Why active funds as a group trail the market after costs

Explain why the average active dollar must trail the average passive dollar after costs, using William Sharpe's arithmetic.

?> Two robo-advisors match on everything but one. A uses index funds. B uses active funds and says its managers beat the market after fees. Which do you pick? A, the index funds => You get the market's return minus a small fee. That turns out to be very hard to beat, and the reason is simple sums. B, the managers => Then the real question is whether they can pick winners well enough to cover a bigger fee. Some arithmetic narrows that fast. Can't tell without years of returns => You need less than you think. One argument from 1991 settles most of it with no data at all.

---

Every market has two kinds of owner

[[flow Passive: every share, at its size | Active: everyone else | Together they own 100%]]

Passive holds the whole market, like an index fund. Active is fund managers, stock pickers, hedge funds.

---

?? Say a market returns 8% before costs. Passive owners hold it exactly, so they earn 8%. What does the average active dollar earn before costs? More than 8%, because managers choose which shares to own + Exactly 8%, the same as passive Less than 8%, after trading => The two groups are the whole market. If the whole earned 8% and the passive part earned 8%, the active part did too. One manager makes 15%, another 1%, but weighted by money they average 8%.

---

Then costs come off

Say passive costs 0.2% a year. Active costs 1.5%, mid-range for active funds per MoneySense.

| On S$10,000 | Passive | Active | |---|---|---| | Market return, 8% | S$800 | S$800 | | Costs | -S$20 | -S$150 | | You keep | S$780 | S$650 |

---

A crash doesn't change it

[[big 1.3% | the yearly gap in this example: 1.5% minus 0.2%]]

Say the market falls 30%. Both groups fall 30% before costs, and active still pays more. Economist William Sharpe made this argument in 1991.

---

[[crowd Of every 100 active large-cap US equity funds, how many did worse than the S&P 500? | 79 | did worse than the S&P 500 | SPIVA U.S. scorecard. It counts funds, not dollars, so it isn't Sharpe's sum exactly. It points the same way.]]

---

21 won. **Which 21** is the hard part

Every year, some active funds beat the market. Last year's winners aren't reliably next year's. So B's claim comes down to one thing: can they pick winners in advance, often enough to cover the extra fee?

---

Passive here means the whole market

The sum assumes a fund that holds every share at its size and charges little. A narrow index fund that trades a lot or charges a lot gets no such promise.

---

What does your fund's fee cost?

Market at 8% before costs. Your fund's factsheet shows its TER, usually 1.0% to 2.5%, per MoneySense.

[[whatif Total expense ratio, TER (%) | fee 0.2 to 2.5 step 0.1 | fees start 10000 years 1 return 8 fee 1.5 | What the fee costs on S$10,000 in a year]]

Open the factsheet of a fund you hold or were offered, find its total expense ratio (TER), and set the TER slider in this lesson to it.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).