Why 30% of a US dividend never reaches you

Explain how US dividend withholding works and why Singapore residents pay a higher rate than residents of some other countries.

Rachel lives in Singapore and owns units in a US fund. When the fund paid its first dividend in March, its announcement put her share at US$50, but only US$35 arrived in her account (all of Rachel's figures are made up for illustration). After twenty minutes of searching for the other US$15, she found a statement line marked tax withheld, at a rate of 30%. She assumed that either her broker had got it wrong or Singapore had taxed her. Neither had happened. The US collected its portion before the payment got to her.

How the US collects tax from foreign shareholders

The US taxes some kinds of income that US sources pay to people who are neither US citizens nor US residents. The US tax term for such a person is non-resident alien. Dividends paid by US companies are one of the kinds of income taxed this way.

The IRS is the US tax authority. It cannot collect small sums from millions of shareholders abroad one person at a time, so the job falls on whoever pays. When a dividend goes to a foreign holder, the payer, or the custodian passing the money on, has to keep back part of it and send that part to the IRS. Tax collected this way, at source and before the holder gets anything, is called withholding tax.

The 30% rate and the missing treaty

US rules set 30% as the standard withholding rate on dividends paid to non-resident aliens. A tax treaty between the US and the holder's home country can set a lower rate, and many countries have an income tax treaty with the US that reduces the rate on dividends. Singapore has no income tax treaty with the US, so you have no treaty rate to claim. A Singapore resident with US shares therefore usually has the full 30% taken from every dividend. This applies to almost every Singapore resident who holds US shares or US-domiciled funds.

You may know people in other countries who keep more of their US dividends. Their country's treaty with the US lowers the rate for them. Your broker has not caused the gap and nothing is wrong with your account. The difference comes from the tax relationship between the two countries. What gets deducted is US tax. Singapore is not charging it and your broker has not miscalculated.

When you opened your account you probably signed a W-8BEN, the form confirming you are not a US person. The form matters, but for someone resident in Singapore it does not bring the rate below 30%. Lesson 3.2, "What the W-8BEN does and does not do", explains the form.

Reading a dividend on your broker statement

By the time a dividend shows in your account, the tax has already been taken. The company pays out, and the payment moves down the custody chain described in Lesson 1.1. At some point along that chain, usually at the US custodian or at your broker, 30% is set aside for the IRS and the rest is credited to you.

A good statement gives three figures for each dividend: the gross amount declared, the tax withheld, and the net amount credited. Brokers lay these out differently. Some show the gross and the tax as separate entries dated the same day. Others show only the net figure on the main screen, and you have to open the activity detail or the monthly statement to see the tax. The tax entry may be labelled withholding tax, non-resident tax, or a short code.

Rachel's statement had two entries on the same date: a US$50.00 dividend and a tax entry of minus US$15.00. US$15 divided by US$50 is 30%, which confirmed the cause. US$50 minus US$15 is the US$35 she received.

To check any dividend of your own:

find the dividend entry on the main screen, in the activity detail, or in the monthly statement write down the gross amount declared find the tax withheld entry, which may read withholding tax, non-resident tax, or a short code write down the net amount credited divide the tax withheld by the gross amount to get the rate if you cannot find the tax entry, the broker's help pages or support team can tell you where it appears

US-domiciled funds and money from selling shares

An ETF or fund set up in the US is a US-domiciled fund. Its ordinary dividends are generally treated the same way as dividends from a US company, even when it holds companies from around the world. When it pays an ordinary dividend, that is a US payer paying a foreign holder, so 30% is withheld. Not every payout is treated this way. Certain distributions that a fund reports as interest-related dividends or short-term capital gain dividends are exempt from this withholding for non-resident aliens. The fund's distribution notices show how each payout is labelled, and the IRS sets out the current rules in Publication 515. Funds set up in Ireland change the arithmetic, and Module 5 covers them. For a portfolio comparison of US-domiciled and Ireland-domiciled funds, see lesson 3.3, "Domicile and withholding tax on dividends", in the course "Build and run an ETF portfolio".

Withholding applies only to dividends. It does not apply to capital gains a non-resident makes when selling US shares. If Rachel buys a US share for US$100 and later sells it for US$130, the US withholds nothing from the US$30 gain. There are exceptions for people who spend long periods in the US and for some special kinds of asset. A Singapore resident trading listed US shares from Singapore receives sale proceeds without any US tax taken.

This affects choices you make later. A holding that pays most of its return as dividends loses 30% of that portion. A holding that pays little and grows in price loses less to withholding. Lesson 3.4 works through the numbers.

For the activity, find one US dividend on your own statement. Look for the gross amount, the tax line and the net amount, write all three down, and divide the tax by the gross to check the rate. If your result is not 30%, note what you found and ask your broker why.

Find a US dividend on your statement. Write down the gross amount, the tax withheld and the net amount, then check what rate was used.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).