You will be able to work out every cost of buying and later selling a US-listed share or ETF, in SGD.
When you buy a US-listed fund or share and later sell it, you pay costs on both sides, and most people judge those costs by guessing. One common claim is that small trades are a waste because fees eat them. Another is that fees don't matter if you hold for years. Both claims are guesses, and you can replace them with a number you calculate yourself: what one round trip (buying, then later selling) costs at different trade sizes, and the smallest trade size worth making. For this hands-on exercise you need your broker's fee schedule, a recent trade or conversion confirmation, and a spreadsheet.
Go through the fee schedule and list every cost line that applies to buying or selling a US-listed share or ETF (a fund that trades on a stock exchange like a share). The common ones are:
commission per order, sometimes a percentage with a minimum platform or account fees charged per order exchange and regulatory fees, often passed through on sales and usually small an explicit conversion fee, if your broker charges one the FX (foreign exchange) spread, the gap between the rate your broker gives you and the mid-market rate, which you measured in Lesson 2.1, "Where the FX cost hides in a US trade"
Mark each line as fixed or variable. A fixed cost is the same in dollars whatever the trade size. A variable cost scales with trade size. A commission with a minimum acts as a fixed cost for small trades and as a variable cost for large ones.
Add up the fixed costs for the round trip (the buy plus the sell, including fees passed on at sale) and convert the total to SGD. The FX spread applies twice: once when you convert SGD to buy, and again when you convert the sale proceeds back. Round-trip FX cost is 2 x the one-way spread, as a percentage of trade size. Total round-trip cost % = (fixed costs + FX cost) / trade size.
Rachel wants to buy a US-listed fund every month with S$500 (an example figure). One friend tells her small trades are a waste because fees eat them, and another says fees don't matter if you hold for years. She works it out instead. Her broker is made up so you can check your method against hers.
The broker charges a commission of US$1.50 per order and a platform fee of US$1 per order. Exchange and regulatory fees passed on at sale round up to US$0.10. The FX spread is 0.3% each way, with no separate conversion fee. The exchange rate is S$1.35 per US dollar throughout, and the fund price is assumed not to change, so only the costs move.
Buying costs US$1.50 + US$1 = US$2.50 in fixed fees. Selling costs US$2.50 + US$0.10 = US$2.60. The round-trip fixed cost is US$5.10, about S$6.89, whether she trades S$500 or S$10,000. Round-trip FX is 0.3% x 2 = 0.6% of trade size, which is S$3 at S$500, S$12 at S$2,000 and S$60 at S$10,000.
At S$500 the total is S$6.89 + S$3 = about S$9.89, about 1.98%. At S$2,000 it is S$6.89 + S$12 = about S$18.89, or 0.94%. At S$10,000 it is S$6.89 + S$60 = about S$66.89, or 0.67%.
At small sizes the fixed costs dominate, and the percentage falls quickly as the trade grows. At large sizes the FX spread dominates, and the percentage flattens out near the round-trip spread, 0.6% here. No trade size can get below the spread. Note which line is biggest at the sizes you usually trade. If it's the spread, go back to Lesson 2.2, "Convert per trade, in bulk, or hold US dollars". If it's the fixed costs, the lever is trading less often in larger amounts.
There is no correct cost level to accept. Someone holding for twenty years may accept more than someone who expects to sell in three years. Write your level down before you calculate, so the answer doesn't talk you into it. Then solve for your minimum sensible trade, the smallest trade size whose round-trip cost stays under your accepted percentage: fixed costs / (accepted % minus round-trip spread %).
Rachel sets her limit at 1%. At that limit, S$6.89 + 0.6% x size = 1% x size, so S$6.89 has to fit into the remaining 0.4%. S$6.89 / 0.004 = about S$1,722. Below S$1,722 her round trip costs more than 1%, and at S$500 a month she would pay close to 2% per round trip with this broker.
When small trades cost more than your limit, you can invest less often in larger amounts, or find a broker with lower fixed costs for small trades. Rachel could invest quarterly, about S$1,500 at a time (3 x S$500), which still sits a little above 1%. She could also look for a broker with lower fixed costs for small trades. Whichever she picks, she decides based on a number she worked out herself.
Lay out the sheet in the order you worked through above. Start with the cost lines marked fixed or variable, then the round-trip fixed costs in SGD, then the FX cost and totals at each size, and last your accepted level and minimum trade.
Your finished calculator shows each cost line with its source in the fee schedule, the round-trip total in Singapore dollars and as a percentage at S$500, S$2,000 and S$10,000, and one sentence naming your accepted level and the smallest trade size that meets it. Use your own broker's schedule and your own measured spread, not the made-up figures above, and keep the sheet so you can rerun it when the broker changes its fees.
Fill in the round-trip cost calculator for one real broker. Then write down the smallest trade size at which total costs drop below a level you are willing to pay.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).