Read the Fed's projections without treating them as promises

Read the Fed's dot plot and explain why market pricing and the Fed's own projections often differ.

Read the Fed's dot plot as a record of how officials are thinking, set it beside the rate path priced in futures markets, and pay attention to the distance between the two. Neither path is a forecast of where rates will end up.

For a while, Marcus took every headline about the dots as a timetable for rate moves. Then Marcus pulled up an old chart to see how it had turned out. In December 2021, the median dot for the end of 2022 sat below 1%. When 2022 ended, the Fed's target range was 4.25% to 4.5%. A projection made only twelve months earlier was out by more than three percentage points, and after seeing that gap Marcus stopped reading the dots as a schedule.

How the dots are drawn and read

The dot plot sits inside the Fed's Summary of Economic Projections, or SEP. Of the Fed's eight scheduled policy meetings each year, four are followed by an SEP: March, June, September and December, so fresh dots appear four times a year.

Every participant in the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), meaning the governors plus the regional Fed presidents, places a dot for the federal funds rate they consider appropriate at the end of each of the next few years, and for the longer run. A dot is one person's view of policy, built on that person's own forecast for the economy. The dots are neither votes nor a decision by the committee, and Fed chairs have told press conferences that they do not amount to a committee plan.

News reports pick the median dot for each year, the one in the middle, and usually turn it into a count of cuts or hikes that are "coming". Reading the dots as a schedule in that way is the error to avoid.

The longer-run dots mark where participants expect the rate to settle when the economy is in balance, which is their estimate of the neutral rate. If that estimate shifts, the line between a "high" rate and a "low" one shifts with it.

The SEP also carries projections for growth, unemployment and inflation, and you should read them with the dots. Median dots pointing to cuts, paired with falling projected inflation, fit together. Dots pointing to cuts while projected inflation climbs are a mismatch worth writing down. Check how scattered the dots are as well: when they sit far apart, the committee is unsure of itself and surprises become more likely.

Setting the dots beside the futures path

Futures markets build a separate rate path. Traders deal in contracts whose value rests on the federal funds rate at future dates, and the prices of those contracts imply a path, called the futures-implied path. CME Group's FedWatch tool turns the prices into probabilities meeting by meeting, and many financial news sites display the implied path.

The two paths often part ways. The dots describe what officials expect to do if their own forecasts prove right. The futures path describes what traders expect the Fed to actually do, weighted by the odds that the economy goes another way, with a small risk premium on top.

When the market prices in more cuts than the dots, traders are betting on a weaker economy than the Fed projects, or on the Fed blinking. When it prices in fewer cuts, traders doubt the Fed will follow through. Neither path has a reliable record. The gap itself is what you can use, because it marks where the market and the Fed disagree and so where the next surprise is most likely to come from.

Why the dots make a poor forecast

Missed dots are routine. Each dot rests on forecasts of growth and inflation, which carry large errors a year or two ahead. For years after the 2008 crisis, the dots kept showing faster rate rises than the Fed delivered.

An investor who bought long-dated bonds in early 2022 on the strength of a gentle dot path would have absorbed the full 2022 bond losses, which Lesson 2.7, "Risk premia: what you are paid to hold equity, term, credit and illiquidity", covers.

Keep the dots out of rate forecasting and out of decisions about when to buy bonds, and avoid building any holding around a set number of cuts. Use them to see:

whether officials treat inflation or growth as the bigger risk whether their view of the neutral rate is shifting how far apart they are from one another

What you want is a sense of which way the reaction function points and what would move it, rather than a date. Lesson 3.4, "Central bank reaction functions: the Fed and MAS", takes the same approach to the Fed's own statements.

Marcus now keeps the dots on a macro dashboard purely for context. The cost of a rate move comes from the bond fund's duration, covered in lesson 2.5. The dots and the futures path tell Marcus which direction officials and traders lean, and how wide the distance between them is.

Working through a new release

Open the latest dot plot on the Federal Reserve website. Note the median dot for each year and the longer-run dots that give the neutral-rate estimate. Read the growth, unemployment and inflation projections and check they tell one consistent story with the dots, then note how widely the dots spread as a reading of committee uncertainty. Find the futures-implied path, for instance on CME FedWatch, and locate where the two paths differ most. Treat the result as context on direction and disagreement, never as a forecast or a trading signal.

For the activity, open the latest dot plot on the Federal Reserve's website and pull up the futures-implied path from a source such as CME FedWatch. Write down the year-end rate each one shows and where the gap between them is largest.

Put the median path from the latest dot plot next to the rate path priced in futures and note where the two differ.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).