Test one active fund against its benchmark and a similar index fund after fees, and work out the yearly hurdle it must clear.
Worked example: S$10,000, ten years ago.
[[doc statement | Index fund instead S$17,908 | Extra fees -S$2,415 (1) | Sales charge, lost growth -S$493 (2) | Manager beat the index +S$951 | Your fund today S$15,951 | 1: 1.75% vs 0.30% a year | 2: S$300 upfront, plus its growth | find 2 | case Not a cost.]]
---
[[bridge Index fund 17908 | Extra fees -2415 | Sales charge -493 | Manager's edge 951 | Your fund 15951 =]]
Before fees, the manager beat the index by about 0.55% a year. The fund also charged 1.45% a year more than the index fund.
---
Take annualised returns for the longest period, NAV to NAV: after running costs, before your sales charge.
| Ten years | After costs | Yearly cost | Before costs | |---|---|---|---| | Your fund | 5.1% | 1.75% | about 6.85% | | Index fund | 6.0% | 0.30% | about 6.3% | | Benchmark | 6.3% | none | 6.3% |
---
[[big 1.45% | a year: 1.75% for the fund minus 0.30% for the index fund]]
The manager has to beat the index by that much, before costs, to leave you level. A 3% sales charge held ten years adds about 0.3% a year.
---
?? Your fund holds mostly Asian banks and tech companies. Which benchmark makes its record a fair test? A 12-month fixed deposit rate + An Asia ex-Japan share index A world tech index => A benchmark should hold roughly what the fund holds, so set the two country and sector splits side by side. Against a deposit rate, almost any share fund looks good. If the fund ever switched benchmarks, the annual report says so.
---
Over ten years my fund returned 5.1% a year after costs, the index fund 6.0%. So it hasn't earned its fee: the manager beat the index by about 0.55% a year before costs, short of the 1.45% hurdle.
It describes the past and forecasts nothing.
---
[[whatif Your fund's yearly cost | fee 0.25 to 2.5 step 0.25 | fees start 10000 years 10 return 6 fee 1.75 | Cost on S$10,000 over ten years, at 6% before fees]]
Try your fund's expense ratio, then an index fund's. No sales charge with CPF money, but it must beat your OA's 2.5% this quarter.
---
[[try active-vs-passive-investing | Test your own fund]]
From your fund's latest factsheet and one index fund's factsheet, copy each ten-year return and yearly cost, work out the hurdle, then write two sentences on whether your fund has earned its fee.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).