Order types beyond limit and market, and when each helps

Pick a limit, stop, stop-limit or auction order to suit a given trade.

When prices move slowly, almost any order type gets you close to the price you expected. Problems start in a fast market, such as when news breaks overnight, or in a thin stock, where few buyers and sellers wait at each price. In those conditions an order can behave very differently from how it looked when you placed it. Every order type trades off two things: getting filled and controlling the price. To choose well, you need to know which of the two you are giving up, and when.

The course "Investing 101: from zero to your first ETF" covers limit and market orders. The basic stop order is explained in lesson 6.2, "Market, limit and stop orders, and when each one hurts", in the course "Investing in US and global markets from Singapore". What follows assumes you know those basics.

How a stop order fills when the price drops fast

A stop order waits until the price touches a trigger level, then becomes a market order. Once triggered, it fills at whatever price is available, like any market order. When prices move smoothly, this works fine. It fails in two situations.

The first is a gap. The stock closes at one price and opens far lower after news, so the first available price is well below your trigger. The second is a thin book, meaning an order book with little size at each price level. A large triggered stop works down through the bid levels, so your average fill ends up below the trigger.

Take the Larkspur order book from lesson 5.1, "Exchanges, market makers and how your order gets filled". Larkspur is an invented SGX stock with bids of 12,000 shares at S$1.59, 20,000 at S$1.58 and 15,000 at S$1.57. Say a stop to sell 40,000 shares triggers at S$1.59. It fills 12,000 at S$1.59 (S$19,080), 20,000 at S$1.58 (S$31,600) and 8,000 at S$1.57 (S$12,560). That comes to S$63,240 for 40,000 shares, or S$1.581 each, about S$1.58. On a morning when buyers have pulled their bids, the same stop can fill far lower than that.

Stops can also trigger on noise. A brief dip in a thin stock can touch your stop level and sell a holding you meant to keep, and then the price recovers without you.

Marcus has a friend who held bank shares in March 2020, with a stop order about 10% below the purchase price. One morning the market opened sharply lower and the stop triggered. The shares sold several percent below the stop level the friend had chosen. A week later the price was back above that level. The friend had bought protection against a gradual fall and instead got a forced sale near the worst moment of the month.

What a stop-limit order changes, and what it costs

A stop-limit order has two prices: a trigger and a limit. When it is triggered, it becomes a limit order, so it sells only at the limit price or better and never below. As an invented example, a stop-limit with a trigger at S$1.50 and a limit at S$1.45 sells at S$1.45 or better.

The cost is that it may not fill at all. If the stock gaps from S$1.60 to S$1.40, the S$1.45 limit sits above the market and nothing happens. You keep the shares, which is the outcome you were trying to avoid. A stop-limit protects you from a terrible fill, but it leaves you holding the risk during the very move you most feared.

Neither kind of stop fixes the underlying problem: any price-based exit lets the price decide when you sell. Module 11 argues for deciding when to sell based on evidence, in lesson 11.4, "Thesis review instead of price stops".

How auctions set a single price

Many exchanges open and close the trading day with an auction instead of continuous trading. During the auction period, orders are collected but not matched. At the end, the exchange finds the single price at which the most shares can trade, and every matched order fills at that one price. SGX runs a pre-open phase before the morning session and a pre-close phase before the end of the day. US exchanges also run opening and closing auctions. Check SGX's website for the current phases and timings instead of relying on a schedule from course notes.

The closing auction matters most. Index funds value their holdings at the closing price, so they tend to trade at the close to match it. You will meet these funds properly in lesson 5.4, "Index construction and what inclusion does to a stock". Their trading puts a large share of the day's volume into a few minutes.

That helps an individual investor in two ways. A larger order meets more opposite orders at the close than it would at 11 in the morning, so it moves the price less. Also, everyone gets one price, so your order does not climb through levels of the book the way a market order does. The risk is that the auction price itself can swing if order flow at the close is lopsided. Send a limit order into the auction rather than an at-market order, and set the limit at a price you would still be content with.

Choosing an order type and timing for the trade

For a routine purchase of a busy ETF or a large stock, use a limit order at or near the ask during the middle of the session, after the opening minutes have passed. For a larger order in a thin stock such as Larkspur, place a limit order into the closing auction or split the order over several days. Either usually costs less than one big order during the day. If you want an automatic exit, prefer a stop-limit over a plain stop, knowing it may not fill. Better still, write down the evidence that would make you sell and review it on a schedule. For any order left overnight, check whether it is a day order or good till cancelled, and look at your open orders list each time you log in.

Checking what your broker offers on each market

Brokers do not offer the same tools on every market. A broker may support stop-limit orders on US stocks but not on SGX, or allow orders into the SGX closing auction but not the US one. Some brokers offer stops only as simulated orders. A simulated stop sits on the broker's own system and is sent to the exchange only when triggered, which changes how fast it reacts.

When Marcus checked his broker's order tools, he found it allowed limit orders in the SGX pre-close phase but offered stop orders only on US stocks. That changed his plan for adding to Larkspur, and he now places his Larkspur purchases as limit orders in the closing auction.

Find out what your broker supports on a calm afternoon, well before the day you need it. Open your broker's order screen for one SGX stock and one US stock. On each, list every order type it lets you choose, including stop, stop-limit, auction access and whether stops are simulated.

List the order types your broker offers on SGX and on a US exchange. Next to each, write one situation where you would use it.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).