Name the main risk premia and explain what risk you take on to earn each one.
People usually judge an investment by the return it has paid. They forget the losses they agreed to sit through to get that return. Shareholders are not owed anything above what cash pays. Some assets pay more over long periods because investors as a group want extra reward before they will hold something that can hurt them in a particular way. That extra reward is called a risk premium.
Every holding you own earns at least one risk premium, and some earn several. Each premium fails in its own way. Once you can name the premium a holding collects, you can also name the bad outcome you accepted when you bought it. There are four premia to know: equity, term, credit and illiquidity.
Over long periods, shares have usually done better than cash and government bonds. Their owners get paid for putting up with falls that are deep and last a long time. Lesson 2.2, "Drawdown and time under water are the risks you feel", showed how large those falls can be. US shares fell by more than half between 2007 and early 2009. Japan's main index took over three decades to get back to its 1989 peak.
The equity premium goes to investors who keep holding through falls like these. Anyone who sells partway down misses it. The equity premium fails in a long bear market, and that failure can last a decade or more. Holdings that earn mainly the equity premium tend to rise and fall together.
Lending your money for years has usually paid more than lending it for a few months. The extra yield on longer bonds is the term premium. You get it because a longer bond loses more of its price when interest rates go up, as Lesson 2.5, "Duration is the risk number for bonds", explained. The term premium fails when inflation and rates rise faster than expected. That is what happened in 2022, when holders of long-dated government bonds in the US and other countries had some of their worst losses in decades. T-bills earn almost no term premium, so their return stays low and steady.
You can't look up the term premium on any screen. It has to be estimated from models, and some of those estimates have put it close to zero, or even below zero, in recent years. A premium can stay small for long stretches.
A corporate bond pays more than a government bond that matures at the same time, because the company might fail to pay you back. The difference in yield is the credit spread. Part of it covers the defaults lenders already expect. The rest is the credit premium, which pays you for the risk that defaults come in clusters. Defaults do cluster, so the credit premium tends to disappear in recessions. In a recession, defaults rise, spreads widen, and corporate bond prices fall at the same time as shares.
There have been cases in Singapore. During the oil price slump of 2015 to 2017, several offshore marine companies defaulted on their SGD bonds. When Hyflux collapsed from 2018, holders of its perpetual securities and its preference shares took losses. Module 6 of the course "Bonds, T-bills, SSBs and fixed deposits", "Judge credit risk before you lend to a company", covers credit risk on single companies.
An asset you can't sell quickly at a fair price tends to offer a higher expected return than a similar asset you can sell easily. That extra return is the illiquidity premium. Private equity, private credit, direct property and the shares of thinly traded small companies all offer it. It fails in two ways. You need to sell and nobody wants to buy, or the fund itself stops you from withdrawing. After the Brexit vote in June 2016, several UK property funds suspended redemptions, and their investors could not get their money out for months.
All four premia are rewards you can expect over long periods. None of them is paid in any particular year, and any of them can be missing for a long time. If the premia were reliable, investors would compete them away and nobody would be paid for taking the risk. Being unreliable is part of what makes them premia.
So a higher expected return does not make a holding better. It means you accepted a specific kind of loss in exchange for a specific kind of reward. If a product offers a high return and claims to carry none of these risks, then either it has a risk it hasn't disclosed or it is mispriced. Undisclosed risk is far more common than mispricing.
Marcus (an invented example) owns T-bills, which give him a modest, predictable return. He also owns a world equity ETF, which has paid more over long periods. His other holdings are an STI ETF, a bank share, two chip stocks, an SGD bond fund with a duration of 6.5, and an S-REIT. One of the chip stocks is a small SGX-listed chip supplier whose shares trade thinly. Lesson 2.4 found that his world ETF, STI ETF, bank share and both chip stocks move together, because each of them earns mainly the equity premium.
He starts by listing every holding. Then he goes through them one at a time and writes down the premium or premia each one earns. He labels the world ETF, STI ETF, bank share and both chip stocks "equity premium", and the SGD bond fund "term premium". He adds "a little illiquidity" to the small SGX chip supplier, because it carries a little illiquidity premium and a little illiquidity risk. Beside the T-bills he writes "almost nothing". The S-REIT gets "equity and term", because REITs behave like shares but are sensitive to interest rates.
Last, next to each holding he writes the scenario in which its premium would fail:
Equity holdings: a long bear market. SGD bond fund: inflation and rates rising faster than expected. Small chip supplier: having to sell when no buyer will pay a fair price. S-REIT: either a long bear market or a fast rise in rates.
Now do the same with your own holdings. List each one, label the premium or premia it earns (equity, term, credit, illiquidity, or almost none), and next to each write the scenario in which that premium would fail.
List every holding in your portfolio. Next to each, write the main premium it earns and the scenario in which that premium fails.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).