Work out the after-tax yield on a US holding

Calculate what a US-listed holding pays you each year after withholding and conversion costs.

The yield a comparison site shows for a US-listed holding is the gross figure, so it isn't the amount you get. It is taken before US withholding tax and before the dividends are changed back into Singapore dollars. You can find what you actually get with four steps and a small table.

Take Hakim (an invented example), a Singapore resident putting together the income side of his portfolio. He has narrowed his choice to two US-listed holdings, a fund and a single US company. A comparison site lists the fund at 1.4% and the company at 3.0%. He intends to invest S$20,000 in each (example figures).

Getting the yield from the issuer

Start with the trailing dividend yield. This is the total dividends paid in the last twelve months divided by the current price. A fund publishes this figure on its factsheet or website, so take it from there. For a company, use its own dividend announcements together with the current share price. You can also work it out yourself: add up the dividends per share from the last twelve months and divide by today's price.

Comparison sites are a reasonable place to find holdings, but their yields are less reliable. The number may be out of date, it may cover a different period, or it may include a one-off special dividend. Whichever figure goes into your table, write down where you got it and the date you checked it.

A yield describes the past. It tells you what was paid and can't tell you what will be paid. The course Dividend stocks and S-REITs covers how to judge whether the dividends themselves will hold up.

When Hakim checks the issuers' own figures, they give the same trailing yields: 1.4% for the fund and 3.0% for the company. With S$20,000 in each, he would receive S$280 and S$600 a year before tax.

Removing the 30% US withholding tax

As a Singapore resident, you usually have 30% of each US dividend withheld. Lesson 3.1, "Why 30% of a US dividend never reaches you", explains the rule. You keep 70%, so your net yield is the gross yield multiplied by 0.7.

Hakim's fund drops to 1.4% x 0.7 = 0.98%, which is S$196 a year. His company drops to 3.0% x 0.7 = 2.1%, or S$420 a year. Before tax, the company paid S$320 a year more than the fund. After tax, the difference is S$224. The higher the yield, the more withholding takes in dollar terms.

Allowing for the currency conversion

You pay the FX spread from Lesson 2.1 every time a dividend is converted to SGD. That applies whether your broker converts it automatically or you convert it later to spend. To allow for it, multiply the net yield by (1 minus the spread).

Hakim pays 0.5% on each conversion (an example figure), so his multiplier is 0.995. The fund moves from 0.98% to about 0.975%, roughly S$195.02 a year. The company moves from 2.1% to about 2.089%, roughly S$417.90 a year.

The conversion cost changes the result less than withholding does, but you pay it on every dividend. If your spread is closer to 1%, or your broker charges a minimum fee on each conversion, small dividends lose a bigger share.

Some investors keep a USD balance and reinvest their dividends in USD, as described in Lesson 2.2. If you do this, leave out this step for now. Add a note in your table that you will pay the spread when you convert later.

Building and reading the comparison table

Give each holding its own row, with six columns:

holding where the yield came from and the date you checked it gross yield net yield after withholding net yield after FX yearly amount in SGD for the amount you hold

In Hakim's table, the fund shows 1.4%, 0.98%, about 0.975% and about S$195 a year. The company shows 3.0%, 2.1%, about 2.089% and about S$418 a year.

Compare the last column with the quoted gross yield. Each of Hakim's holdings pays him a little under 70% of its headline yield, and the site's 3.0% comes to about 2.09% for him.

The table also stops you from comparing a US holding at its gross yield with a Singapore holding whose dividends arrive without withholding. If you compare them that way, the US holding always looks better than it is.

The table can't tell you which holding to choose. After-tax yield is only one input, and dividends are only part of the return. A holding with a lower yield may grow more in price, and Lesson 3.1 notes that price gains are not withheld for a non-resident. Other courses cover comparing total returns and deciding how much income you want from a portfolio.

Now build your own table for two holdings you own or are considering. Use each issuer's own figures, your own measured FX spread and your own holding sizes, and write the date beside each yield.

Pick two holdings you own or are considering. In one table, work out the gross yield, the net yield after withholding and the net yield after FX for each.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).