Explain momentum, how researchers have measured it and the crash risk that comes with it.
When a share has risen sharply, people start buying it because it has risen. Some investors call that the worst kind of reasoning. Others point out that buying recent winners is the one chart-based idea with decades of academic research behind it. Both views are partly right, and what separates them is the detail: how long you hold, how many stocks you hold, and what it costs.
Marcus (an invented investor) holds a US chip designer whose shares rose about 60% in a year (an invented figure). His group chat is full of people buying it because it had risen. Marcus always considered that the worst kind of reasoning, until he read about the research on buying recent winners.
The study is "Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers" by Narasimhan Jegadeesh and Sheridan Titman, published in the Journal of Finance in 1993. It was introduced in lesson 10.1, "What technical analysis claims and what the evidence supports". They ranked US stocks by their returns over the past 3 to 12 months, formed portfolios of the best and worst performers, and held them for the next 3 to 12 months. Past winners tended to keep beating past losers over those holding periods. That tendency, measured on portfolios, is called momentum.
The first caveat is time horizon. The effect works over months. Over around one month, earlier research by Jegadeesh found the opposite: recent winners tended to fall back. This short-term reversal is why many momentum measures skip the most recent month. Over several years, past winners have tended to lag.
The second caveat is breadth. The effect was measured on portfolios of many stocks. A single stock's past rise says very little about that stock's own next year, so the 60% rise tells Marcus little about his chip designer. What has held up is that a broad group of past winners, held together, has tended to beat a broad group of past losers.
Momentum has since been found in many stock markets, in sectors, in countries and in other asset classes. In 1997 Mark Carhart added momentum as a factor in explaining fund performance, and it has been part of standard fund analysis since then. A factor is a driver of returns that many stocks share; adding one lets you see how much of a fund's return came from it. Researchers still disagree about why momentum exists. The proposed explanations are that investors react slowly to news and then overreact, and that they herd, buying what others are buying. The cause matters because an effect with no reason behind it may not last.
Relative strength compares a stock's or sector's return with the market's return over the same period. Write both returns as decimals, add 1 to each, and divide: (1 + stock or sector return) / (1 + market return). A result above 1 means it beat the market, and below 1 means it lagged.
Marcus ranks the six sectors in an index by twelve-month relative strength (his figures are invented). The index rose 8% over twelve months, so each sector is divided by 1.08.
Technology rose 24%: 1.24 / 1.08, about 1.15 Financials rose 15%: 1.15 / 1.08, about 1.06 Industrials rose 10%: 1.10 / 1.08, about 1.02 Utilities rose 3%: 1.03 / 1.08, about 0.95 Real estate fell 4%: 0.96 / 1.08, about 0.89 Energy fell 9%: 0.91 / 1.08, about 0.84
A sector momentum rule works from a ranking like this: calculate twelve-month relative strength for each sector, rank the sectors, hold the leaders, avoid the laggards, and rerank every month or quarter. The rule is described so you can follow it, and nothing in these notes is a recommendation to trade. Relative strength tells you only how the past twelve months went. The research says top groups have tended to stay ahead for a while, on average, across many periods. It does not say that technology, or any other particular sector, will lead next year.
Momentum returns come with occasional sharp losses, and those losses cluster when markets rebound hard after a fall. After a long decline, the past losers are the stocks that fell hardest, often the most indebted and most cyclical (companies whose profits rise and fall most with the economy). When the market turns, they rise fastest, and a momentum strategy is betting against exactly those stocks as they jump.
In 2009, after the financial crisis, beaten-down stocks rallied violently from March. Momentum strategies that were short them, meaning they had bet on those stocks falling, had some of their worst losses on record. Kent Daniel and Tobias Moskowitz, in their paper "Momentum Crashes", documented those losses and found the same pattern in other market rebounds. Momentum wins slowly and loses quickly. Its return pattern resembles the steady-income strategies in lesson 2.3, "Sharpe and Sortino ratios, and when each misleads", in reverse: long stretches of gains interrupted by short, deep losses.
Academic results are mostly measured before trading costs, or with costs typical of large institutions. Momentum trades a lot because the list of winners changes every month, and if you have a small account, most of the return goes on costs.
Suppose you have a S$20,000 account holding ten stocks, reranked monthly. Each month 3 stocks drop out and 3 come in, which is 6 trades a month, each about S$2,000. Over a year that is 6 x 12 = 72 trades. The half-spread is half the gap between the price you can buy at and the price you can sell at, and you lose roughly that much on each trade. A minimum commission of S$10 plus a half-spread cost of 0.2% per trade (0.2% of S$2,000 is S$4) makes each trade cost about S$14. Then 72 x S$14 is about S$1,008 a year, and S$1,008 / S$20,000 is about 5% of the account a year.
To estimate this for any strategy, count the trades per rebalance (stocks out plus stocks in) and multiply by the number of rebalances a year. Work out the cost per trade as commission plus the half-spread percentage times the trade size. Multiply that cost by the trades you make a year, and divide by the size of your account. Then add two costs the example leaves out: currency conversion on US stocks, and slippage on thinly traded names. Slippage is the gap between the price you expect to trade at and the price you actually get.
Frequent buying and selling over short holding periods is also one of the patterns IRAS looks at when deciding whether gains are trading income. Lesson 12.4, "Tax on gains and dividends: check how IRAS treats you", explains how IRAS decides, and if you run a high-turnover strategy, check the IRAS guidance first.
Most retail investors get momentum in a lower-cost form. Broad index funds already hold more of the stocks that have risen, simply because their market values grew. Funds built around the momentum factor are another route; compare their costs using lesson 2.2, "Yearly charges: management fee, expense ratio and trailer fee", in the course "Unit trusts, robo-advisors and managed money compared".
The twelve-month returns of each sector, and of the index itself, are in the index provider's factsheet for any index you hold.
Rank the sectors in one index by their twelve-month relative strength and note which led and which lagged. Then write three sentences explaining what momentum is, how Jegadeesh and Titman measured it, and when momentum strategies have crashed.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).