Growth and inflation: four regimes and what tends to do well in each

Place the economy in a growth and inflation regime and name the assets that have tended to do well in it.

Find the most recent official release for growth and the most recent one for consumer prices. For each, note which way it has moved over the last several months: up or down. With those two directions you can place the economy in one of four broad regimes. Once you have a regime, the jobs reports, inflation prints and central banker speeches that fill your feed each day have somewhere to go.

Marcus is an individual investor. Every morning their news feed hands them a fresh worry. A weak jobs report seems to call for one move, a hot inflation print for another, a central banker's speech for a third. Marcus has no way to file these headlines into a small number of states of the world, so each one feels like a separate instruction.

The four growth and inflation regimes

Analysts use a simple framework built on two questions. The first asks whether economic growth is speeding up or slowing down. The second asks whether inflation is rising or falling. A regime is a broad state of the economy, set by which way growth and inflation are moving. Combining the two answers gives four of them.

When growth rises and inflation holds stable or falls, you are in the "good" regime. Firms sell more, their costs stay contained, and central banks see no reason to raise rates hard.

When growth and inflation rise together, you have an economy running hot. Demand is outrunning supply, and central banks begin to lean against it.

When both fall, the economy is in slowdown or recession. Demand softens, prices cool, and central banks lower rates.

When growth falls while inflation rises, the result is stagflation. A supply shock is the usual cause: something pushes prices up and squeezes activity at the same time.

Markets respond to change, so each regime is defined by direction and the level matters less. An economy growing at 3% and slowing belongs in a different regime from one growing at 1% and accelerating, although 3% is the larger figure (an illustrative example, not real data).

What has happened to shares, bonds and real assets

Everything here comes from the record of past decades. These are tendencies, and every regime has had exceptions.

Shares have usually done best with rising growth and stable inflation. Earnings climb, and interest rates do not go up quickly enough to cancel that out. Much of the 1990s and of the decade after 2009 looked like this, and shares did well for most of both periods.

High-quality government bonds have usually done best when growth and inflation are both falling. Central banks cut rates, bond yields drop and bond prices go up, while shares suffer as earnings fall. In late 2008 and again in early 2020, US government bonds rose while shares fell sharply.

When inflation is rising, assets tied to real things have generally come out ahead: commodities, and inflation-linked bonds such as US TIPS, which Lesson 3.3 explains. If strong growth comes with the rising inflation, shares in companies able to raise their prices have often held up as well.

Stagflation has tended to hit shares and bonds in the same stretch, which makes it the most dangerous regime for a typical portfolio. Shares drop because earnings weaken and discount rates go up. Bonds drop because inflation erodes the value of their fixed payments and central banks raise rates where they would otherwise cut.

The 1970s are the classic example. The oil shocks of 1973 and 1979 drove US inflation into double digits as growth stalled, and over much of the decade both shares and bonds lost money after inflation. 2022 was a milder version: inflation reached levels not seen in decades, central banks raised rates fast while growth slowed, and global shares and bonds fell in the same calendar year. Lesson 2.4, "Beta, correlation and why diversification shrinks in a crisis", showed how that year hurt portfolios relying on bonds to cushion shares.

Marcus holds an 80/20 portfolio, with 20% in bonds. Stagflation deserves the most thought from them, since those bonds give the least protection in that regime.

Using regimes to test scenarios

Looking back, naming a regime is easy. Calling one while it is happening is hard. GDP and other growth data come out months late and are revised afterwards; "How the economy hits your wallet: rates, inflation and cycles" and lesson 4.2, "Indicators to watch: GDP, hiring, inflation and the yield curve", go through this. Inflation can change direction fast. And once the data confirms a regime, markets have usually priced in much of it already.

So use the four regimes to organise scenarios, and do not use them to forecast. Asking "which regime are we in, so what should I buy?" is the wrong question. Ask instead: "if we moved into each regime, what would happen to my holdings, and could I live with it?" Work through all four against what you own. Lesson 3.8, "Write a macro dashboard and three scenarios", turns this into a written page.

Checking the indicators and making your call

Judge each indicator by its direction across the past several months:

Growth: GDP growth, a purchasing managers' index and employment data. Singapore's purchasing managers' index comes from the Singapore Institute of Purchasing and Materials Management. Inflation: headline consumer price inflation and core consumer price inflation.

Go to the latest official releases for each, and do not rely on a headline's summary of them. Then place the economy in one of the four regimes.

Expect the indicators to disagree. When Marcus looks, two of their growth indicators are pointing down and inflation is easing, which suggests a slowdown. Hiring data is still firm, though, and that argues against one. Marcus keeps both views in mind at once, which is a normal position to be in.

Write down your own regime call, the evidence for it, and the one piece of data that cuts against it.

Write down the regime you think the economy is in now, two data points that support your view and one that goes against it.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).