You will be able to list every cost of running your own portfolio and find today's figure for each one.
A portfolio costs more to run than its fund expense ratios. To find the real yearly figure, add up every money cost that a year of your own documents shows or implies, then state the total in dollars and as a percentage of the portfolio.
Asked what their portfolio costs, most investors quote only the expense ratios, because that is the only cost they see printed. The other costs are spread across contract notes, broker statements and fund reports that people never add together.
Marcus lives in Singapore and runs his own portfolio. Before this exercise he would have said it cost about 0.2% to run (an example figure, as is every rate in Marcus's figures). He went through a year of his own documents and found seven cost lines, and expense ratios were less than half of the total. For your own account, look up the current figure for each line from its source, and write the source and date beside it.
Gather a year of contract notes, broker statements and fund reports first.
An expense ratio is a yearly charge taken from a fund's assets before you see the price. You never see it leave, because it is already inside the fund's returns. To cost it, multiply each fund's expense ratio by the amount you hold, then add the results.
Marcus holds S$91,000 in an Irish-domiciled world ETF at 0.20%, which is S$182. His S$20,000 in an STI ETF at 0.30% is S$60, and his S$30,000 bond fund at 0.40% is S$120. Across his three funds that is about S$362 a year. Lesson 3.1 of the "Build and run an ETF portfolio" course, "Expense ratio and the costs it leaves out", explains what the figure includes and leaves out. Lesson 3.2 of that course, "Tracking difference is what you actually lost to the index", explains why tracking difference is a better measure of fund cost.
Every trade pays a commission, and often a platform fee or clearing fee, all shown on the contract note. Count your trades and total the commission and fees. Marcus made 16 trades at an average of S$12 each, which is S$192.
Every trade also pays the spread, plus any market impact and slippage. None of these appear as a line on any document, as lesson 5.3, "Spreads, depth and market impact on small and large stocks", sets out. Estimate them as a percentage of the amount traded, using the trade-cost tab from lesson 5.8, "Measure the true cost of five paper trades". Thinly traded stocks have higher spread and impact costs. Marcus traded S$30,000 in the year and estimated these costs at about 0.2%, or S$60. Most of it came from Larkspur, as it had in his paper trades.
Some brokers charge a custody fee to hold shares, a monthly or quarterly platform fee, or a fee per dividend collected. Others charge nothing for holding and make their money elsewhere. These charges usually sit well below the commission table in a broker's fee schedule, so read the whole schedule. Marcus pays S$100 a year in platform fees. Module 1 of the "Investing in US and global markets from Singapore" course, "Know who actually holds your overseas shares", covers how your broker holds your shares.
Buying a US stock from Singapore means converting SGD to USD, and selling means converting back. Each conversion pays a conversion spread, the gap between the FX rate you get and the mid-market rate, plus any fee. Over the life of a holding you pay it twice, once going in and once coming out. Record the amount converted and the spread plus any fee. Marcus converted about S$10,000 to USD at a 0.3% spread, about S$30. Lesson 2.1 of the US markets course, "Where the FX cost hides in a US trade", shows where this cost sits.
The conversion cost is certain and paid at once, whatever the US dollar does next. Currency risk depends on the dollar's next move and is a separate matter, covered in lesson 11.7, "Currency risk and when hedging earns its cost".
Withholding tax is tax the dividend-paying company's home country takes before the dividend reaches you. The rate is set by the country paying the dividend and by any tax treaty. For a Singapore individual it is usually a final cost with nothing to offset it, as lesson 3.3 of the US markets course, "How Singapore treats the dividends that reach you", explains. The W-8BEN is the paperwork that decides which rate your broker applies, covered in lesson 3.2, "What the W-8BEN does and does not do". Check the current rate with your broker and the source country's tax authority before relying on any figure, including the 30% in the title of lesson 3.1, "Why 30% of a US dividend never reaches you".
Record withholding on foreign dividends you hold directly. Marcus holds S$15,000 of a US chip designer stock directly. At a 1% yield it pays about S$150 in dividends a year, and at an example rate of 30%, about S$45 is withheld.
Funds also pay withholding tax inside the fund, where you never see it, before it shows in the fund's price. A fund's domicile changes the rate it pays, and an Irish-domiciled fund pays a different rate on US dividends, as lesson 5.2, "How Irish domicile changes the dividend tax", explains. For each fund, multiply the dividend yield by the share of dividends from the taxed country, by the fund-level rate, by the amount held. Marcus's world ETF yields 1.8%, 65% of its dividends come from US companies, and the fund-level rate is 15%. S$91,000 x 1.8% is S$1,638, x 65% is about S$1,065, and x 15% is about S$160 a year.
US shares held directly can also expose your estate to US estate tax, covered in lesson 4.1, "The US can tax your US shares when you die". This is a risk, not a yearly cost. Note it in the same spreadsheet tab as a risk, with the value of your US-situated holdings beside it, and leave it out of the total.
Add every line into one yearly total, then divide by the portfolio value to get a percentage. Marcus's seven lines are:
Expense ratios: S$362 Commissions: S$192 Spread, impact and slippage: S$60 FX conversion: S$30 Platform fees: S$100 Direct US withholding: S$45 Fund-level withholding: S$160
That comes to about S$949. His portfolio is S$202,000, so the cost is about 0.47% a year. The expense ratios he would have quoted are about 38% of the total.
Two costs are left out of the total on purpose. Tax on gains is nil for most long-term investors in Singapore, and lesson 12.4, "Tax on gains and dividends: check how IRAS treats you", shows how to check your own position. Your own hours are also left out, even though for Marcus they are the largest cost of all. Lesson 12.5, "Price your hours: what your research time costs", shows how to put a figure on them.
For the activity, you'll build the same list for your own account, with each line's current figure from your broker's fee schedule, your contract notes and your fund documents, and the source you checked beside it.
List every cost on your own account. Next to each, write the current figure from your broker's fee schedule and where you checked it.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).