Spreads, depth and market impact on small and large stocks

Estimate the full cost of a trade, counting the spread and how far your own order moves the price.

Before your next trade, open your trading app and write down the bid and the ask for a stock you hold or are thinking of buying. The gap between them is a cost you pay on every trade, and it never appears as a line item on a statement or contract note.

Commission is the visible cost of trading. The spread, market impact and slippage are the invisible costs, built into the prices you buy and sell at. On small stocks, the invisible costs are usually bigger than the commission.

Marcus, the investor you have been following through this course, learned this on a small SGX stock. His app showed S$1.60 when he bought and S$1.60 when he sold two weeks later, yet he lost money after commission. He had bought at the ask and sold at the bid, and the spread on that stock was more than twice his commission.

Working out the spread as a percentage of price

The spread is the ask minus the bid. In cents it means little by itself. As a percentage of price, it shows roughly what a round trip, buying and later selling, costs you before commission.

Use the midpoint, the price halfway between bid and ask, as the fair reference price. Buying at the ask costs you half the spread above the midpoint, and selling at the bid costs the other half below it, so a round trip costs about one full spread. To get the percentage, note the bid and ask, subtract the bid from the ask, find the midpoint, and divide the spread by the midpoint.

Take three quotes Marcus could see at the same time of day. His local bank shares show a bid of S$31.99 and an ask of S$32.00, a spread of one cent, about 0.03% of price. His US chip designer shows a bid of US$149.98 and an ask of US$150.02, a spread of four cents, also under 0.03%. Larkspur, the small SGX supplier from Lesson 5.1, shows a bid of S$1.59 and an ask of S$1.61, a spread of two cents, or 1.25% of price.

A round trip in Larkspur costs about 1.25% before commission, against about 0.03% for the bank. Four Larkspur round trips a year and the spread alone costs about 5% of the money involved. Frequent round trips in a wide-spread stock can cost more than many years of fund fees.

Spreads change during the day. They are usually widest just after the open and often narrower in the middle of the session. They can widen before results or news, and they widen in a sell-off because market makers want more pay for the risk. A sell-off is also when many investors decide to trade.

Estimating market impact from the order book

The spread only measures the cost of an order small enough to fit inside the best bid or ask. A larger order eats through several price levels, and the extra cost of doing that is market impact.

Say Larkspur's order book (invented) shows 4,000 shares offered at S$1.61, 6,000 at S$1.62 and 10,000 at S$1.63. A market order for 5,000 shares takes all 4,000 at S$1.61 plus 1,000 at S$1.62, for S$8,060, an average of about S$1.612. At the midpoint those shares are worth S$8,000, so the cost is S$60 above the midpoint, about 0.75%.

A 20,000-share market order climbs all three levels: S$6,440 + S$9,720 + S$16,300 = S$32,460, an average of about S$1.623. Against the midpoint, the cost is S$460, about 1.4%. Making the order four times bigger nearly doubled the cost per dollar traded, so size raises the cost per dollar as well as the total.

To estimate impact yourself, read the order book levels on the side you will trade against and fill your order level by level until the full quantity is covered. Add up the cost and divide by the number of shares for the average price. Compare the total with shares times the midpoint, and express the difference as a percentage.

The visible book is not the whole story. Once sellers notice a large buyer, some raise their prices or pull their orders. For a rough check, compare your order size with the depth at the best price and with the stock's average daily volume. If your order is more than a small slice of either, expect impact. In a large, busy stock it is tiny: an order of a few thousand dollars in a large bank stock barely touches the first price level. On SGX small caps, impact can be the largest cost you pay.

Recording a decision price to measure slippage

Slippage is the gap between the price when you decided to trade and the price you actually got. It includes the spread, market impact, and any price move while you hesitated, waited for the open or left a limit order sitting.

On Friday night, Marcus decides to buy Larkspur at its last price of S$1.60. His market order fills on Monday at an average of S$1.623, giving 2.3 cents a share of slippage, partly from the order book and partly from the market moving over the weekend.

How slippage splits between those parts matters less than the habit of writing down the decision price before you trade, then comparing your average fill price with it afterwards. If you don't record the decision price, you will remember the price you got as the price you meant.

Slippage can be negative. A limit order below the market that fills after a dip gets a better price than the decision price, which is the point of a limit order. The cost of limit orders is the trades that never fill.

Splitting orders, limit orders and the closing auction

The standard way to reduce impact is to split a large order into smaller limit orders placed over time, each small enough to fit within the available depth. Marcus could place his 20,000 Larkspur shares as four limit orders of 5,000 shares over several days, each at or near the ask. Each might cost close to the spread instead of climbing the book.

Splitting has its own costs: the price may move away while you wait, and some orders may not fill. Professional trading desks put a lot of effort into balancing impact against delay, and you face a simple version of the same trade-off. If you are adding to a long-term holding, a few days' delay rarely matters as much as paying 1.4% in impact. If you are reacting to news everyone else has already seen, the price may run before you finish a split order.

The closing auction is another option for large orders, because more opposite orders arrive at the same moment. Lesson 5.2, "Order types beyond limit and market, and when each helps", explains how it works.

After working through these figures, Marcus wrote a rule in his workbook: in an SGX small cap, any order larger than the shares available at the best price goes in as limit orders, either split over time or placed into the closing auction.

Now check the same thing on your own screens, at one time of day, for three very different stocks.

At the same time of day, work out the spread as a percentage of the price for an STI stock, a small SGX stock and a large US stock, and compare them.

Course

Junxiong-WFG Organisation is an authorised representative of AIA Financial Advisers Private Limited (Reg. No. 201715016G).