You will be able to explain how currency moves change your return in SGD, apart from what you paid to convert.
Open your broker's app, pick one holding priced in US dollars, and look at its return twice: once in US dollars and once in Singapore dollars. The two figures usually differ, and fees explain only part of the gap.
Take Hakim, who bought shares in a US company a year ago. He is pleased that his app shows the share price up 6% in US dollars (an example figure). When he switches the display to Singapore dollars, he sees a small loss. He rechecks the fees, and they are what he expected. The rest of the gap comes from what the US dollar did while he held the shares. It has nothing to do with conversion costs.
Conversion cost is the spread and fees you pay each time you change money from one currency to another. The spread is the gap between the rate at which a provider buys a currency and the rate at which it sells it. Lessons 2.1 and 2.2 covered it. Currency risk is the change in your result caused by the exchange rate moving while you are invested. The two are separate, and confusing them leads to the wrong fixes.
For an asset priced in US dollars, your Singapore-dollar return depends on two things: the asset's return in US dollars, and how much the US dollar rose or fell against the Singapore dollar over the same period. A strengthening US dollar adds to your Singapore-dollar return, and a weakening one reduces it. This means an asset can rise in US dollars and still lose money in Singapore dollars.
Write the asset's return in its own currency as a decimal and add 1, so +10% becomes 1.10. Do the same for the currency's move against the Singapore dollar, so -8% becomes 0.92. Multiply the two numbers and subtract 1. The result is your return in Singapore dollars: 1.10 times 0.92, minus 1, gives 1.2%.
For a quick estimate, add the two percentages: 10% minus 8% gives 2%. This is close enough only when both moves are small. The Build and run an ETF portfolio course works through the same formula in more depth for whole portfolios.
In made-up figures, Hakim invested S$13,500 when the rate was S$1.35 per US dollar. S$13,500 divided by 1.35 bought US$10,000 of a US stock. One year later the stock is worth US$11,000, up 10%. Over the same year the US dollar fell 8% against the Singapore dollar, so US$1 now equals S$1.242. US$11,000 times 1.242 converts to S$13,662. Against the S$13,500 he put in, his gain is S$162, or 1.2%, although the stock rose 10%.
The same steps work for any holding. Divide the Singapore-dollar amount invested by the starting rate to get the foreign-currency amount bought. Apply the asset's return to get its current foreign-currency value. Apply the currency move to the starting rate to get the new rate. Multiply the current value by the new rate, and compare the result with the Singapore-dollar amount you started with.
If the stock had risen 6% instead, 1.06 times 0.92, minus 1, is about minus 2.5%, which matches what Hakim's app showed. If the stock had risen 10% and the US dollar had risen 5%, 1.10 times 1.05, minus 1, is 15.5%. Once Hakim can see the split, he stops looking for a hidden fee and notes the currency move instead.
Some funds offer a currency-hedged share class, a version of the fund that uses financial instruments to reduce the currency exposure between the fund's currency and the share class currency. A hedged class priced in Singapore dollars aims to give a return close to the underlying return, without the US dollar swings. Hedging comes at an additional cost. The fund documents describe the hedging method and its costs, so read them and don't assume a hedged class is a free version of the same fund. Whether to hedge is a portfolio decision this course does not cover. Build and run an ETF portfolio, lesson 5.3, "Hedged share classes: when they help", deals with it.
A common reaction is to wait for a better exchange rate before converting. It feels like control but does not remove currency risk. Your exposure comes from holding foreign-currency assets, for as long as you hold them, and does not come from the moment you convert. A good rate today does nothing about what the US dollar does over the next ten years.
Asking when to convert is the wrong question. The useful one is how much of your money should depend on foreign currencies at all, given what you are saving for. Money you will spend in Singapore dollars in two years is highly exposed to a currency swing, while money for retirement in thirty years has time for swings in both directions. The Build and run an ETF portfolio course sets out how to decide your limits on foreign-currency exposure for your goals. This course covers only the mechanics: knowing which part of a result came from the asset and which came from the currency.
To run the same split on one of your own holdings, you need its price a year ago, its price now, and the exchange rate at both dates. The MAS website publishes exchange rate data you can use for the rates.
Choose one overseas holding and split its return over the past year into two parts: what came from the asset price and what came from the exchange rate.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).