Real rates and breakeven inflation from inflation-linked bonds

Read real yields and breakeven inflation and explain why real rates matter for valuations.

Breakeven inflation is the nominal government bond yield minus the real yield for the same maturity. When real yields go up, assets whose cash arrives far in the future lose the most value.

Marcus holds two things: a share in a US chip designer and a world ETF. Through 2022 the chip designer dropped much further than the ETF, though the company's sales were still growing. A colleague said the cause was "rising real rates". Marcus nodded and never asked what the phrase meant.

Three yields from two kinds of bond

An ordinary government bond promises a fixed sum in dollars. The return it offers is its nominal yield, which tells you nothing about what those dollars will buy on the day you receive them.

An inflation-linked bond raises its principal as prices rise, so each payment holds its purchasing power. The US version is Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), and the adjustment follows the US consumer price index. A TIPS yield is a real yield, meaning the return over and above inflation that you secure by buying the bond and keeping it until it matures.

Subtract the real yield from the nominal yield at the same maturity and you get the breakeven inflation rate. Ten years is the benchmark maturity for all three figures here. Suppose the ten-year Treasury is at 4.2% and the ten-year TIPS is at 1.9%, both invented for the example. Breakeven is 4.2% - 1.9% = 2.3%. Should inflation average above 2.3% a year across those ten years, the TIPS owner finishes ahead. Should it average below, the owner of the ordinary Treasury does.

To do it yourself, find the nominal yield for one maturity, such as the ten-year Treasury, then the TIPS yield for that same maturity, and take the second from the first. Markets quote this plain subtraction as an approximation. The precise link is (1 + nominal yield) = (1 + real yield) x (1 + inflation), which comes from the real return formula in Lesson 1.1, Nominal vs real returns and the geometric mean trap. Solved for inflation, it gives breakeven = (1 + nominal) / (1 + real) - 1.

Why distant profits suffer most when real yields rise

Every asset is worth the cash it is expected to pay later, brought back to a value today. The rate used for that, the discount rate, begins with a risk-free rate and adds a premium for risk. A rise in real yields lifts the starting point, which lowers the present value of every future payment.

The size of the drop depends on timing. Move the discount rate from 6% to 7%, using example rates. A dollar due in two years falls about 1.9% in present value. A dollar due in twenty years falls about 17%.

Lesson 2.5, Duration is the risk number for bonds, set out this idea for bonds, and it carries over to shares. A mature business paying out most of its profit today acts like a short bond. A fast-growing business expecting most of its profit years ahead acts like a long bond, and it takes the biggest hit when rates go up.

Valuing a company as though it grows at a steady pace for ever makes the effect bigger. Under that assumption, value = cash flow / (discount rate - growth rate). Use a cash flow of 100 a year with 4% growth, again example figures. With a 6% discount rate, value is 100 / 0.02 = 5,000. With 7%, value is 100 / 0.03, about 3,333, so one point on the discount rate removed a third of the value. Module 8 works through this method in detail.

In 2022, US real yields climbed from below zero to well above zero. Companies valued mainly on profits far in the future fell the most, and Marcus's chip designer was among them. His world ETF holds mature and growing companies together, so it fell less.

Reading breakevens with two distortions in mind

People often treat breakeven inflation as the market's forecast of inflation. It is close to one, with two distortions to allow for. Buyers of ordinary bonds ask for extra yield as cover against inflation coming in higher than expected, and this inflation risk premium raises breakevens. TIPS are also harder to trade than ordinary Treasuries, more so in a crisis, and this liquidity effect can lower breakevens. Late in 2008, with investors selling whatever they could to raise cash, US breakevens dropped for a short time to levels that implied deflation lasting years.

A breakeven therefore shows what the bond market is pricing, shifted by those premia. Set it against your own view of where inflation is heading and against what the Fed is saying. Breakevens climbing while the Fed says inflation is under control means the market does not fully believe the Fed. Past breakevens have often been far from the inflation that actually followed, so do not use them to predict what will happen.

Where to find the yields

The US Treasury publishes nominal and real yield curve rates every day. FRED, the St. Louis Fed's database, charts the ten-year nominal yield, the ten-year TIPS yield and the ten-year breakeven going back decades.

Look up today's ten-year nominal and real yields from one of those sources, subtract to get breakeven inflation, and compare it with the same calculation from a year earlier.

Look up the current US 10-year nominal and real yields, work out breakeven inflation, and note how it has moved over the past year.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).