Describe how an order travels from your broker to an exchange, and who takes the other side of the trade.
Every share you buy comes from a seller. Your broker holds none of the shares you buy, even though the app can make it feel as if it sold them to you. The seller is another party, and it sells at a price it picked, for its own reasons.
Marcus, an invented investor, wants shares in a small chip supplier listed on SGX. He taps buy on 5,000 shares, and a second later his app says filled. He thinks he bought them from the app, but someone else sold them to him at a price they chose. His company is called Larkspur Precision from here on. It's an invented firm, modelled on the small SGX precision engineers that supply parts to chip equipment makers.
Module 5 covers who that seller is, what it charges you, and what its behaviour can tell you. The separate course Investing 101: from zero to your first ETF covers opening an account, board lots, and how a basic limit order differs from a market order. Investing 101 lesson 6.2, "Limit orders, market orders and the bid-ask spread", follows a market order as it climbs the ask levels. Lesson 6.3, "After you click buy: settlement, contract notes and your CDP statement", covers what happens after the fill. Module 5 starts where lessons 6.2 and 6.3 stop. It asks what the order book can show you about the cost of a trade while you can still change your order.
First, your broker checks that you have enough cash for a purchase, or enough shares for a sale. Second, the broker passes the order to a trading venue. An order for an SGX-listed stock goes to SGX's own market. An order for a US stock could go to any one of many venues.
At an exchange, the order arrives at the order book, the list of buy and sell orders sitting at each price until someone trades with them. SGX matches orders by price first and time second. When two orders sit at the same price, the one placed earlier fills first.
A buy order priced at or above the best ask fills straight away against the sellers already waiting, as long as its quantity is no more than what rests there. A buy order priced below the best ask is added to the book. It waits there until a seller is willing to come down to that price.
The bid is the highest price a buyer is offering. The ask is the lowest price a seller will accept. Depth is the number of shares waiting at each price level. The last Larkspur trade was at S$1.60 (an example figure), and the book shows these levels:
Asks: 4,000 shares at S$1.61; 6,000 shares at S$1.62; 10,000 shares at S$1.63 Bids: 12,000 shares at S$1.59; 20,000 shares at S$1.58; 15,000 shares at S$1.57
A buy from Marcus at S$1.61 for 4,000 shares or fewer goes through immediately. A bid at S$1.60 would sit in the book until a seller came down to S$1.60.
Each order in the book was placed on purpose by someone. When you trade against it, you accept the terms that person set. The seller who placed 4,000 shares at S$1.61 judged S$1.61 a good enough price to sell at.
The 4,000 shares at the best ask decide whether Marcus's order fills at one price or at three. Depth makes little difference for a large bank stock and a big one for a thin stock like Larkspur.
Some orders in a book come from ordinary investors. Others come from a market maker, a firm that shows a bid and an ask at the same time and will trade with you in either direction. Most ETFs on SGX have a designated market maker. Big market-making firms quote prices in US stocks throughout the trading day.
A market maker earns the spread, the gap between the bid and the ask. On Larkspur, a market maker might buy at S$1.59 and sell at S$1.61, keeping two cents on each share (S$1.61 - S$1.59 = two cents). On a good day it buys from one customer at the bid, sells to a different customer at the ask, and keeps the gap. On a bad day it buys from a seller who knows something it doesn't, and the price keeps dropping. The spread pays the market maker for taking that risk.
The risk rises when a stock rarely trades, when its price moves sharply, or when the company is about to report results. Spreads are therefore wide on thinly traded stocks and in the minutes before news comes out, and narrow on large companies that trade heavily.
The exchange does not set the spread as a charge. It is what you pay to trade immediately instead of waiting, and its size is set by whoever is prepared to stand between buyers and sellers.
US stocks trade on many competing exchanges and also on venues outside the exchanges. US rules say a broker must seek best execution for its customers. A US trade generally can't take place at a price worse than the best bid and ask shown across the exchanges taken together, known as the national best bid and offer.
Many US retail brokers don't send customer orders to an exchange. They pass them to a wholesaler, a large market-making firm that fills the orders from its own inventory. Some of these brokers are paid by the wholesaler for sending them, which is called payment for order flow.
The wholesaler pays because retail orders are small and, on average, aren't based on information it lacks. It can earn a thin spread on them with less risk than it would face on the open exchange. As the customer, you usually get filled at the national best price or slightly better, and a fill slightly better is called price improvement.
Critics say payment for order flow gives the broker a reason to send orders where it gets paid, which may not be where you get the best price. Supporters say the payments are what make low or zero commissions possible. You don't need to decide who is right, only to understand how the arrangement works.
Each broker publishes an order routing disclosure that says where its US orders go and what it receives for them. If you hold your US account through a Singapore broker, your order may go to a US partner firm first. Read your broker's order routing disclosure once.
Before every order, Marcus now opens the full depth screen instead of looking only at the last price. He writes down how many shares are waiting at the best bid and the best ask. With those two numbers he can judge whether his order will fill at one price level or across several.
Many broker apps show several levels of depth for SGX stocks and at least the best bid and ask for US stocks. The course comes back to Larkspur from module 6 onwards, reading its accounts, building a model of it, and putting a value on it.
During trading hours, open both screens, one for an SGX stock and one for a US stock, and write down what you see on each.
In your broker, open the order book for one SGX stock and one US stock. For each, write down the best bid, the best ask and the depth.
Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).