Set a maximum weight for single positions and for sectors, and explain what each limit protects you from.
Open your latest statements and write down every holding you own, with its value and its weight as a share of the whole portfolio. You need those weights to set limits and to check each holding against them. Without written limits, the size of each holding is set by whatever happened to rise.
A limit is a decision you make once, on a calm day, about the most damage any one idea or theme is allowed to do. Marcus, the course's example investor, never made those decisions, and his account grew into its current shape as prices moved. In lesson 2.8, Build a risk dashboard for your portfolio and two benchmarks, he noted that his bank and chip holdings added risk he had not chosen deliberately, and said he would come back to it when he wrote his position limits.
Marcus's holdings are made-up figures used throughout the course, and every other figure below is made up as well. He has about S$202,000 spread across eight holdings:
World ETF: S$91,000, about 45.0% SGD bond fund: S$30,000, 14.9% STI ETF: S$20,000, 9.9% Bank: S$16,000, 7.9% Chip designer: S$15,000, 7.4% S-REIT: S$12,000, 5.9% T-bills: S$10,000, 5.0% Larkspur: S$8,000, 4.0%
His written allocation says shares of all kinds should come to about 80% of the portfolio, and they do, so the problems he is looking for sit inside the share portion.
A position limit is the largest weight any single holding may have, as a share of the whole portfolio. It is the simplest risk rule you can write and the most useful, because any single company can fail in ways no analysis catches. Lesson 6.3, The auditor's report, key audit matters and going-concern wording, opened with Hyflux as an example of that kind of failure.
Marcus takes his single-stock targets from the sizing method in lesson 11.1, Position sizing: equal, conviction and volatility weights. Each single stock gets 5% of the portfolio, or 4% if its volatility is above 30%. In money, 5% of S$202,000 is S$10,100 and 4% is S$8,080.
Next he sets each single stock beside its target. The bank, at S$16,000, is about S$5,900 over (S$16,000 minus S$10,100). The chip designer, at S$15,000, is about S$6,900 over its target. Larkspur sits on its target at 4.0%. Lesson 8.6 found Larkspur could lose about a third of its value in a bad cycle, and at a 4% weight that bear case would cost about 1.3% of the portfolio. The S-REIT, at 5.9%, is just above its 5% target.
Weights drift as prices move. If one stock doubles while the rest of the portfolio stays flat, its weight roughly doubles too, though nobody decided it should. A limit with no rule for winners holds only until something goes up, so Marcus adds one.
A trim rule is a rule with a trigger and an action for cutting a winner back to target. Marcus's trigger is a single stock rising more than one percentage point above its target, and his action is to trim it back to target at the next review. He chose a one-point gap so that he isn't trading every small wobble. A stock with a 5% target gets trimmed at 6%, and a stock with a 4% target gets trimmed at 5%.
On his current figures, the bank at 7.9% and the chip designer at 7.4% both need trimming now. The S-REIT at 5.9% is over its target but below the trigger, so it does not need trimming on its own.
The second kind of limit covers sectors and countries. These caps catch concentration you can't see holding by holding, such as owning several bank stocks, or one bank stock plus a fund full of banks. To count sector exposure properly, open each fund's factsheet, see what it holds, and add that exposure to your direct holdings in the same sector.
Lesson 4.6, Singapore's exposure as a trade and financial hub, noted that the STI gives large weights to the three local banks. Suppose 40% of Marcus's STI ETF is in banks. His bank exposure is then S$16,000 held directly plus 40% of S$20,000, a total of S$24,000, or about 11.9% of the portfolio.
His world ETF already holds the large US technology companies, and his own chip designer makes up 1% of that fund. Suppose semiconductor companies are 8% of the world ETF, which puts about S$7,300 of semiconductors in his portfolio through the fund (8% of S$91,000). Marcus counts Larkspur as a semiconductor holding as well. His chip exposure is S$15,000 in the chip designer, S$8,000 in Larkspur and about S$7,300 through the world ETF, some S$30,300 in total, or 15.0% of the portfolio.
He sets his sector limit at 15% of the portfolio, counted through funds. Banks pass at 11.9%. Semiconductors at 15.0% sit right on the limit, and he treats a sector sitting exactly on its limit as a warning in itself.
Marcus's benchmark holds only 10% in the STI. He also knows he is drawn to markets he knows, which is home bias, covered in lesson 5.1, Home bias: holding too much of what you know, in the Build and run an ETF portfolio course. For both reasons he sets a Singapore country limit of 25%.
His Singapore shares are the STI ETF, the bank, the S-REIT and Larkspur. Together they come to S$56,000, about 27.7% of the portfolio, which puts him over his 25% limit.
No limit has a correct number. Marcus worked his out by answering three questions for himself, and you can use the same three. The first is how much you would lose in one holding before it changed your plans. The second is how confident you are in your own analysis, judged by your record and not by how you feel. The third is how much you want your portfolio to differ from your benchmark.
Marcus chose 5% for single stocks because losing all of one would cost him about a year of savings, and he could survive that. His 15% sector limit keeps any one industry from carrying more than about a fifth of his shares, since 15% is roughly a fifth of an 80% share allocation. His 25% Singapore limit allows a home tilt well above the benchmark's 10% while capping how far that tilt can go.
Your numbers can be different from his. Write your limits down before you need them, and give every limit a stated action for when it is broken.
Marcus finishes with a short written summary of what he found. He has three breaches: the bank and the chip designer are over his single-stock limit, and his Singapore shares are over his country limit. Semiconductors sit on his sector limit. He will make no trades until he has written the cluster limit in lesson 11.5, and lesson 12.2, Rebalance a mix of ETFs and single stocks to a written rule, turns these breaches into trades.
Now get your own holdings and weights in front of you, with the latest factsheets for any funds, ready to set and check each limit.
Write down a maximum weight for single stocks, for sectors and for countries, then check your current portfolio against each one.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).