Read volume, market breadth and sentiment data as context for where the market stands.
Marcus, an investor who follows the Singapore market, hears a colleague say the market is "back" after the STI climbs 1.5% in one afternoon (an example figure, like the other numbers here unless a source is named). He opens the market summary on his broker app to check.
The summary shows more SGX stocks falling than rising that day. Trading was thinner than normal, and two of the three banks account for almost all of the index's gain. The index rose while most of the market did not. A price chart records the path of a single line. Volume shows how many people took part in a move, breadth shows how many stocks joined in, and sentiment shows how investors feel. All three give context to a price move, and none of them tells you when to buy or sell.
Volume is the count of shares that change hands in a given period. If a price moves while volume is heavy, a large number of buyers and sellers accepted the new level. If it moves on light volume, only a few did, and that move is easier to undo because a single big order arriving next can push the price back.
Judge volume against the stock's usual level. Larkspur, the invented company from Lesson 5.4, Index construction and what inclusion does to a stock, normally trades 0.6 million shares a day, so a 3 million share day is unusual for it.
An unusual day shows that some event took place without saying which one. Heavy trading on a rising price could come from keen buyers, from a fund building up a holding, or from index funds buying at a rebalance, which can be entirely mechanical, as Lesson 5.4 showed. Your routine is to compare the day's volume with the stock's own average. If it is unusual, take it as a prompt to find out what happened. Then read the company's announcements and check for rebalancing, fund activity or news before drawing any conclusion.
An index weighted by market value, as described in Lesson 5.4, can go up because a few large companies rise while most of its other members fall.
Market breadth is the extent to which a move is shared across stocks. The plainest version counts how many stocks advanced and how many declined each day. Keep a running total of advances minus declines and you have the advance-decline line, which shows whether participation is growing or shrinking over time. A second common measure is the percentage of an index's members trading above their own 200-day moving average. If an index is close to a high while only 40% of its members sit above their 200-day averages, the rise is resting on a narrow base.
A narrow rally can continue. Large companies have carried an index for years at a time, as the biggest US technology companies have done in some periods. Because it depends on a few names, though, a narrow rally is more fragile. It also suggests that someone holding an index fund and a typical stock picker may be having quite different results.
Sentiment measures attempt to capture the mood of investors. Their data comes from option prices, trading activity or surveys. Three you will see often:
The VIX, which Cboe calculates from S&P 500 index option prices. It measures how much volatility the options market expects over the next 30 days, using implied volatility (explained in Lesson 5.7, Options basics: payoffs and the Greeks). When investors pay more for protection the VIX goes up, so people call it the fear gauge. The put-call ratio, which is the volume of put options traded divided by the volume of call options traded. Puts protect against falls, so a high ratio points to investors buying protection. The American Association of Individual Investors (AAII) survey. Each week it asks members whether they think US shares will rise, fall or stay flat over the next six months, and publishes the share giving each answer. Other surveys ask fund managers how they are positioned.
These readings move between extremes, and traders pay most attention to the extremes. The usual interpretation is contrarian: if nearly everyone is afraid, a lot of bad news may already be reflected in prices, and if nearly everyone is confident, few buyers may be left. As context this has some worth. Very high fear has often shown up near market lows, since lows are when people feel most afraid.
Timing is where it breaks down. Fear that already looks extreme can keep rising, and markets can stay calm and confident for years. The VIX was already very high in October 2008, but shares carried on falling until March 2009, so a buyer acting on the first extreme fear reading in late 2008 sat through months of further losses. In March 2020 the VIX hit its highest close on record, above its late-2008 peak. Extreme sentiment has helped more in recognising the kind of market you are in than in naming the day it turns.
Each of these measures says little alone, so read them side by side. Marcus adds three rows to the macro dashboard he built in Lesson 3.8, Write a macro dashboard and three scenarios: the VIX, the share of STI members above their 200-day averages, and the AAII survey's bullish minus bearish figure. Every row has a value, a direction and a date.
Next to the rows he writes a rule that echoes the one at the end of that dashboard: the rows describe conditions, and they may prompt him to reread his rules but never to trade. He also plans for a day when the VIX is high, breadth is collapsing and the survey shows deep pessimism. On that day he will check that his rebalancing bands and cash needs are set where he wants them, so that a fall in prices finds him already prepared.
Set up your own rows the same way. Add the VIX, a breadth measure such as the share of index members above their 200-day averages, and a sentiment survey such as the AAII bullish minus bearish reading. Give each a value, a direction and a date. Write the rule that these rows describe conditions and can prompt a reread of your rules, never a trade. When readings turn extreme, review your rebalancing bands and cash needs and leave trading out of it.
For the activity, you'll look up the latest VIX from Cboe or a finance site, one breadth measure for an index you hold and the latest reading of one investor sentiment survey, all dated today.
Write down today's VIX, one breadth measure and one investor sentiment survey, then write what the three say taken together.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).