Judge how a placement to institutional investors affects retail holders.
Darren owns units in a REIT (an illustration, not a named real REIT). One morning Darren reads that the REIT sold a block of new units overnight to institutional investors, priced below the last traded price. None of the new units were offered to Darren, and the sale had closed before the news came out, so Darren's units now make up a slightly smaller slice of a slightly bigger REIT.
In a private placement, the REIT issues new units and sells them only to a chosen group of investors. Those buyers are known as placees, and most are institutions such as fund managers. A bank manages the sale. Usually the REIT announces it after the market has closed. The bank gathers orders through the night, and the price and the number of units are fixed before the next morning. The units are priced at a discount to the recent market price to bring buyers in. As a retail holder, you are usually left out.
REITs like placements for their speed. Within hours a REIT can raise a large sum at a price it already knows. A rights issue or a preferential offering, where existing holders are offered new units, runs over several weeks, and the market can turn against the REIT during that time.
You hold the same number of units after a placement, but the total in issue goes up, so your percentage of the REIT falls. This is called dilution. The discount is a separate cost. The placees paid less than the market price, so part of the REIT's value moves to them and the existing units are worth a little less.
Take a REIT with 2,000 million units in issue trading at S$1.00 (example figures), which gives a market value of S$2,000 million. It sells 200 million new units at S$0.90, a 10% discount. It raises 200 million x S$0.90 = S$180 million and now has 2,200 million units in issue. Your holding used to be measured against 2,000 million units and is now measured against 2,200 million, so your share of the REIT falls by about 9.1%.
The theoretical value per unit after the placement shows what the discount did. Add the money raised to the market value before the placement, then divide by the units in issue after it: (S$2,000 million + S$180 million) / 2,200 million, which is about S$0.991. About 0.9% of the value of each existing unit has gone to the placees.
Many S-REITs run a preferential offering alongside a placement. It offers you and other existing holders new units at a price close to the placement price, so you can buy enough to keep your share. If the REIT doesn't run one, you are diluted and can't buy at the placement price.
When you go through the announcement, look for these, in this order:
The discount: compare the issue price with the recent market price. The size: new units as a share of the units in issue before the placement. Who got the units: the main placees, whether the sponsor (the company that set up the REIT) joined in, and how the REIT met the SGX rules on placements to related parties, such as the sponsor. Whether a preferential offering runs alongside the placement.
Strong demand from placees usually shows up as a small discount. A large discount means the REIT gave away more value to raise its money. On size, the larger the new units are compared with the units in issue beforehand, the more you and other existing holders are diluted.
The announcement will often name the main placees or say whether the sponsor bought. Take note if the sponsor bought a large part of a placement you couldn't join. SGX rules limit placements to certain related parties, and the announcement explains how the REIT met those rules.
For Darren, the new units came to about 8% of units in issue, the discount was around 5%, and there was no preferential offering.
When a placement pays for an acquisition, the announcement usually claims the deal is DPU-accretive, meaning DPU (distribution per unit, the payout on each unit) goes up as a result. A deal that brings DPU down is dilutive.
You can check the claim yourself using the circular, the document the REIT publishes to explain the deal to unitholders. Start with DPU before the deal, which is distributable income (the income available to pay out to unitholders) divided by units in issue. Then take the net property income of the property being bought, which is its rental income after property expenses. Work out a year's interest on the new debt at the cost of debt the circular assumes, meaning the interest rate it expects to pay on that borrowing. Net property income minus that interest is the distributable income the deal adds.
Add it to the existing distributable income and divide by the units in issue after the placement. If the new DPU is above the old one, the deal is accretive. If it is below, the deal is dilutive. Then repeat the calculation with a different cost of debt to see how much the result changes.
For the same REIT, distributable income before the deal is S$140 million, so DPU is S$140 million / 2,000 million units = S$0.070. The property costs S$400 million and earns net property income of S$22 million a year, a yield of 5.5% on the price. The REIT pays for it with the S$180 million from the placement and S$220 million of new debt.
If the debt costs 4%, interest is S$8.8 million a year. The property adds S$22 million - S$8.8 million = S$13.2 million, which takes distributable income to S$153.2 million. Spread over 2,200 million units, DPU is about S$0.0696. That is a little under S$0.070, so the deal is dilutive.
If the debt costs 3%, interest falls to S$6.6 million and the property adds S$15.4 million. DPU comes to about S$0.0706, so the deal is slightly accretive. The two results differ by one percentage point on the cost of debt, so a small change in that one assumption can move a deal from dilutive to accretive or back again.
When you read a real circular, you will find more items, such as fees, the cost of the placement and changes to existing debt. You add each one to the same calculation in the same way.
Find the assumed property yield and the assumed cost of debt in the circular, and decide whether each one is realistic. Watch for two warning signs: a yield at the top of the market's range, and a cost of debt lower than what the REIT pays on its existing loans. Compare the circular's cost of debt first with the REIT's current average cost of debt. Lesson 5.2, "Gearing, interest coverage and the debt profile", shows you where to find that figure.
Darren's circular shows a small DPU gain, but only because it assumes the new debt will cost well below what the REIT pays on its existing loans. Darren notes this as a reason for doubt and keeps the units already held, because a doubtful assumption on its own isn't a reason to sell.
Read one placement announcement and write down the discount, the new units as a share of units in issue, whether a preferential offering runs alongside it, and the DPU effect it claims. Then judge in one sentence whether retail holders lose out and why.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).