You will be able to judge whether a geopolitical event is likely to change long-term earnings or only short-term prices.
Find your investment policy statement, the written rules you set for your portfolio, and copy out the rebalancing band for each asset class you hold, with your current allocation beside it. A rebalancing band is the range around a target weight that you allow before you rebalance. When a war, a sanction or a vote is leading the news, you will need those numbers and a few questions about the shock to decide what to do, and it helps to have them ready before the news starts.
Every geopolitical shock arrives with the feeling that this time is different and everything will change. Sometimes a shock does change everything. More often, markets fall hard and then recover within months, once the range of possible outcomes narrows.
Uncertainty on its own pushes prices down. When nobody knows how bad an event will get, investors want a bigger discount before they will hold risky assets, so prices fall far enough to allow for the worst case. That extra margin is the uncertainty discount. As the picture clears, the worst case usually drops away, even if the news is bad, and some of the discount goes with it.
Several past shocks show this pattern. After the attacks of 11 September 2001, US stock markets closed for several trading days and fell sharply when they reopened. The main US indexes were back above their pre-attack levels within a few months. After Iraq invaded Kuwait in August 1990, shares fell for months, then rallied strongly once the US-led air campaign began in January 1991, as described in Lesson 4.1, How geopolitical shocks reach prices. Many smaller scares, such as missile tests and border clashes, barely register in prices a year later.
The shocks that stay in prices are the ones that change what businesses earn. A lasting shock usually travels through one of three channels: energy supply, trade routes and rules, or capital access.
On energy supply, the 1973 oil embargo raised energy costs for years and changed which industries and countries prospered. Lesson 4.2, Energy markets and OPEC+ decisions as a market input, covers it. More recently, Europe's loss of cheap Russian gas after 2022 permanently raised costs for some energy-intensive manufacturers.
On trade, when tariffs or export controls stay in place, supply chains are rebuilt around them, and the companies that won keep winning while the ones that lost keep losing. Lessons 4.3 and 4.4 look at who sits on each side.
Capital access is the harshest of the three. In March 2022, sanctions and capital controls, which are limits on moving money into or out of a country, made Russian shares impossible for foreign investors to trade. MSCI, the index provider, removed Russia from its emerging markets indexes at a price of effectively zero. Foreign investors who held Russian shares through index funds lost that part of their holdings outright, and no recovery followed for them because they could no longer own the assets.
Currency moves are a quieter form of lasting shock. After the UK voted for Brexit in June 2016, the FTSE 100, an index of the 100 largest companies listed in London, fell and then recovered within days, measured in pounds. Part of that recovery came from the many multinationals in the index that earn abroad. The pound fell to its lowest level against the US dollar in more than three decades and stayed low for years. If you measured your returns in Singapore dollars, you had a loss that stuck, and the UK index never showed it.
Selling after a shock can feel like taking control. Behavioural Finance: why you make the money mistakes you make, lesson 6.3, Recent returns, hot tips and the crowd, explains why the urge is so strong. A sale commits you to two decisions where holding needed one: when to sell and when to buy back.
You make the sell decision at the moment of greatest fear, usually after much of the fall has already happened. The buy-back decision has no natural trigger. The news rarely announces that it is safe to come back, and prices often recover before the headlines improve.
Take an index that falls 12% in the month after a shock and then rises 15% over the following eleven months (example figures). 0.88 times 1.15 is 1.012, so a year on, the index stands about 1% above where it started. If you sold at the bottom of the first month and waited for things to "settle", you would have had to buy back at higher prices to end up where you began. So before selling on a headline, check that your reason would still hold a year later.
When a shock hits, sort it using the questions from this module:
Which channels is the shock travelling through? Does it change energy supply, trade routes or capital access for the companies you own, or is it mostly uncertainty? Has anything happened to your own need for cash?
If the shock is mostly uncertainty, your written rules decide what you do. In Build and run an ETF portfolio, lesson 8.2, Rules for when markets fall and when they boom, you wrote an investment policy statement that says how and when to rebalance. If the shock has pushed your allocation outside its bands, rebalance as those rules set out. You wrote them on a calm day for a week like this one.
If the earnings of one of your holdings have changed for years, review that holding properly through a thesis review, and leave the decision until the review is done instead of selling in a panic on the day. Lesson 11.4, Thesis review instead of price stops, shows how to run one.
Pick one past shock, compare how far the market fell in the first month with where it stood a year later, and decide whether the shock changed earnings through energy supply, trade routes or capital access, or was mostly uncertainty.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).