Use a chart to time entry within a decision made on fundamentals

Use price action only to place orders for a decision you have already made on value and risk.

Before you open a price chart, write down which holding you are adding to and how much money is going in. Charts have one job in this module: helping you place orders for a purchase you have already decided on using value and portfolio rules. Writing those two things first means nothing you see on the chart can change them. The prices used below are made up.

The order of the three decisions

Every purchase involves three decisions, and the order you make them in matters more than any charting technique. First you decide what to own. That comes from your valuation and quality work in modules 8 and 9, or, for index funds, from your allocation. Second you decide how much, which comes from the portfolio rules you wrote down in module 11. Third you decide when and at what price. This last decision is the least important of the three.

Letting the chart into the first two decisions means treating support levels and indicators as forecasts, and lessons 10.2 and 10.3 showed that they are not. A stock that is "breaking out" has not become worth more. A fund sitting "at resistance" has not become a worse home for long-term savings.

Marcus adds S$8,000 to his account every January, a contribution he records in his returns tab from lesson 1.8, "Build the returns tab of your investment workbook". His investment policy says new money goes to whichever holding is furthest below its target weight, and this year that is his world equity ETF. So the what and the how much were settled before he looked at any price. In past years, once he had decided, he spent a week opening the chart, waiting for a dip, watching the price rise, and finally buying higher than he could have on day one, annoyed with himself.

Setting limit prices from the recent range

Once the decision is fixed, the chart has a narrower use. The recent trading range shows where buyers and sellers have been meeting, and that helps you set a limit price likely to fill without paying more than you need to. A limit price is the most you will pay for a buy; set it too low and the order may not fill. A market order pays whatever the ask is at that moment.

Marcus's world ETF trades at S$10.00. Over the past month it has traded between S$9.60 and S$10.30, and over the past three months between S$9.30 and S$10.40. A limit at S$9.00, far below that range, might never fill. A limit near the middle of the recent range, or just below the current price, is a reasonable compromise.

For a busy, liquid ETF like his, the gain from clever limits is small, a few cents a share at most. For a thinly traded stock, limit placement can matter more, but there the order book depth and the auction habits matter more than the chart. Lesson 5.2, "Order types beyond limit and market, and when each helps", covers both. If you are buying a stock you have already decided on, a recent support area, as described in lesson 10.2, "Trend, support and resistance as a description of past trading", is a sensible place for a patient limit order, as long as you accept it may not fill.

Splitting the purchase over a few weeks

Phasing means splitting a purchase into two or three parts, called tranches, over several weeks. It does not raise expected returns. Studies comparing lump-sum with phased investing, including work published by Vanguard, have generally found that investing at once did better more often than not. Markets have risen more often than they have fallen, and holding cash while you wait has a cost.

What phasing reduces is regret. If the price falls the day after you invest everything, it feels like a mistake, and investors who feel that tend to make worse decisions next time. Lesson 2.2, "Losses weigh more than equal gains", in the course "Behavioural Finance: why you make the money mistakes you make", explains why a fall straight after buying stings so much. Two or three tranches over a few weeks spread that regret risk, and the cost of waiting is small when the period is short.

Phase over weeks rather than months, and set an end date. A plan that waits indefinitely for the perfect price is market timing by another name.

Writing Marcus's January order plan

Write your plan before you look at the chart again, because every fresh look invites a new opinion. A complete plan answers four questions:

What you are buying How much goes in each tranche The limit price for each tranche The date by which any unfilled order becomes an order at the current price

Marcus wrote: world ETF, S$8,000, in two tranches of S$4,000. First tranche, limit S$9.98, placed on the first Monday of January at the open, after the first few minutes. Second tranche, limit S$9.80, from the third Monday. If the second has not filled by the last Friday of January, cancel it and place a limit at the ask that afternoon. He saved the plan in his workbook's notes and closed the app.

The second tranche did not fill at S$9.80, and he bought at S$10.12 on the last Friday. On that S$4,000 tranche, the gap against the first tranche's price of S$9.98 was about S$55. Before he had a plan, he would have spent a week watching the screen to lose about the same amount.

Pick one position you intend to add to, whether new money for a fund or an addition to a stock you've valued, and have your target amount and the deadline for the money ready before you write your plan. Then look at the past month and past three months of trading, write your answers to the four questions with a date on the plan, save it in your workbook notes, and close the chart.

Before you check the chart, write an entry plan for one position you mean to add to, with limit prices and dates.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).