Calculate Sharpe and Sortino ratios and spot when a high ratio is hiding a risk.
Open the MAS website and find the yield on a Singapore T-bill for the period your portfolio returns cover. You need that figure to work out two ratios for your own portfolio and for a benchmark. The rate used in the example below is invented, so use your own period's figure when you do the calculation yourself.
Marcus has been offered a structured income fund by his relationship manager. The fund's factsheet shows a Sharpe ratio above 2 (an illustrative figure). Marcus works out the same ratio for his own portfolio and gets under 0.4, so on that comparison the fund looks five times better. Before he believes it, he needs to know what the ratio measures and which strategies can produce a high one without being any safer.
The Sharpe ratio, named after the economist William Sharpe, divides the return you earned above a risk-free rate by the volatility you took on to earn it. It tells you how much extra return each unit of volatility, or wobble, bought you. The formula is the average return minus the risk-free rate, divided by the standard deviation of returns.
The risk-free rate should be one you could actually earn in Singapore dollars with no real risk. A Singapore T-bill yield is the natural choice, and MAS publishes T-bill auction results and yields on its website.
To calculate it, choose a period and gather your returns for it. Find the T-bill yield for the same period. Work out the arithmetic average return and the standard deviation of returns. All three inputs must cover the same period and be annualised together on the same basis. Then subtract the risk-free rate from the average return and divide the result by the standard deviation.
Analysts use the arithmetic average here because it fits the statistics the ratio is built on. When you want to judge what an investor actually ended up with, the geometric figure from module 1 is still the one to quote.
Marcus takes ten yearly returns, which include the five years on his returns tab: 10%, minus 7%, 19%, 6%, 12%, 14%, minus 18%, 16%, 9% and 11%. These are invented example figures, as is the 3% a year risk-free rate he uses. His arithmetic average is 7.2% and his standard deviation is about 11.3%. His Sharpe ratio is (7.2 minus 3) / 11.3, which is about 0.37.
A world equity index over the same ten years, also invented, averaged 9.0% with a standard deviation of about 12.5%, giving a Sharpe ratio of about 0.48. The index paid more return per unit of volatility than Marcus's portfolio did.
Volatility counts a big gain as risk, as lesson 2.1 showed. The Sortino ratio fixes this by replacing volatility with downside deviation, which only counts returns below a target you choose. The formula is the average return minus the target, divided by downside deviation.
Pick a target first. Marcus uses the 3% risk-free rate. For each year, take the return minus the target if the result is negative, and count zero otherwise. Square those numbers, average the squares over all the years, and take the square root. That is the downside deviation. Divide the average return minus the target by it.
Two of Marcus's years fell below 3%: the minus 7% year and the minus 18% year. His shortfalls are 10 points and 21 points. Squaring them, averaging over all ten years and taking the square root gives a downside deviation of about 7.4%. His excess return is 4.2, so his Sortino ratio is 4.2 / 7.4, about 0.57. The world index's Sortino ratio is about 0.84.
Sources differ on the method. Some use zero as the target and some use the risk-free rate. Some average only over the losing years instead of all of them. Each choice changes the number, so write down which target and averaging method you used, and use the same ones for everything you compare.
Some strategies effectively sell insurance. They collect a small, steady premium most of the time and pay out heavily in a rare bad event. Selling put options, writing default protection and some structured products work this way. Their return history looks smooth, so volatility is low and the Sharpe ratio is high until the bad event arrives. The danger is that you only see the good years.
Take an invented strategy of this kind with nine years of returns: 9%, 6%, 8%, 5%, 7%, 9%, 6%, 8% and 7%. The average is about 7.2%, the standard deviation is about 1.4%, and the Sharpe ratio is about 3.0. In year ten it loses 30%. Over the ten years the Sharpe ratio falls to about 0.04, and the compound return is about 2.7% a year, below the 3% risk-free rate.
A fund launched in a calm period, or a backtest that leaves out a crash, can show a Sharpe ratio above 2 for its whole published life. The ratio cannot warn you about a risk the history does not contain.
Assets that are priced rarely, such as private funds or property valued once a year, look smoother than they are, which flatters their ratio. A ratio calculated from three years of data is mostly noise. Borrowing to invest leaves the Sharpe ratio roughly unchanged: a fund that doubles both its excess return and its volatility with borrowed money keeps the same score while its drawdowns double.
When a product shows a high Sharpe ratio, ask:
How long is the history? Does it include a crisis? What does the strategy lose when things go wrong?
If the answer to the last question is "we've never had a losing year", ask harder questions before going further.
For the activity, take your portfolio's yearly or monthly returns, which you already have from lesson 1.8, and one benchmark's. Look up the T-bill yield for your period on the MAS website, and calculate both ratios for each.
Look up a T-bill yield on the MAS website, then use it to calculate Sharpe and Sortino ratios for your portfolio and one benchmark.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).