Where the FX cost hides in a US trade

You will be able to pick out the spread, the fee and the reference rate in any currency conversion, and add them up.

Hakim (an invented example, as are all his figures) wants to buy a US fund, so he shifts S$5,000 out of his savings and into his brokerage account. The app says the conversion is free, and the little over US$3,667 that lands in his account seems reasonable until Rachel looks up the exchange rate on her phone and tells him it should have been about US$3,704.

Nobody charged Hakim a fee, yet changing his money cost him about S$50. The cost was inside the exchange rate his broker gave him.

The rate on the screen and the rate you get

Banks and large dealers trade currencies with each other all day. In that wholesale market there are always two prices for US dollars at any moment: a price at which dealers buy, and a slightly higher price at which they sell. Halfway between those two is the mid-market rate. Search results, news sites and currency apps show exchange rate quotes, but these are indicative reference rates, not rates a retail customer can deal at. Google, for example, says it cannot guarantee the accuracy of the rates it displays and that you should confirm current rates before making any transaction. Only traders inside the wholesale market can deal at mid-market, and you and your broker are outside it.

When you convert, your provider buys or sells US dollars for you at a rate it sets itself, and that rate usually leaves you a little worse off than mid-market. The difference between the provider's rate and the mid-market rate is the spread. Because it sits inside the price, you pay it even when the app says "no fee".

Some providers add a separate charge every time you convert, either a fixed sum or a percentage of the amount, occasionally with a minimum. Add that charge to the spread and you have the total cost of a conversion. A provider with a fee and a narrow spread can work out cheaper than one with no fee and a wide spread, so you need both figures before you can judge which costs less.

Hakim's numbers

When Hakim converted, mid-market was S$1.3500 per US dollar. His broker gave him S$1.3635 per US dollar.

Dividing his S$5,000 by 1.35 gives about US$3,703.70, which is what he would have received at mid-market. Dividing it by 1.3635 gives about US$3,667.03, which is what he actually received. He is short by about US$36.67, worth about S$49.50 at the mid-market rate, and that is the roughly S$50 Rachel noticed.

The percentage takes one division and one subtraction: divide the rate he received by mid-market, then take away 1. For Hakim, 1.3635 / 1.35 - 1 = 1.0%. About 1% of his money went on changing currency alone, before the fund charged anything of its own and before any commission.

Most investors in Singapore convert twice. They change SGD into USD to buy, and later change USD back into SGD so they can spend the money here. The spread applies each time, so across the life of the investment the cost roughly doubles. For Hakim that is about 1% going in and 1% coming out, around 2% of the money, before any change in the fund's price.

A broker that automatically turns each US dividend back into SGD charges the spread on every one of those payments as well. Lesson 2.2, "Convert per trade, in bulk, or hold US dollars", shows ways to reduce these repeated costs, including the spread taken on dividends converted automatically.

Setting two brokers side by side

A broker advertising "zero commission" on US trades may save you real money, but commission is only one of the costs. To compare providers, write down every cost for each one (commission, spread and any explicit fee), turn each into Singapore dollars, total them per broker, and see which total is lower.

Suppose you are buying S$3,000 of a US fund and choosing between Broker A and Broker B (both invented). Broker A has no commission and a 0.6% spread, so the trade costs you about S$18. Broker B charges US$2 in commission, about S$2.70, and has a 0.1% spread, about S$3, which comes to about S$5.70 in total. Broker A's commission-free trade costs more than three times what Broker B's does.

Change the trade size or the spreads and the cheaper broker can change too. What you carry into your own decisions is the method of adding up every cost in SGD, which matters more than which of these two brokers came out ahead.

Finding your own spread

A few brokers publish their spread or markup in their fee schedule. Many don't, and then you have to work it out yourself from a conversion you have made. For that you need the rate shown on your confirmation, the time the conversion went through, and the mid-market rate at that time.

Get the rate from your trade or conversion confirmation. If the confirmation lists only the two currency amounts, divide one by the other to get the rate. Write down when the conversion happened. Look up mid-market for that time on a currency data site. Plenty of them keep historical rates by the hour or by the minute. Pick the quote nearest to your conversion time, since rates shift through the day and a few hours' difference can hide a small spread. Divide your rate by the mid-market rate and take away 1 to get the spread as a percentage. If you also want the amount, work out what mid-market would have given you, subtract what you actually received, and convert that difference to SGD at mid-market. Check the broker's fee schedule for any explicit conversion fee, and add it to the spread to get the total cost.

Now pick one conversion you made in the last few months. Find the rate you received and the mid-market rate at that time, then work out the gap the way Hakim's was worked out above. If the result is close to zero, you have learned that your provider prices tightly. If it is near 1%, you have found a cost worth acting on in the next lesson.

Find a recent conversion you made. Look up the mid-market rate at that time, compare it with the rate you got, and write the gap as a percentage.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).