Explain why an Irish-domiciled fund holding US shares can lose less of its dividends to withholding tax.
Two index funds can hold the same US companies and still pay you different amounts of dividend. The difference comes from where each fund is legally based. That country is the fund's domicile, and it decides how much US tax comes off a dividend before you get it. For an investor in Singapore, the comparison that usually comes up is a fund domiciled in the US against one domiciled in Ireland.
Take Rachel, who lives in Singapore and invests on her own. She has two funds side by side that track the same index of large US companies. One is US-domiciled and listed in New York. The other is Irish-domiciled and listed in London. She has read a forum post saying the Irish fund "halves the dividend tax". She wants to know what that means in dollars on her own holding, and whether the post is right.
Withholding is tax taken from a dividend before it is paid on to the next person. When US companies pay dividends to a US-domiciled fund, they pay in full. The fund is a US entity, so no withholding is taken at that stage.
The withholding happens when the fund passes the dividends on to Rachel. For US tax purposes she is a non-resident alien, and Singapore has no tax treaty with the US, so 30% is withheld. Lesson 3.1, "Why 30% of a US dividend never reaches you", explained this rule and showed how the 30% appears as a tax line on your statement.
Ireland has a tax treaty with the US. Under that treaty, US dividends paid to an Irish fund are generally withheld at 15%, as the funds' own documents describe. The tax is taken at fund level, at half the rate that applies to the US fund.
The next question is whether Ireland takes any more tax when the fund pays dividends out or keeps them in the fund. For investors who are not Irish, fund documents generally describe no further Irish tax on distributions, subject to the conditions they set out. For the exact treatment, rely on the prospectus.
In both cases Singapore does not tax dividends received by individuals, as lesson 3.3, "How Singapore treats the dividends that reach you", explained. So for US dividends the comparison comes down to 30% against 15%.
If a fund holds companies outside the US, there are more layers. Those companies' home countries take their own withholding, at rates set by their treaties with the fund's domicile. A US-domiciled fund holding non-US companies loses two layers: first the foreign withholding, then the US 30% when the fund pays you. The course "Build and run an ETF portfolio", lesson 3.3, "Domicile and withholding tax on dividends", covers this case.
The saving applies only to the dividend part of your return, and only to dividends from US companies. How big it is depends on the fund's dividend yield. To estimate it, take the fund's stated dividend yield from its factsheet and multiply by your holding to get your yearly dividends. Multiply those dividends by 30% for a US-domiciled fund and by 15% for an Irish-domiciled fund. Subtract one from the other to get the yearly difference, then divide by your holding to express it as a percentage. Compare that percentage with the differences in expense ratios covered in lesson 5.3.
Rachel uses an index dividend yield of 1.5% a year and a holding of S$20,000 (both invented figures for the example). 1.5% of S$20,000 is S$300 in dividends a year. Through the US fund, 30% of S$300 is S$90 withheld. Through the Irish fund, 15% of S$300 is S$45. The difference is S$90 - S$45 = S$45 a year, which is 0.225% of S$20,000.
So the forum post is roughly right, with conditions. The withholding is halved. Rachel's total costs are not, and S$45 a year will not change her life. Even so, a yearly saving of this size can be larger than the fee difference between many competing index funds, and it repeats every year on a balance that keeps growing.
With the US-domiciled fund, the 30% appears as a tax line on your own statement. With the Irish fund, the 15% does not appear anywhere on your statement. It is fund-level withholding, taken inside the fund before any distribution. You see it only as a slightly lower return than the index would have earned with no tax. It forms part of the fund's tracking difference, the gap between the fund's return and the index's return. Some indexes are calculated net of withholding, so fund documents state which version of the index they compare against.
Don't take any of this from a forum post. Two documents confirm the treatment:
the tax section of the prospectus, which sets out the fund's position on withholding and how distributions to investors are treated the annual report, which shows what the fund actually received and paid
Check that both match what you expect, and check their dates, before you rely on the saving. The 15% depends on the treaty and on the fund meeting its conditions, and treaties can change. Some funds use other methods, such as holding swaps instead of shares. That changes the tax picture again, and the fund's documents describe how.
For the activity, take your two funds from lesson 5.1. Use each fund's stated dividend yield from its factsheet and your own holding size to estimate the yearly withholding cost through each, as Rachel did. Note which documents you used.
Take each fund's stated dividend yield and estimate what withholding costs you each year in the US-domiciled and the Irish-domiciled version of one index.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).