What a robo-advisor really costs

Add a robo-advisor's advisory fee and its weighted fund costs into one yearly cost in dollars.

S$20,000 in a robo portfolio for one year. The fees and the S$200 of dividends are examples.

?^ Which costs more in a year? A 0.6% advisory fee | 120 | 0.6% x S$20,000 The funds' own costs, 0.18% weighted | 36 | 0.18% x S$20,000 The robo all in, 0.78% | 156 | S$120 + S$36 US tax on S$200 of dividends from a US-domiciled fund | 60 | 30% x S$200, the usual US rate unless a treaty lowers it A unit trust with a 1.5% expense ratio | 300 | 1.5% x S$20,000 The same S$200 of dividends through an Ireland-domiciled fund | 30 | 15% x S$200, the usual US-Ireland treaty rate A wrap account at about 1% a year | 200 | 1% x S$20,000, MoneySense's figure for wrap fees

---

The advert shows **one of two fees**

[[bridge Advisory fee 120 | Fund costs 36 | All in 156 =]]

Each fund's expense ratio comes out of its price, so it never shows on your statement.

---

Weight each fund's cost by its share

Weight x cost, then add, on S$20,000:

| Fund | Weight | Cost | Share | A year | |---|---|---|---|---| | Developed markets shares | 50% | 0.20% | 0.10% | S$20 | | Emerging markets shares | 10% | 0.25% | 0.025% | S$5 | | Global bonds | 30% | 0.15% | 0.045% | S$9 | | Short-term bonds | 10% | 0.10% | 0.01% | S$2 | | Total | 100% | | 0.18% | S$36 |

---

Tax on dividends **never shows as a fee**

[[flow S$200 of US dividends | 30% US tax, or 15% via an Ireland fund | S$140 or S$170 left]]

It comes out of your returns instead. So does the FX spread on your deposit. Note both beside the all-in cost.

---

Doing it yourself saves the advisory fee

[[versus Robo | Same funds yourself | Fund costs: S$36 / S$36 > tie | Advisory fee: S$120 / S$0 > B | Rebalancing: Automatic / Your job > A]]

About S$120 a year, less brokerage, for rebalancing you might skip.

---

?? S$40,000, two robos. A: 0.8% on the first S$25,000 and 0.5% above, funds at 0.2%. B: a flat 0.6%, funds at 0.25%. Which costs less a year? A, since 0.5% beats 0.6% + B, by S$15 a year A, by S$60 a year => A: S$200 + S$75 + S$80 = S$355. B: S$240 + S$100 = S$340. A's lower rate only covers the S$15,000 above the tier, so check the fee page for which way a robo tiers.

---

[[try robo-advisor-fee | Price one robo on S$20,000]]

Pick one robo portfolio and price it on S$20,000 in the calculator below, with the advisory fee and the weighted fund costs on separate lines.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).