Total return counts dividends and what you did with them

Tell price return apart from total return, and explain why charts that leave out dividends make income stocks look worse than they did.

Open your broker app, pick a holding that pays dividends or distributions, and look at the percentage next to its name. Broker apps track price only and keep no record of the distributions you received, so that figure leaves out every payout the holding has made to you.

Price return measures only the change in market price. Total return adds back everything the holding paid out. For a stock that pays nothing, the two are the same. For a REIT, or a bank that pays out a large share of its profits, the gap between them is most of the story. Most charts in broker apps and on news sites are probably price charts, so for income stocks they understate what holders actually earned. Check whether a chart shows price or total return before you compare anything with it.

Marcus and his S-REIT

Marcus is 41 and runs operations for a logistics firm in Singapore. He has invested for about twelve years, with a world equity ETF at the core and a handful of SGX and US shares on the side. Three years ago he bought 6,000 units of an S-REIT at S$2.10 (made-up figures). It now trades at S$2.00, and every time he opens his broker app it shows red, down 4.8%.

That figure is the price return. To get it, divide the end price by the start price and subtract one: S$2.00 / S$2.10 - 1 is about minus 4.8%. His holding has gone from S$12,600 (6,000 x S$2.10) to S$12,000 (6,000 x S$2.00).

Over the three years the REIT paid yearly distributions of S$0.13, S$0.13 and S$0.12 per unit. The money landed in his bank account and he spent it on school fees and a holiday. The app does not know this cash exists.

Total return with the cash taken

A simple total return treats distributions as cash sitting in a drawer and never reinvested. Add up every payout per unit and multiply by the units held. For Marcus, 6,000 units times those payouts is S$2,280. Add that to the ending value, S$12,000 + S$2,280 = S$14,280, and compare the sum with the S$12,600 he put in. His total return is about 13.3% over three years, which is a gain.

Total return with each payout reinvested

Index providers and fund reports assume each payout is reinvested in the same holding on the pay date, so it starts earning from that day. The result is the reinvested total return. You need the price on each pay date. For Marcus, say these were S$2.02, S$2.15 and S$2.00.

On each pay date, divide the payout by that day's price to get extra units, and add them to the holding. His first payout of S$780 (6,000 x S$0.13) buys about 386 more units at S$2.02. The next payout is paid on the larger unit count, so it is larger too. Repeat for every payout. After three rounds he would hold about 7,179 units, worth about S$14,357 at the end price of S$2.00. Against the S$12,600 invested, that is a total return of about 13.9%. If you want an annual compounded rate, it works out to about 4.4% a year.

The gap between 13.3% with the cash taken and 13.9% reinvested looks small over three years, but over twenty years it compounds into real money.

Picking a fair benchmark

Some investors compare their own record, with dividends taken as cash, against an index's reinvested total return and call the gap skill or bad luck. That comparison is not valid. If you spent your dividends, your account return will trail the index's total return even if you held exactly the same shares. There are two fair ways to compare: reinvest your payouts on paper in your spreadsheet, or compare with a price index plus the cash you actually received. A distribution you take out counts as a withdrawal, and Lesson 1.4 of this course, "Time-weighted vs money-weighted returns on your own account", handles that properly.

One index name can have two total return series. Index providers such as MSCI publish a gross version, which reinvests the full dividend as if no tax were taken, and a net version, which reinvests the dividend after deducting withholding tax at a rate the provider assumes. The US withholds part of every dividend before it reaches a Singapore investor who buys US shares directly. Lesson 3.1 of the course "Investing in US and global markets from Singapore", "Why 30% of a US dividend never reaches you", explains how. With a dividend yield of 2% a year and 30% of the dividend withheld (made-up figures), the net index trails the gross by about 0.6 percentage points a year (2% x 30%).

A fund you hold can't escape withholding tax, so comparing it with the gross index makes it look worse than it is. Compare it with the net total return index instead. Whichever version you pick, write the choice down. Getting it right is worth more than many fee differences you might spend hours on.

The Dividend stocks and S-REITs course covers how dividends are declared, why the price falls on the ex-date, and how S-REIT distributions are taxed in Singapore. Lesson 1.4 of that course, "Track one dividend and its total return", follows a single payout from announcement to bank account. Here you only measure the effect of payouts on your return, which is all the returns tab needs.

Two columns for every holding

Give every holding in your workbook two columns, price return and total return, and only ever compare total return with total return.

For the activity, pick one dividend-paying holding you've owned for at least three years. You will need its price at the start and end, and every payout with its pay date, which SGXNet or your broker statements will show. Work out its price return and its total return, and enter both in the holding's two columns.

Work out the last three years of one dividend-paying holding twice, once as price return and once as total return. Write down the difference in SGD.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).