Compare buying the same fund two ways

Work out the five-year cost of one fund bought at a bank and on a platform, and judge whether the gap is worth paying.

?? Two of these are true. Which one isn't? Sales charges on unit trusts run from 1.5% to 5% of what you put in + A trailer fee is a yearly charge added on top of the expense ratio A seller that takes a sales charge doesn't usually add a redemption fee => The trailer fee is 20% to 60% of the fund's management fee, so it's already inside the expense ratio. Add it again and you've counted it twice. The other two are MoneySense's figures.

---

Same fund, two price tags

[[versus Bank | Platform | Sales charge: 2% / 0% > B | Platform fee: None / 0.3% a year > A | Expense ratio: 1.75% / 1.00% > B | Trailer fee: In the 1.75% / None > B]]

---

Add up the yearly cost once

The bank costs 1.75% a year, its expense ratio.

The platform costs 1.00% + 0.3% = 1.30% a year.

Leave the trailer fee out, since it's already in the 1.75%.

---

S$10,000 for five years

[[grow S$10,000, assuming 6% a year before costs | years | Bank: 0 S$9,800, 3 S$11,103, 5 S$12,067 | Platform: 0 S$10,000, 3 S$11,477, 5 S$12,582]]

The bank takes 2% first, so S$9,800 grows at 6% - 1.75% = 4.25%. =FV(4.25%, 5, 0, -9800) gives S$12,067.20.

---

?^ Over five years on S$10,000, which costs more? The bank's 2% sales charge on day one | 200 | 2% of S$10,000 The platform fee in year one | 30 | 0.3% of S$10,000 The bank's expense ratio in year one | 171.50 | 1.75% of the S$9,800 invested The platform fund's expense ratio in year one | 100 | 1.00% of S$10,000 Everything the bank route costs over five years | 1315.06 | S$13,382.26 with no charges at 6%, minus S$12,067.20 The gap between the two routes | 514.33 | S$1,315.06 minus S$800.73 Everything the platform route costs over five years | 800.73 | S$13,382.26 minus S$12,581.53

---

The bank costs **S$514 more**

[[big S$514 | over five years on S$10,000, assuming 6% a year before costs]]

About S$103 a year. The trailer fee is meant to pay for ongoing advice. Worth it if a review would change what you do, so if not, take the platform.

---

[[order Run your own comparison | Pick one fund both sell, in the cheapest class each offers | Note the sales charge, platform fee and expense ratio | Add up each yearly cost, counting the trailer fee once | Grow S$10,000 for five years in each | Write what the bank gives you for the gap]]

Pick one fund your bank and a platform both sell. In a spreadsheet you keep, fill in both routes for S$10,000 over five years, then write one line on what the gap buys you.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).