The yield curve and what an inversion has and has not predicted

Read the shape of the yield curve and explain the limits of an inversion as a recession signal.

Open the US Treasury's daily yield curve rates, find the two-year and ten-year yields for the latest day, and subtract the two-year figure from the ten-year figure. If the answer is negative, the curve is inverted. You first met the yield curve in the course "How the economy hits your wallet: rates, inflation and cycles", lesson 4.2, "Indicators to watch: GDP, hiring, inflation and the yield curve". An analyst reads more out of it than a single number, starting with what sets each end.

What sets the short end and the long end

The yield curve plots the yields on a government's bonds against their maturity, from bills of a few months to bonds of thirty years. Short yields are anchored by the central bank's policy rate, because a three-month bill is close to cash. If the central bank holds its rate steady, you can't expect a three-month bill to yield much more or less than that rate.

Long yields reflect two things. The first is what investors expect short rates to average over the bond's life. The second is a term premium, the extra return investors want for the risk of holding a long bond, which lesson 2.7 described. Put together, the curve's shape gives you the market's rough view of where policy rates are heading, plus a risk premium that moves on its own.

Measuring the shape with spreads

Analysts summarise the curve's shape as a spread, the difference between yields at two points on the curve. You take the longer-maturity yield minus the shorter-maturity yield. The two most watched US spreads are the ten-year yield minus the two-year yield, called 2s10s, and the ten-year yield minus the three-month yield.

Say you see a two-year yield of 4.5% (an example figure) and a ten-year yield of 4.0%. The 2s10s spread is 4.0 minus 4.5, which is minus 0.5 points. A negative spread means an inverted curve, where short-term yields are above long-term yields.

How the curve changes over time tells you more than one day's snapshot. In bond markets, a bull move means yields fall and prices rise. A bear move means yields rise and prices fall. To read a change, compare how fast short and long yields are moving:

Bull steepening: short yields fall faster than long yields, usually because the market expects rate cuts. The curve steepens from the front. Bear steepening: long yields rise faster than short yields, often on worries about inflation or the supply of bonds. The curve steepens from the back. Bull flattening and bear flattening: the reverse movements of the two above.

What inversions have and haven't predicted

In 2022 Marcus, an investor in Singapore, kept reading every few weeks that the yield curve had inverted and a recession was coming. He trimmed some of his shares and waited. Through 2023 he watched those shares rise without him. The headlines were accurate, since the curve had inverted, but they left out how loose the link between inversion and recession is.

The usual reading of an inversion is that markets expect the central bank to cut rates in future, often because they expect the economy to weaken. Inversions have often come before US recessions. They came before the recessions that began in 2001 and 2008, and in the second case the curve inverted in 2006 and 2007, more than a year before the recession began. In 2019 parts of the US curve inverted briefly and a recession followed in 2020, but that recession was caused by a pandemic no bond market foresaw. When you see the signal's record quoted, the 2019 case counts as a hit, which shows how much luck can be built into it.

The gap between inversion and recession has ranged from several months to around two years, which means you can't use it to time the market. Shares often rise for a long time after the curve inverts, and the fall, when it comes, can start after the curve has already turned positive again.

Parts of the US curve inverted in 2022 and stayed inverted into 2024, an unusually long stretch. A US recession did not follow in the window many forecasters expected, and investors who sold on the inversion, Marcus partly among them, missed a strong rise in shares. One possible explanation is that years of central bank bond buying held long yields down, so the curve looked more inverted than rate expectations alone would have made it.

Treat an inversion as one piece of evidence about the economic regime described in lesson 3.1, "Growth and inflation: four regimes and what tends to do well in each". It raises the odds that markets expect weaker growth and lower rates. It says nothing about timing, and you should not trade on it by itself.

How the SGS curve relates to the US curve

Singapore Government Securities (SGS) have their own curve, from short-dated bills to long bonds, and MAS publishes SGS prices and yields on its website. When US Treasury yields move, you'll usually see SGS yields move closely with them. MAS manages the exchange rate rather than a domestic interest rate, so Singapore rates are largely set by global rates and capital flows. The course "How the economy hits your wallet", lesson 2.1, "Why Singapore interest rates follow the US Fed", explains this in full.

You'll still see the level and shape of the SGS curve differ from the US curve, because Singapore's inflation, the demand for its bonds and expectations for the Singapore dollar differ from America's.

Marcus holds an SGD bond fund of Singapore government and corporate bonds. A rise in long-end SGS yields lowers the value of that fund through duration, the measure of how much a bond's price moves when yields change, set out in lesson 2.5, "Duration is the risk number for bonds". He also holds T-bills, which are short-dated SGS bills, and those, along with any new SGS he buys, are priced off the short end of the SGS curve. A move at either end of the Singapore curve reaches his money by a different route.

Plot today's US Treasury and SGS yield curves from official sources and describe the shape of each in one sentence. Then write two sentences on what an inversion in either curve would and would not tell you about a coming recession.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).