Compare two robo-advisor portfolios with the same share in equities on all-in cost, rebalancing, minimums, withdrawals and SRS or CPF use.
[[doc ad | Growth portfolio | Risk level: High | Equities 80% (1) | Bonds 20% | Advisory fee 0.8% a year (2) | Start from S$1,000 | 1: Another provider's High holds 60%. Same label, different portfolio | 2: The funds inside charge their own fees on top | find 2]]
---
[[flow Search the name in the MAS Financial Institutions Directory | Listed: keep it | Not listed: drop it]]
Robo-advisers have to be licensed by MAS, which is why a provider missing from the directory comes off your list.
---
[[flow A's High: 60% in equities | B's High: 80% | B's next level down: 60% | Compare those two]]
Say these are two providers, and each names its risk levels its own way. The fair comparison is between the two portfolios holding 60%.
---
Say you put S$20,000 into B's 60% portfolio, where the fee is 0.8% and the funds' expense ratios average 0.30%. Add the two together to get the all-in yearly cost.
[[bridge Advisory fee 160 | Fund costs +60 | All-in a year 220 =]]
---
?^ Which costs more in a year? Provider A on S$20,000: a 0.5% fee plus 0.20% in funds | 140 | 0.70% of S$20,000 Provider B on S$20,000 | 220 | 1.10% of S$20,000 Provider B's fee alone on S$20,000 | 160 | 0.8% of S$20,000 Provider A on S$40,000 | 280 | 0.70% of S$40,000 The gap between A and B on S$20,000 | 80 | S$220 minus S$140 Provider B on S$30,000 | 330 | 1.10% of S$30,000 Provider A's funds alone on S$20,000 | 40 | 0.20% of S$20,000 The gap between A and B on S$100,000 | 400 | 0.40% of S$100,000
---
[[big S$400 | a year between A and B on S$100,000, at 0.70% and 1.10%]]
On S$20,000 the same gap is S$80 a year, so work it out on the amount you'll actually put in.
---
[[versus Provider A | Provider B | Rebalances: On drift / Quarterly > tie | To start: S$0 / S$1,000 > A | Withdrawal: 5 days / 7 days > A | SRS: No / Yes > B]]
Not every provider takes SRS money. For CPF, ask CPF Board.
---
?? Provider C charges a 0.6% fee and its funds average 0.25%. On S$20,000, how does it compare with A's S$140 a year? S$120 a year, so C is the cheaper one + S$170, which is S$30 more than A S$50, so C is S$90 cheaper => Adding 0.6% and 0.25% gives 0.85%, and 0.85% of S$20,000 is S$170. S$120 counts the fee alone, without the S$50 from the funds.
---
The source might be the fee page, the factsheet or the FAQ, so note which one and the date you read it. Fees can change, and next year it helps to check each one again at its source.
---
Line up portfolios with the same share in equities, then work out what each one costs in dollars on your own balance.
---
[[try robo-advisor-fee | Compare two on your balance]]
Pick two MAS-licensed robo-advisors, choose the portfolio at each that holds the same share in equities, and put both into the calculator below with your own balance.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).