Convert a quoted return into a real, geometric figure, and explain why the arithmetic average makes results look better than they were.
Return figures turn up in apps, brochures and conversations with friends, and they are rarely labelled well enough to compare. Two numbers that look alike can measure different things, and a number that looks healthy can describe money that shrank.
Say your brokerage app shows a fund averaging 8% a year over five years, a friend's robo-advisor shows 6%, and your own account, after a bad 2022, feels like it has gone nowhere (an illustrative scenario). All three numbers could be true, and none of them may mean what you assume. An analyst's first habit is to refuse a return figure until four questions are answered. Is it nominal or real? Is it an arithmetic average or a compounded one? Does it include dividends, or only the price change? Is it in the currency you spend? Lessons 1.2 and 1.3 cover dividends and currency. The first two questions are worked through below.
A nominal return is the change in a holding's dollar value before any adjustment. If S$10,000 becomes S$10,700 in a year, the nominal return is 7% (an invented example). That gain overstates what the money can buy, because shop prices also rose over the same year. A real return is the nominal return with inflation removed. To work it out, add 1 to the nominal return, add 1 to the inflation rate, divide the first by the second, and subtract 1. As a formula, that is (1 + nominal return) / (1 + inflation) - 1.
Take a made-up year with a 7% nominal return and 3% inflation. 1.07 / 1.03 - 1 gives about 3.9% real. Subtracting inflation from the nominal return gives 4%, which is only an approximation and slightly overstates the real return. The gap between the two looks small in one year and grows over a working life. Real return is the number that matters for any goal measured in what money buys, such as retirement income or a child's university fees. For current inflation, look up the consumer price index (CPI) published by the Department of Statistics, or the core inflation measure published by MAS, and don't rely on a figure someone quotes to you.
The second question is about how the average was taken. Most marketing material and many app screens show the arithmetic mean: add each year's return and divide by the number of years. That works for things like exam scores. It fails for money because returns compound, and a loss hurts compounding more than a gain of the same size helps it.
With made-up figures, suppose a holding gains 50% in year one and loses 50% in year two. The arithmetic mean is (50 + -50) / 2 = 0, which suggests you broke even. In fact S$10,000 grows to S$15,000, then halves to S$7,500, a loss of a quarter of the money.
The geometric mean is the only average that takes you from the starting balance to the ending balance. Convert each year's return into a growth factor, so +50% becomes 1.5 and -50% becomes 0.5. Multiply the growth factors together, take the nth root where n is the number of years, and subtract 1. Here, 1.5 x 0.5 = 0.75, and the square root of 0.75, minus 1, is about -13.4% a year. Compounding -13.4% for two years from S$10,000 gives S$7,500, which matches what happened to the money.
Fund managers call the geometric mean the compound annual growth rate (CAGR). In a spreadsheet you can skip the yearly factors and use (ending value / starting value) ^ (1 / number of years) - 1.
The gap between the two averages follows a pattern: it grows with volatility. A rough analyst rule is that the geometric mean sits below the arithmetic mean by about half the variance of the yearly returns. Two funds with the same arithmetic average can end with very different sums if one swings much harder than the other. This gap is the course's first link between return and risk, and Module 2 builds on it.
Because the arithmetic number flatters, a brochure that quotes an "average annual return" without saying which average tells you less than it seems to. A friend who says a stock "averaged 20% a year" may have ended up flat. If you average a spreadsheet column of your own yearly percentages, you overstate your performance whenever there was a down year.
From here on, every return in the course is geometric, real where the goal is spending power, net of fees, and in Singapore dollars. Treat any return quoted without those terms stated as unconfirmed until you know which kind it is.
That convention starts with your own numbers. Pull the year-end values of one holding or of your whole account for the last few years, and you're ready to put the two averages side by side.
Take the year-end values of one holding for the last five years, work out its arithmetic and geometric average returns, and convert the geometric figure into a real return using average CPI inflation. Write one line on why the arithmetic average is higher.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).