Bring problems with options

You will be able to raise a problem upward in a way that gets a decision.

Aziz has settled in well, but the new client is bigger than anyone expected. Wei Ling's team is now stretched. Arjun is covering two accounts, Hui Min's dashboard project has stalled, and Farid has worked late four Mondays in a row. Wei Ling walks into her fortnightly meeting with Daniel and says, "The team's really overloaded. It's not sustainable."

Daniel nods sympathetically, says he knows everyone is busy, and moves on to the next item. Nothing changes.

Wei Ling described a real problem. She just didn't give Daniel anything to decide.

Problem, impact, decision

A complaint describes how things feel. A problem raised well gives your manager something to act on. The difference is mostly in the order and in what you include.

Start with the problem, stated specifically. "Since the new client started, the team's workload has gone up by about 20 hours a week, based on our ticket log." The figure is Wei Ling's own estimate from her team's tracker, which is what makes it more than a feeling.

Then the impact, in terms your manager cares about. You learned in lesson 8.2, Learn what your manager actually needs, that Daniel is measured on client retention. So: "Farid has missed the Monday 6pm report deadline twice in the last month, and the Changi renewal is in eight weeks. If report quality slips before the renewal, we put it at risk."

Then the decision you need. "I need us to decide this week how to bring the workload back to something the team can sustain."

Putting the decision request up front, rather than leaving your manager to work out what you want, is the single biggest change. Communicate at work taught a version of this in lesson 3.2, Raise bad news early and bring options. As a manager, you are doing it on behalf of a team.

Bring options with a recommendation

Never bring a problem with only one possible answer, and never bring it with none. Two or three options, each with its trade-offs, and your recommendation.

Wei Ling's options were these. Option one: hire a contract staff member for three months to cover routine queries. It's fast relief and keeps the team's quality up through the renewal, but it needs budget and a few weeks to find someone. Option two: pause Hui Min's dashboard project and move her to client work full time. It costs no money and is immediate, but it delays the dashboard Daniel's own boss has been asking for. Option three: agree with the new client to move their weekly report to fortnightly for the first quarter. It saves about six hours a week, but the client may push back, and it needs Daniel to make the call.

Her recommendation: option two for the next four weeks, while starting the search for a contract staff member, which is option one, so that Hui Min can return to the dashboard by next quarter.

The recommendation matters. It shows you've thought it through, and it gives your manager something to say yes or no to. Your manager may choose a different option. That's fine. Your job is to make the decision easy to take, whichever way it goes.

Ask for what you need

Be explicit about what kind of help you want. There are four common ones.

A decision means choosing between options, approving a change, or settling a conflict between priorities. Resources means budget, headcount, time, or a person from another team. Air cover means backing you up with someone above or beside you, such as a client, another department, or their own boss, so you can do the right thing without being overruled. Advice means you want their experience, and you'll make the call yourself.

Say which one. "I need a decision on this today" lands very differently from "I'd like your advice before I decide." If you leave it unsaid, your manager will guess, and they may offer sympathy when you needed money, or advice when you needed a decision.

In public and in private

Sometimes your manager will decide something you disagree with. The rule for handling that is simple, and hard to follow: disagree in private, and support the decision in public.

Raise your disagreement directly with your manager, with reasons, before the decision is final if you can. Make your case once, clearly. If the decision goes against you, accept it, unless it's unethical or unsafe, in which case escalate properly.

Then, with your team, explain the decision and carry it out. Don't say "I argued against this, but Daniel insisted." It may feel loyal to your team, but it undermines both you and your manager, and it tells the team that decisions are only as firm as the last complaint.

The same rule protects your team in the other direction. When your manager or another department criticises your team, defend them in that room. Take the criticism yourself, and raise any real problems with the person privately afterwards. Your team will hear about how you spoke for them, and it builds more loyalty than almost anything else you can do.

Daniel approved option two and asked Wei Ling to bring a cost for the contract staff member in two weeks. The meeting took ten minutes.

Pick one real problem on your team that you have been carrying without raising, and put it in writing for your manager in this shape.

Write a short note to your manager about one real problem, with the impact, two options and your recommendation.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).