Benchmark your results against a managed fund, like for like

You will be able to compare your net return with a managed fund or robo-advisor on the same basis.

Marcus's sister keeps her savings in a robo-advisor, an online service that builds and manages a portfolio of funds for you for a fee, and likes to tease him about his spreadsheets. She shows him her app, which reports about 4.6% a year (an example figure) over five years. His own figure is about 5.6%, and he is tempted to declare victory.

He holds off because he remembers module 1, which asks four questions before any two returns can sit side by side. Her app's figure and his were not worked out the same way, so the one-point gap tells him very little yet. His returns are the made-up figures from Lesson 1.8, Build the returns tab of your investment workbook, and every number that follows is an invented example.

Putting both returns on the same basis

A fair comparison uses the same basis: the same measure, the same costs, the same currency and the same period. Start with the measure. Use time-weighted returns for both your portfolio and the alternative. You are comparing investment choices, and a time-weighted return removes the effect of when you happened to deposit money. Lesson 1.4, Time-weighted vs money-weighted returns on your own account, explains why.

Both returns should then be net of every cost, in SGD, over exactly the same dates. If your figures run from January to December and the fund's run from April to March, line them up before you compare anything.

The managed alternative also has to hold similar risk to your own allocation. Lesson 1.6, Choose a benchmark that matches what you actually hold, warned about the mismatch here. A 100% equity fund would beat an investor holding 80% shares in good years and lose to them in bad years, for reasons that have nothing to do with skill. For Marcus, similar risk means a fund or robo portfolio at roughly 80% shares and 20% bonds and cash, spread across the world, which matches the shape of his own allocation.

Counting every cost of the managed option

The managed alternative's figures must include its complete costs: the advisory or platform fee, plus the expense ratios, or yearly running costs, of the funds inside it, plus any sales charge. Lesson 4.3, What a robo-advisor really costs, part of Unit trusts, robo-advisors and managed money compared, lists all of these for robo-advisors. Lesson 2.4, List every charge on one fund, does the same for unit trusts.

A published net return usually includes the fund expenses and sometimes includes the advisory fee. Check which costs it covers, and deduct whatever it leaves out yourself.

Marcus's comparison in percentages, dollars and hours

Marcus picks a made-up robo portfolio at his risk level. Its published yearly returns in SGD, after all fees, are 8.8%, minus 14.2%, 14.6%, 6.8% and 9.8%. He links these together into a chained return, which is the yearly returns combined into one annualised time-weighted figure, the steady yearly rate that gives the same total growth. For this robo portfolio it comes to about 4.64% a year.

His own time-weighted return over the same years, after all money costs and worked out from his actual account values, is about 5.58% a year. That puts him about 0.94 points a year ahead (5.58 minus 4.64).

He then turns the percentages into money by running his actual deposits on the same dates through the alternative. He put in S$164,000, which ended at about S$202,185. The same deposits on the same dates in the managed portfolio would have ended at about S$197,445. Before counting his time, he is about S$4,740 better off over five years.

Next he adds his hours. Lesson 12.5, Price your hours: what your research time costs, put his time at about S$5,616 a year at S$36 an hour, which is about 156 hours a year. Five years of those hours at half that rate comes to more than S$14,000. At the full rate it is about S$28,000. Either way, the S$4,740 he gained is smaller than what his time cost.

The managed portfolio is not his only alternative, so he adds a third line: a plain index fund tracking his own benchmark, with a made-up total cost of 0.25% a year. It returns about 5.17% a year, and his deposits would have ended at about S$201,670. That is only S$515 less than his actual S$202,185, and it would have needed about 12 hours a year against his 156.

Judging the result over many years

Five years sounds long, but it is a short record for telling skill from luck. Suppose Marcus's yearly return and the managed portfolio's differ by about 3 points in a typical year, which is a made-up figure. An average lead of 0.94 points over five years is then well within what chance alone could produce. On the usual statistical rule of thumb, being fairly confident that such a lead was not luck would need roughly 40 years of data.

Most investors never build a record that long, so the comparison has to be repeated every year. It cannot be settled once. The caution applies in both directions: one bad year does not prove a self-run portfolio is a mistake, and one good year does not prove it is working. Use rolling three- or five-year windows, as taught in Lesson 1.5, Annualise, compare periods and spot cherry-picked start dates, and look at the trend across them.

Marcus writes three sentences under his comparison:

He beat the managed alternative by about 0.94 points a year, worth about S$4,740 over five years. Counting his hours at S$36, he trailed it by somewhere between S$9,000 and S$23,000. The index version matched his result to within S$515 in less than a tenth of the time.

He has not decided what to do yet. The comparison does not tell you what to do. It tells you what your choices have cost, measured honestly, and the decision comes in Lesson 12.8, Assemble your investment file and decide your next step.

Choose a managed fund or robo portfolio at a risk level close to your own allocation, and collect its net returns in SGD for the same years your returns tab covers.

Pick a managed fund or robo portfolio with risk similar to yours, then compare its time-weighted return after all charges, in SGD, with your own over the same dates.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).