Assemble your investment file and decide your next step

You will be able to put your workbook, memo and rulebook into one investment file and use that evidence to decide how you run your money.

Your final project is one investment file that ends in a written decision on how you'll run your money next year. Allow about ninety minutes, and spend most of that time on the cost and benchmark tab and on the decision page.

The file draws together everything you've practised in the course: measuring returns and risk, reading and modelling a company, valuing it, writing a memo, setting risk rules and counting costs. Marcus's file is the worked example below, and it uses the same made-up figures as the rest of the course. The decision page may be the shortest document in your file, but it is the one you will reread next January, so give it the time it needs.

Assembling the workbook and its contents tab

Start by putting a Contents tab at the front of your workbook. List every tab, the lesson that built it, and the date it was last updated. Marcus's Contents tab reads: Returns (lesson 1.8), Risk (2.8), Macro (3.8), Scenario (4.8), Trade costs (5.8), Reading log (6.8), Inputs and the three statements (7.7 and 7.8), Valuation (8.8), Comps (9.8), Backtest (10.8) and Stress (11.8), plus the new Costs tab you'll build next.

Keep your two written pieces beside the workbook. The two-page memo comes from lesson 9.8, Build a comps table and write an investment memo. The one-page rulebook comes from lesson 11.8, Write your risk rulebook and stress test your portfolio, and it should now include the rebalancing rule from lesson 12.2, Rebalance a mix of ETFs and single stocks to a written rule.

Then check the dates on your Contents tab. Any tab whose figures are more than a quarter old needs updating. Start with returns and holdings, since the cost and comparison work depends on them.

Totalling your all-in cost

Your all-in cost is your money costs plus your hours valued at a stated rate, totalled in SGD and as a percentage of your portfolio. Build it on a new Costs tab in two halves.

The top half lists every money cost, as set out in lesson 12.3, The full cost stack. These are commissions, spreads (the gap between the buying and selling price), FX (currency conversion) charges, custody fees and withholding tax on foreign dividends. Write the source and date beside each one so you can check it next year. The bottom half lists your research hours, the hourly rate you chose, and your reason for choosing it, following lesson 12.5, Price your hours: what your research time costs.

Total the two halves twice: once in SGD and once as a percentage of the portfolio. Marcus's money costs come to about S$949 (an example figure), or 0.47%. His hours come to 156 at S$36, about S$5,616, or 2.78%. Added together (S$949 + S$5,616 = S$6,565), his all-in cost is about S$6,565 a year, or 3.25% of his S$202,000 portfolio.

Comparing with a managed fund and an index version

On the same Costs tab, set your own result beside two others: your managed alternative, and a plain index version of your benchmark. The comparison has to be like for like, as lesson 12.6, Benchmark your results against a managed fund, defined it. That means time-weighted (a return measured so your deposits and withdrawals don't distort it), net of all money costs, in SGD, and over the same years. Also show what the same deposits would have become in each option, so you can see the difference in dollars as well as percentages.

Marcus compares five years. His own portfolio returned about 5.58% a year and ended at about S$202,185. The managed portfolio returned about 4.64% a year and ended at about S$197,445. A plain index version of his benchmark, with a made-up 0.25% cost, returned about 5.17% a year and ended at about S$201,670.

Before counting his time, Marcus is S$4,740 ahead of the managed portfolio (S$202,185 - S$197,445) and S$515 ahead of the index version (S$202,185 - S$201,670). When he counts his hours at the full rate, he is behind both.

Add one line on luck to your file. Lesson 12.6 showed that a five-year lead of under a point a year is too short to tell from chance. Your comparison records what happened over those years; it can't settle whether you have skill.

Choosing one of the four options on your decision page

Your decision page is one page with four parts: what you'll do, why, what result would change it, and when you'll check. The "what you'll do" part names one of four options:

Keep picking at your current size. Shrink the satellite, the stock-picking part you hold beside your index funds. Go fully passive, meaning you hold only index funds, kept to your allocation. Hand the money to a managed fund or robo-advisor, a service that invests and rebalances for you automatically.

Each of these is a reasonable answer for someone. Let the evidence in your file choose between them, rather than how you feel after a good or bad year.

Marcus decides to shrink his satellite. His reason is that his stocks have shown no edge. Over five years he beat his benchmark by about 0.15 points a year before his time, and trailed it on risk-adjusted terms, which weigh return against the swings taken to earn it. At his January review he will sell the chip designer and the bank. Both are large, heavily researched companies that his world and STI ETFs already hold, and lesson 12.7 says he has no advantage in companies like these.

He keeps Larkspur and the S-REIT, a property trust listed in Singapore, at their targets, which gives a satellite of 9%. He adds the rest to the world ETF so shares stay at 80%. He caps his investing time at 40 hours a year, about S$1,440, and will check prices weekly.

He records why he rejected the other options too. He won't hand the money to a manager, because in his own comparison a plain index portfolio beat the robo at lower cost and took about 12 hours a year. His change trigger is written down: if after three years his time-weighted return trails his benchmark after money costs, he will go fully passive. He reviews the decision every January.

If your evidence points you towards keeping picking at a larger size, reread your Costs tab first. Check that the edge you'd need to cover your hours is one your record actually supports.

The course doesn't tell you what to buy, and your decision page doesn't need to either. Its job is to record what you measured and what you chose, so that next year you can check one against the other.

Now complete your Costs tab and write your decision.

Finish the cost and benchmark tab. Then write one page on how you will run your money next year and why.

Calculators for this lesson

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).