fixed rent is only as strong as the operator. For a hospitality REIT, find out whether income comes from master leases or direct operation. Then find the fixed and variable split and whether the variable part is linked to revenue or profit. Judge whether the lessee could pay the fixed rent in a bad year, and check the Singapore Tourism Board figures for current conditions.

Darren's healthcare and hotel REITs

Darren, an example investor, puts one healthcare REIT and one hospitality REIT side by side. The healthcare REIT earns almost all its rent from fixed master leases with annual reviews, mostly from one operator. The hospitality REIT reports roughly a third of its rent as fixed, with the rest varying with hotel revenue. He concludes that the healthcare REIT gives steadiness with a single point of failure. The hospitality REIT gives a share of a travel recovery, with income that could fall hard in a downturn.

Neither sector is better than the other. They meet different needs in an income portfolio, which Lesson 8.2, Spread income across sectors, sources and countries, picks up. The annual report or results presentation usually states how rent is earned: under master leases or direct operation, with fixed and variable parts. In the activity you will find that split for one healthcare and one hospitality S-REIT, and it will tell you more about the next bad year than either REIT's yield does.

Take one healthcare and one hospitality S-REIT, look at how each earns its rent, and note how much of its income is fixed and how much is variable.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).