Compare four managed options over 20 years using the same inputs and each option's own charges, and price what each service costs you.
[[big S$37,905 | the 20-year cost of a fund charging 2% to buy and 1.75% a year, on S$10,000 plus S$300 a month at an assumed 6%]]
You put in S$82,000. This is how far the fund ends below the same money with no charges.
---
[[drawit How does that S$37,905 build up over the 20 years? | years | 20 | points 0 200, 2 882, 4 1969, 6 3539, 8 5684, 10 8512, 12 12145, 14 16725, 16 22415, 18 29403, 20 37905]]
---
[[bars First 10 years 8512 | Next 5 years 10908 | Last 5 years 18485 | of S$37,905]]
The 1.75% comes off a bigger balance every year, and takes that year's growth with it.
---
Say these are yours. Take every charge from the option's own factsheet or fee page.
| Option | To buy | A year | |---|---|---| | Bank unit trust | 2% | 1.75% | | Same fund, platform | 0% | 1% fund + 0.3% platform | | Robo-advisor | 0% | 0.75% | | ETF you buy | 0.3% | 0.2% |
---
S$10,000 to start, S$300 a month, 6% a year before costs, 20 years. The 6% keeps it fair. It isn't a forecast.
If you're investing CPF savings, CPFIS unit trusts have no sales charge, so put 0% to buy.
---
``` No charges: =FV(6%/12, 240, -300, -10000) = S$171,714 Bank fund: =FV((6%-1.75%)/12, 240, -300*0.98, -10000*0.98) = S$133,809 ```
The yearly cost comes off the 6%. A 2% sales charge leaves 0.98 of every payment. Cost: S$171,714 - S$133,809 = S$37,905.
[[sum The platform route ends at S$144,681. Its 20-year cost? | S$27,033 | 62,681 => That's its growth over what you put in. Measure from the no-charge S$171,714. | => S$171,714 - S$144,681 = S$27,033.]]
---
| | Ends at | Cost | Behind the ETF | |---|---|---|---| | Bank | S$133,809 | S$37,905 | S$32,874 | | Platform | S$144,681 | S$27,033 | S$22,002 | | Robo | S$155,445 | S$16,270 | S$11,238 | | ETF | S$166,683 | S$5,031 | S$0 |
Cheapest, and you do the work: monthly buys, rebalancing, records.
---
| Pair | What separates them | Its price | |---|---|---| | Bank vs platform | Adviser reviews, plus the 2% sales charge | S$10,872 | | Robo vs ETF | Someone picks and rebalances your mix | S$11,238 |
S$144,681 - S$133,809 = S$10,872. S$166,683 - S$155,445 = S$11,238.
---
| Option | What you get | |---|---| | Bank | A yearly adviser review | | Platform | Same fund, no advice | | Robo | Your mix picked and rebalanced | | ETF | Lowest cost, you do it all |
Say yours ends: "Rebalancing is worth S$11,238 to me. The reviews aren't worth S$10,872."
---
?? Two routes into the same fund. With yearly adviser reviews it ends at S$118,400, without them at S$127,900. What do the reviews cost you over 20 years? Nothing extra, since you own the same fund either way + S$9,500, the gap between the two endings One year's adviser fee, times 20 => The gap counts the fees and the growth they took. Find two options that differ mainly by one service, and the gap in their endings is its price.
---
[[checklist Is your comparison ready? | Four options you'd really choose between | Charges from each option's own documents | The same inputs in all four | A no-charge line to measure against | Each option's 20-year cost in dollars | What each service costs you, in dollars | 0-3 => Fill the gaps before you trust the table | 4-5 => Nearly there: finish the last lines | 6 => Ready. Now decide which services are worth it]]
In a spreadsheet you keep, run your four options through FV with the same inputs, then write each one's 20-year cost in dollars and the service you'd pay extra for.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).