The Spam Control Act and unsolicited email

You will be able to explain what the Spam Control Act requires of anyone who sends unsolicited commercial email in bulk.

Priya runs a tuition centre in Tampines. A vendor offers her a list of 20,000 "parents in the east" (an example figure), and the Spam Control Act is the law that decides what happens if she emails them.

Before getting to Priya's decision, think of an email you've had from a company you never dealt with. It offers a renovation package or a cheap loan, and it was sent to an address you never gave them. There's no clear way to stop it, and another one arrives the next week. The Act was written for this kind of email.

The Spam Control Act is a Singapore law, separate from the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA). The PDPA, covered in lesson 1.2, deals with collecting and using personal data with consent. The Spam Control Act deals with something narrower: unsolicited commercial messages sent in bulk. If you run a small business and follow the consent habits from lesson 1.2, you'll rarely send the kind of email the Act targets. You still need to know where its lines are, because suggestions like buying a list or emailing every business card from an event put you right on them. What follows is an overview to help you ask good questions. As in the previous lesson, it isn't legal advice.

What the Act means by unsolicited commercial messages

The Act applies to unsolicited commercial electronic messages sent in bulk, and each part of that phrase matters.

A message is commercial if it sells or promotes something, such as a product, service, business or offer. A receipt, or a reply to a customer's question, isn't what the Act is aimed at.

A message is unsolicited if the person didn't ask for it and didn't consent to receive it. This is where the Act meets lesson 1.2. A subscriber who ticked your box for the monthly email asked for it. Someone whose address you found on a website or bought in a spreadsheet did not.

Electronic messages include email. They also include text messages to mobile numbers, so some businesses get caught by the Act with SMS blasts.

The Act sets out what counts as sending in bulk. If someone quotes you a figure, read the current definition in the Act itself rather than trusting what they tell you.

People often confuse the Act with the Do Not Call (DNC) Registry. The DNC rules sit under the PDPA. They cover marketing calls and text messages to Singapore phone numbers, and they don't cover email. Keep the two apart: the DNC Registry is for phones, while the Spam Control Act covers bulk unsolicited electronic messages, including email.

What a message under the Act must include

Messages that fall under the Act have to meet certain requirements. Two of them matter most for email.

The first is an unsubscribe facility. The message must give the recipient a clear way to ask you to stop sending, and you must act on that request. Every reputable email tool puts an unsubscribe link in the footer of marketing email and handles removals for you. If you send through such a tool and never strip the link out, the mechanics are covered. You're still responsible for honouring requests that arrive by other routes, such as a reply that says "remove me".

The second is a label. Unsolicited commercial messages sent in bulk must start the subject line with the letters ADV inside angle brackets, so the recipient can see at a glance that the message is an advertisement. You rarely see this label in your own inbox. Mostly this is because the businesses you hear from have your consent, so their email isn't unsolicited and the label doesn't apply.

The Act has other provisions too, including rules against using software to harvest email addresses or to generate them automatically. You don't need to memorise them. Know that the law exists, roughly what it targets, and where to read the current text.

To check a message against the Act, work through these questions in order:

Is it commercial, meaning it sells or promotes something? Is it unsolicited, meaning the recipient never asked for it or consented to it? Is it an electronic message, email or SMS, sent in bulk as the Act currently defines bulk? If it falls under the Act, does it have a working unsubscribe facility, do you act on every request including "remove me" replies, and does the subject line start with ADV in angle brackets?

Take Priya's offer through those questions. An email to the vendor's 20,000 parents promoting her holiday classes sells something, so it's commercial. None of those parents gave her their address or asked to hear from her, so it's unsolicited. It goes out by email to 20,000 addresses at once, so she would check that against the Act's current definition of bulk. If it falls under the Act, every email would need a working unsubscribe link, someone acting on each "remove me" reply, and a subject line that starts with ADV in angle brackets before the words "Holiday maths classes in Tampines".

Why bought and scraped lists cross the line

A bought list is unsolicited by definition. The people on it never asked to hear from you, whatever the seller claims about "opt-in data". The same goes for addresses copied from websites, directories or LinkedIn profiles. If you email bought or scraped addresses in bulk, you're inside the territory the Act was written for.

The law is only half of the problem. In lesson 1.1, "Your email list is the one audience you own", you saw that complaints land on your own domain, the name after the @ in the address you send from. Bought and scraped lists are full of old, abandoned and fake addresses, and some of them are spam traps: addresses that exist only to catch senders with poor practices. One send to a bad list can lower your domain's reputation far enough that your invoices and your replies to real customers start going to spam.

Lesson 3.4, "Clean your list before it costs you", covers spam traps in more detail. Most email tools also forbid bought lists in their terms and can close your account if you use one.

If Priya buys the list, a handful of those parents might have liked her classes, but complaints from everyone else would hurt every email she sends afterwards. That includes her termly update to the parents who actually signed up.

Where to check the current rules

Laws and guidance change. The Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA) and the Personal Data Protection Commission (PDPC) both publish information on Singapore's rules for electronic marketing. The full text of the Spam Control Act is on Singapore Statutes Online. Before you rely on any summary, including this one, check what those sources say now.

The check below takes about ten minutes. It's worth doing now, while the four questions above are fresh and before you write a marketing email of your own, because a missing unsubscribe link or label is easier to spot in someone else's email first.

Open the last three marketing emails you got from Singapore businesses. For each one, note whether you asked for it, how it let you unsubscribe and whether it had an <ADV> label.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).