Decide whether to hedge the currency on your stocks and on your bonds, and work out what the hedge costs.
When you hold shares or bonds priced in another currency, your return in Singapore dollars depends on two things: what the investment does, and what the exchange rate does. You can remove the second part with a hedge, but the hedge has a price, and whether it is worth paying depends on what you hold. Writing one policy that covers every holding type means you make this decision once, with reasons, and can check it later.
A currency hedge fixes today's exchange rate for a future date, usually through a forward contract, so that rate moves stop affecting your return. A fund's hedged share class does the hedging for you and renews the contracts each month. Choosing between share classes of one fund is covered in the course "Build and run an ETF portfolio", lesson 5.3, "Hedged share classes: when they help". The question here is wider: one rule that covers everything you own.
Take Marcus, an investor whose home currency is the Singapore dollar. In lesson 3.5, "The dollar cycle and what a strong dollar does to Asian assets", he worked out that he holds about S$74,150 in US dollar assets: most of a world ETF and all of his chip designer stock. That is a little over a third of his portfolio. The figures for Marcus, and the other figures in these notes, are made up unless stated otherwise. If the US dollar fell 10% against the Singapore dollar, he would lose about S$7,400 in SGD terms even if no share price moved. A colleague asks him why he doesn't hedge it.
A hedge removes currency gains as well as currency losses. In 2022 (a real event), the US dollar rose against most currencies. An SGD investor holding unhedged US shares saw part of the fall in share prices offset by the stronger dollar. A hedged investor gave up that cushion.
Whether a hedge pays for itself depends on what you hold. It usually does on bonds, and usually does not on shares held for many years.
High-quality government bonds are held for steady returns and to cushion the portfolio when shares fall. Their price swings are usually small, and exchange rate swings are much larger. Take a made-up global government bond index with volatility of 4% a year in its own currencies. Held unhedged by an SGD investor, its volatility might rise to around 7%, mostly from exchange rates. In a given year, currency often determines most of the return on an unhedged foreign bond fund, and the fund stops behaving like a bond fund. In a year when shares fall and the Singapore dollar strengthens, the currency loss on unhedged foreign bonds can erase the cushion the bonds were meant to provide. For this reason many investors hold foreign bonds hedged to their own currency, or hold bonds in their own currency to begin with.
Share prices swing far more than exchange rates, so currency is a smaller part of their total volatility. Over long periods, currency moves between major economies have tended to partly even out, while the cost of hedging is paid every year.
The cost of hedging comes from the gap between the two currencies' interest rates. A forward contract, say to sell US dollars for Singapore dollars in a year, is priced so neither side gains from that gap. If US dollar rates are above SGD rates, the forward rate for the US dollar is below today's spot rate, and the hedger gives up roughly the rate difference each year. If the gap reverses and SGD rates are higher, the hedger earns the difference instead.
To estimate it, find the interest rate of each currency and subtract one from the other. Hedging out of the higher-rate currency costs roughly the difference per year, or earns it if your home rate is the higher one. Then compound that annual drag over your horizon. With made-up rates of 4.5% for the US dollar and 2.5% for the Singapore dollar, hedging US assets back to SGD costs roughly 2 points a year. Paid every year for ten years, that leaves you about 18% less than you would otherwise have, because 0.98 multiplied by itself ten times is about 0.82.
You can see the real cost in two places. Fund houses that offer hedged and unhedged classes of the same fund report both returns; over a period when the currency barely moved, the gap between them is mostly hedging cost. MAS publishes SGD interest rate data, which you can compare with US rates published by the Federal Reserve. Check these figures when you write your policy, and date them.
A currency policy is one rule for the whole portfolio. It covers each holding type, gives a reason for each decision, and names where you check the cost. To write one, list your foreign currency holdings by type, shares or bonds, with their SGD value. Decide for each type whether it is hedged, unhedged or held in SGD, and write down why. Name where you will check the hedging cost, check it now, date the figures, and set how often you will look again.
Marcus's bond fund is an SGD fund, so his bond decision was made when he chose it. His policy reads:
Shares: unhedged. His horizon is over fifteen years, currency adds little volatility to shares over that period, and the hedging cost, driven by the gap between US dollar and SGD interest rates, compounds against his return. Bonds and cash: held in SGD or hedged to SGD, because currency swings would overwhelm their returns and defeat their role as a cushion. If he ever adds a global bond fund, it must be hedged to SGD. Cost check: once a year, using the gap between hedged and unhedged classes of a world equity fund, and MAS and Federal Reserve rate data.
Two exposures sit outside the hedging decision but belong in the same note. The first is the currency you will spend in: someone retiring abroad has a different home currency from someone retiring in Singapore. The second is conversion cost, which is separate from currency risk. A hedge does nothing about the spread you pay each time you convert currency, and that spread adds to your costs. The course "Investing in US and global markets from Singapore", lesson 2.3, "Currency risk is not the same as conversion cost", explains the difference, and lesson 12.3, "The full cost stack: commissions, spreads, FX, custody and withholding tax", adds the conversion spread to your total costs.
Before you write your own policy, list your foreign currency holdings by type, shares or bonds, with their value in SGD.
Write your currency policy for shares and for bonds, give a reason for each, and note where you will look up the current cost of hedging.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).