When an active fee might be worth paying

List the conditions an active fund must meet, after fees and against its own category, before you would pay its fee.

[[versus The sales pitch | A fair test | Against: The STI / Its own category > B | Returns: Best recent year / After fees, full cycle > B | Proof: Its own chart / Two independent scorecards > B | Rules written: After the chart / Before any chart > B]]

---

Every fee comes off your return

An active fund has to earn its costs back before it beats anything.

Say you put in S$10,000. The index fund's 0.3% is a typical figure. The rest are examples inside MoneySense's ranges.

---

?^ Which costs more in a year on S$10,000? An index fund with a 0.3% expense ratio | 30 | S$10,000 x 0.3% An active fund with a 1.75% expense ratio | 175 | S$10,000 x 1.75% A fund platform fee of 0.2% a year | 20 | S$10,000 x 0.2% An adviser's wrap fee of 1% a year | 100 | S$10,000 x 1% The seller's 40% cut of a fund's 1.5% management fee, paid from that fee and not on top | 60 | S$10,000 x 1.5% x 40% A 3% sales charge, paid in year one | 300 | S$10,000 x 3% One switch to another fund from the same manager, at 1% | 100 | S$10,000 x 1%

---

The gap the fund has to **win back**

[[big S$145 | a year on S$10,000, 1.75% against 0.3%]]

It needs that lead yearly to tie. A 3% sales charge makes year one S$445.

Under CPFIS: no sales charge, a 0.4% wrap fee cap, and the OA's 2.5% this quarter to beat.

---

?? An Asia ex-Japan fund beat the STI by 2% a year over five years, after fees. What should you set it against? The STI, because it's the number the adviser quoted + An Asia ex-Japan index fund over the same years A world index fund, the widest test => The fund holds different shares in different markets from the STI. The fair test is the cheapest way to own what it actually holds.

---

Last year's winner is a weak clue

[[flow A great year | Did it hold up through a rise and a fall? | Same manager, same approach? | Worth a closer look]]

SPIVA's persistence scorecards show how often top funds stay on top. Check the one for your category.

---

Check a second scorecard

Morningstar's Active/Passive Barometer sets active funds against index funds you can buy, not the index itself. If both agree on your category, trust the verdict more.

---

Write your test before you see the chart

Say yours read:

1. Beats a same-category index fund after all fees, over ten years or more. 2. Same lead manager for most of that time. 3. Costs at most one percentage point a year more than the index fund.

---

[[try active-vs-passive-investing | Test a fund you've been offered]]

Before you open any fund's chart, write three conditions it must meet to earn its fee over an index fund, in the spreadsheet or note where you track your investments.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).