Collect a month of email results on one page and decide three changes for next month.
Open your email tool and your website analytics, and set both to show last month. In a notebook or a blank document, write down every email that went out in that month: each newsletter issue, each one-off campaign and every automation flow that ran. You will fill in the numbers for each of these as you go.
Most small businesses look at email results one send at a time, or they don't look at all. A common habit is to check the report the morning after a send, feel pleased or let down, and get on with the day. A month later the owner can't say whether email is getting better or worse, and has only a feeling about whether it is worth the time spent on it. A monthly review solves this. Once a month you gather every email result onto one page, look for patterns across the whole page, and make three decisions. When it has become a habit, it takes about thirty minutes.
Your first review uses the metrics you chose in lesson 8.2. Include every email sent in the month: newsletter issues, one-off campaigns and all automation flows. Flows include the welcome flow, enquiry follow-up, abandoned cart, re-engagement and any other flow currently running. Flows are easy to leave out because they run in the background, yet they often send more email than the newsletter.
For each send or flow, record emails delivered, click rate, conversions or revenue where you can trace them, unsubscribes and complaints. For a flow, use the month's totals for the whole flow. If one email inside a flow did much better or much worse than the rest, write a note beside that flow.
Next, record four list figures: subscribers at the start of the month, new subscribers, losses and subscribers at the end. Start plus new, minus losses, should equal the end figure. The change across the month is your net list growth.
Your analytics can only show conversions from email if it can tell which website visits came from email. UTM tags are added to links so that analytics can identify each visit by source and medium. If you added UTM tags in lesson 8.2, check that they work: look in analytics for traffic during the month from the source and medium you used, such as newsletter and email. Where some links went out without tags, write down which ones.
If your email tool can add UTM tags automatically, switch that setting on so next month's review has complete data. Use the same tag names every month. If the names change, analytics splits one campaign across several rows. Lesson 2.2, "A naming convention your whole team can follow", in the course "Marketing analytics: GA4, attribution and testing", gives a convention for keeping tags consistent from month to month.
With everything on one page, compare the rows against each other instead of reading each one by itself. Note which topics earned the most clicks and which segments from module 6 clicked and bought the most. Work out which flow produced the most bookings or orders for the number of emails it sent. Check whether unsubscribes rose after any particular send, and whether net list growth is positive.
If you have last month's data, set this month beside it. Your first review has nothing to compare against, which is fine. Its main job is to set the baseline, the figures next month's review will be measured against.
Priya runs a business whose email list is made up of parents. They offer trial classes, and some families are already enrolled. During the month Priya sent two newsletter issues to about 300 parents. The issue about fraction mistakes got a 9 percent click rate (an example figure), and the issue about the exam timetable got 3 percent. Their welcome flow sent 112 emails to 28 new subscribers, and 4 of those subscribers booked trial classes. The enquiry follow-up flow handled 19 enquiries. Of those, 11 booked trials, and 3 of the 11 booked only after receiving the follow-up email. Unsubscribes were low on every send apart from the timetable issue, which lost 5 parents. Net list growth was positive.
Priya's report is one table, with a row for each send or flow and columns for delivered, click rate, bookings and unsubscribes. Below the table is a short line giving the list's start size, gains, losses and end size.
Each review ends with three written decisions: one thing to keep, one thing to change and one thing to stop. Write each as a specific action and put the reason next to it. Next month you can then check whether you carried it out and whether it made a difference.
Priya wrote these three. Keep practical how-to topics, because the fraction issue earned three times the click rate of the timetable issue. Change how exam and timetable news is sent, so it goes only to enrolled families as a conditional block, because parents who weren't enrolled ignored it and some of them unsubscribed. Stop the third email in the welcome sequence, because almost nobody clicked it, and move its one useful tip into email two.
Limit yourself to three decisions. Reviews that end with twelve ideas usually end with none of them done. Any other ideas go on a separate list that you can pick from in later months.
Pull your month's results now and put together your one-page report. It is finished when it:
fits on one page lists every send and flow from the month with the numbers you track has one table or simple chart showing them together records list growth ends with three decisions and their reasons
Make a one-page report for the month with your five tracked numbers, one chart or table, and three written decisions for next month.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).