Read corporate credit spreads and explain why they widen before or during equity sell-offs.
Share prices are a weak early-warning system for trouble in the economy. They are set by millions of buyers and sellers who react to news, to their moods and to one another, so prices swing for many reasons unrelated to how companies are doing. Bond investors are a duller crowd, and that dullness makes them worth watching. Someone lending to a company has one narrow concern: whether the money comes back.
When lenders start asking for more before they will lend to companies, something underneath is often going wrong, and lenders sometimes see the trouble before shareholders do. You can use this data without holding a single bond.
The gap between a corporate bond's yield and the yield on a government bond maturing at the same time is the credit spread. To get it, subtract the government yield from the corporate yield. Suppose a company's five-year bond yields 6.5% and the five-year US Treasury yields 4.2% (both invented figures). 6.5% minus 4.2% leaves a spread of 2.3 percentage points.
That extra yield pays the lender for three risks: the company failing to repay, the bond being harder to sell, and defaults clustering together in a downturn.
Index providers calculate average spreads across whole groups of bonds. Investment-grade spreads are averages for companies rated BBB- or higher, which are less likely to default. High-yield spreads are averages for companies rated below BBB-, which default more often and so have to pay more. Give the high-yield figures the most attention, because weaker borrowers feel a slowdown first and their spreads react sooner.
FRED, the St. Louis Fed's database, publishes daily US investment-grade and high-yield spread series built on ICE BofA indexes. Check how many years of history it currently shows, and find a second source if you need a longer record.
High-yield spreads and shares both reflect the market's view of company earnings and whether companies will survive. They usually move in step: spreads widen as shares drop and narrow as shares climb. The cases to watch are the ones where they part ways.
In one, spreads creep wider while shares sit near their highs, a sign that lenders are getting uneasy before shareholders. In the other, shares fall hard on some scare while spreads hardly move, which suggests the bond market sees no real threat to companies' ability to pay. Neither pattern is dependable enough to trade on, though either is worth writing down.
During 2008, high-yield spreads rose to levels that assumed a wave of defaults, and defaults did climb sharply the next year. In March 2020, spreads shot up within weeks as the pandemic closed economies. On 23 March 2020 the Fed said it would buy corporate bonds for the first time, and spreads started falling almost at once, well before the economy had recovered.
A spread shows the price lenders are asking. Bank lending surveys and funding-market data show whether credit is flowing at all.
Bank lending surveys ask loan officers whether they are tightening or easing their standards for borrowers. The Federal Reserve runs the US version, the Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey, each quarter, and MAS and other central banks release their own credit data. As more banks report tightening, companies and households struggle to borrow, and spending usually slows a few quarters on.
Funding markets are where banks and other large institutions lend to one another for days or weeks. Most of the time nobody outside them notices they exist; under stress they lock up. In 2008 banks lost confidence that other banks would repay, and short-term interbank borrowing costs rose far above the policy rate. In March 2020 even the US Treasury market, often described as the deepest in the world, could not absorb the selling until the Fed stepped in. Unusually wide gaps between short-term borrowing rates and the policy rate, and other signs of funding strain, are among the earliest warnings that a sell-off may turn into a crisis.
Every indicator jumps at times for reasons that have nothing to do with the economy: a large bond issue, a quarter-end, or trouble confined to one sector. Reacting to each jump means trading much too often and being wrong most of the time. Wider spreads, tighter bank standards and strained funding markets showing up together carry far more information than any one of them. Lesson 3.1, "Growth and inflation: four regimes and what tends to do well in each", applies the same principle in its regime check, which looks for separate pieces of evidence pointing the same way.
A workable routine:
Track high-yield spreads as the more sensitive measure. Set spreads beside share prices and note any disagreement without trading on it. Read the latest bank lending survey for tightening or easing. Look for funding strain, such as wide gaps between short-term borrowing rates and the policy rate. Treat one indicator moving as noise and several moving together as the real signal. When that signal appears, review your written rules and your cash and bond holdings instead of placing trades.
Marcus, an example investor, owns no high-yield bonds and follows their spreads anyway. They keep one high-yield spread series on the macro dashboard from Lesson 3.8 and never trade off it. Marcus uses it to decide when to reread their written investing rules and to confirm that their cash and bond holdings would cover what they might need in a bad year.
For the activity, find the ICE BofA US high-yield spread series on FRED, note where today's reading sits within its range over the past ten years, and write one sentence on what that position says about how worried lenders are.
Find a published high-yield spread series, compare its current level with its ten-year range and write down what that suggests.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).