Explain the signals inbox providers use to put an email in the inbox, the promotions tab or the spam folder.
Every inbox provider, including Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo, runs filters on each message that arrives. The filters try to answer one question: does this person want this email? The answer decides whether your email goes to the main inbox, the promotions tab or the spam folder. It rests on four kinds of signal: your reputation, your authentication (proof that an email really comes from the domain it claims), how readers treat your mail, and how you send.
Mei Ling sent her first proper newsletter to 180 subscribers (an invented example, like the other people here). Over the following week she heard three different stories about where it landed. One regular found it by accident in the spam folder, among lottery-win emails. Another saw it in the promotions tab. A third read it in the main inbox over breakfast. All three had received the same email at the same minute. Where an email lands is not random, but identical emails sent at the same minute can land in different places for different recipients, because the filters weigh signals about the sender and about each reader.
The biggest signal is reputation, the record an inbox provider builds up about your sending over time. It attaches mainly to your domain, the part of your email address after the @, and to the servers that send your mail. When you send through an email tool, you share some servers with the tool's other customers. This is one reason good email tools police their customers' lists carefully.
Reputation builds slowly and drops fast. Months of sending wanted email to people who engage with it builds a good reputation. A single send to an old or bought list can damage it in a day, because such lists are full of dead addresses and people who complain. Reputation is tied to the domain, so the damage spreads beyond your newsletter to the invoices, quotes and replies to customers you send from that domain. Module 1 covers list quality and lesson 2.3 covers opt-in, and both matter for delivery for this reason.
Providers also check whether an email really came from the domain it claims, using three records: SPF, DKIM and DMARC. SPF lists the servers allowed to send mail for your domain. DKIM adds a signature showing the message was not changed on the way. DMARC tells providers what to do with mail that fails those checks. Mail that is not authenticated starts at a disadvantage. Lesson 3.2, "SPF, DKIM and DMARC in plain words", explains each record.
Providers watch how their users treat your mail. Opening, reading, replying, clicking and adding you to contacts are positive signals. When a reader marks one of your messages as not spam, Gmail learns how to manage mail addressed to that reader. Google describes this as learning that person's own preferences, not as a boost to your reputation as a sender. Deleting without opening and ignoring message after message are negative signals.
If people report your mail as spam often, Gmail becomes more likely to send your future messages to spam, and your domain's reputation can drop. A list of people who asked to hear from you produces good signals naturally. A list of people who forgot they signed up produces bad signals, however well the email is written.
Replies are worth encouraging. Priya sends a fortnightly tip to parents and ends each one with "Reply and tell me which topic your child finds hardest". Each parent who replies shows their inbox provider that people answer Priya's mail. Lesson 4.1 comes back to why this helps.
Providers watch sending patterns too. An established domain that has sent a few emails a week for months and then suddenly sends thousands in an hour looks like a spammer who has taken over an account. A brand-new domain that starts with a large send looks like a spammer who has just set one up.
Warming up means starting a new sender, domain or tool with small sends to engaged contacts and growing steadily. New senders should do this, and so should anyone who has moved to a new domain or a new email tool. Start with your most engaged contacts: recent signups and frequent buyers. Widen to the rest of the list over several sends, and grow volume steadily without sudden jumps. Most email tools publish their own advice on warm-up pace. Follow that advice, since it beats a number quoted on a forum.
A list you have left untouched for a long time, such as a year, has gone stale and needs careful handling. Lesson 3.4 shows how to handle a stale list safely.
For many users, Gmail sorts incoming mail into tabs, and marketing email often lands in Promotions. Many business owners treat this as a defeat and hunt for tricks to escape it, and there is little reason to. Mail in the promotions tab has been delivered: the provider has judged it legitimate and wanted, just commercial. People who use the tab go there when they are in the mood for offers and newsletters, and subscribers who value your email find it there. Some readers will move your email to Primary, and the provider learns from that. Being read in Primary or in Promotions both count as success, because either way you are in front of the reader.
The spam folder holds mail the provider has judged unwanted, and most people never look in it. Of Mei Ling's three regulars, the one who found her newsletter there only did so by accident.
You cannot see inside the filters, but you can see the results. Send a test to addresses you control at different providers and note where each one lands: inbox, promotions or spam. Then open the message headers, the technical lines that travel hidden at the top of every email. In Gmail, the menu on an open message has an option to show the original, which displays whether SPF, DKIM and DMARC passed. Outlook offers a similar view through the message source or details. Check whether all three passed.
Mei Ling runs this check before her next issue to her 180 subscribers. Her Gmail copy lands in Promotions and her Outlook copy lands in the inbox. In Gmail she opens the menu, chooses to show the original, and sees that SPF, DKIM and DMARC all passed, so authentication is not holding her back. Promotions means Gmail delivered the newsletter and judged it commercial, which is what it is. Her list is made up of people who asked to hear from her, so reader signals should stay good as long as she keeps sending at a steady pace.
The trap in this check is your own addresses. Gmail learns each person's preferences, and your test accounts may have you saved as a contact or a long history of opening your mail. A copy that reaches their inbox shows how the filters treat you as a reader, and a subscriber who has never opened your mail can get a different result.
Send a test email from your tool to a Gmail address and an Outlook address, and note where each lands and whether its headers show SPF, DKIM and DMARC passed. For each, write which of the four signals best explains where it landed.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).